The stove isn’t just hot in Baltimore right now; it’s basically glowing orange.
If you’ve been following the MLB rumors Baltimore Orioles fans are obsessing over this January, you know the vibe has shifted. Gone are the days of the "wait and see" approach. David Rubenstein’s ownership era has officially kicked down the door, and the recent $155 million splash for Pete Alonso proved this isn't your older brother's rebuild anymore.
But here’s the thing: everyone is looking at the home run totals, while the real drama is brewing in the starting rotation and the arbitration room.
The Rotation Isn't Finished (And Everyone Knows It)
Let’s be real. Even after bringing back Zach Eflin on a fresh deal and snagging Shane Baz from the Rays, the O’s rotation looks a bit... fragile? That might be the right word. You’ve got Kyle Bradish and Trevor Rogers coming off seasons where health was a constant question mark.
Mike Elias basically confirmed the team is still hunting. He told reporters recently that he’s being "judicious" but still assessing opportunities before the buses head to Sarasota.
The names circling the rumor mill right now? Framber Valdez and Ranger Suarez.
Honestly, the Valdez talk makes a ton of sense if the Orioles want a true "horse" to pair with Eflin. Valdez is a groundball machine, and with the way the O’s defense is set up, he’d be a nightmare for AL East hitters. But the cost? It’s going to hurt.
👉 See also: Meaning of Grand Slam: Why We Use It for Tennis, Baseball, and Breakfast
Is Freddy Peralta the "Corbin Burnes 2.0" Move?
There is a growing whispers—and some solid logic from folks like Joel Reuter at Bleacher Report—that the Orioles might pivot back to their favorite trade partner: the Milwaukee Brewers.
Freddy Peralta is entering the final year of his contract. He’s owed $8 million in 2026. Does that sound familiar? It’s the exact blueprint Elias used to land Corbin Burnes.
The Brewers are famous for trading stars a year early rather than losing them for nothing. If the Orioles decide the free-agent price for someone like Max Fried or even a late-offseason gamble on Justin Verlander is too high, Peralta is the guy.
The projected trade package floating around involves names like Dylan Beavers and Cade Povich. Losing Povich would sting given his flashes of brilliance, but you have to give up talent to get a frontline starter.
The Coby Mayo Conundrum
We need to talk about Coby Mayo. He’s the elephant in the room.
With Pete Alonso locked in at first base for the next five years and Gunnar Henderson and Jordan Westburg anchoring the left side of the dirt, where does Mayo go?
✨ Don't miss: NFL Week 5 2025 Point Spreads: What Most People Get Wrong
Some scouts think he’s a future All-Star. Others worry he’s a "man without a position" in Baltimore. This makes him the ultimate trade chip. If the Orioles go "all-in" for a top-tier pitcher before Spring Training, Mayo is likely the centerpiece of that deal.
It’s a terrifying thought for fans who want to see the "Baby Birds" grow up together, but that’s the price of a championship window.
The $8.5 Million Elephant: Gunnar’s Contract
The Orioles just dodged a bullet—or at least a headache—by agreeing to an $8.5 million deal with Gunnar Henderson to avoid arbitration.
It’s a record for a first-year arb-eligible player in Baltimore.
While that’s great news for 2026, it also highlights the ticking clock. Adley Rutschman also settled at $7.25 million. These numbers are only going up.
A lot of the MLB rumors Baltimore Orioles fans are hearing about "financial flexibility" hinge on whether or not they can lock Gunnar into a long-term extension now. If they wait until next winter, that $8.5 million could easily double if he has another MVP-caliber season.
🔗 Read more: Bethany Hamilton and the Shark: What Really Happened That Morning
What’s Actually Happening with the Bullpen?
While everyone is staring at the starters, the back end of the game is where the Orioles quietly made a massive move.
Ryan Helsley is in the building.
Pairing Helsley with a returning Felix Bautista (once he's fully cleared) gives Baltimore arguably the most terrifying 8th and 9th inning combo in baseball. But there’s still a hole. The middle relief is currently a collection of "if" and "maybe."
Don't be surprised if Elias snagged another high-leverage arm on a one-year "prove it" deal. Think along the lines of a veteran who can bridge the gap to the big guns.
Actionable Insights for the Rest of the Offseason
If you're trying to keep track of where this roster is heading before Opening Day, keep these three things in your peripheral vision:
- Watch the 40-man crunch: The Orioles have a massive "Rule 5" headache coming up in December 2026. They have too many good prospects and not enough spots. This almost guarantees a 2-for-1 or 3-for-1 trade is coming before the trade deadline, if not sooner.
- The "Lefty" Factor: Aside from Trevor Rogers, the rotation is very right-handed heavy. This is why the Framber Valdez and Ranger Suarez rumors won't die. Expect Elias to prioritize a southpaw.
- The Bench Shuffle: With Taylor Ward now in the mix (acquired from the Angels), the outfield is crowded. Ryan Mountcastle’s name has surfaced in trade talks because his $6.87 million salary is a lot for a bench bat/occasional DH.
The reality is that the Orioles are no longer the "scrappy underdogs." They are the predators in the AL East. Whether they land one more ace or decide to trust their internal depth, the moves made in the next three weeks will dictate if they are just "good" or "World Series favorites."
Keep an eye on the waiver wire and the late-night trade leaks. Elias usually moves in silence, but in 2026, the Orioles are making way too much noise to stay quiet for long.
Check the spring training invite list as soon as it drops. If a guy like Coby Mayo or Cade Povich isn't on it, or if there's a sudden 40-man vacancy, you’ll know the "big one" is finally happening.