Betting on a baseball manager is a weird science. You aren't really betting on who the "best" strategist is—if that were the case, Bruce Bochy would have a shelf full of these trophies instead of just one from 1996. No, when you look at the MLB Manager of the Year odds, you’re actually betting on a narrative. You are wagering on which team is going to shatter expectations so loudly that the writers have no choice but to notice.
Honestly, 2026 is shaping up to be a total circus for this award. We just came off a year where Stephen Vogt and Pat Murphy both repeated as winners. That basically never happens. Now, the market is resetting, and a massive wave of new hires has completely scrambled the board.
The Fresh Blood Dominating the American League
If you want to understand where the smart money is going, look at Baltimore. The Orioles just handed the keys to Craig Albernaz, and the hype is already getting a bit out of control.
Albernaz spent the last couple of years as the right-hand man for Stephen Vogt in Cleveland. He’s basically the "Manager of the Year" whisperer at this point. Considering the Orioles just went out and grabbed Pete Alonso and Ryan Helsley this winter, the stage is set for a massive "bounce back" narrative after their rough 2025. When a team with that much talent underachieves one year and explodes the next, the new manager almost always gets the credit.
But he’s not the only one.
Skip Schumaker is now in Texas. He’s already won this award once with the Marlins (2023), and the voters clearly love his "player's manager" vibe. Replacing a legend like Bochy is a tall order, but if the Rangers claw back into the postseason after a mediocre 81-81 finish last year, Schumaker will be the betting favorite by July.
👉 See also: Sammy Sosa Before and After Steroids: What Really Happened
Then there's the chaos in Toronto. John Schneider nearly won the award last year, finishing second to Vogt. The Blue Jays are projected to have arguably the best rotation in the league with Kevin Gausman and Shane Bieber. If they finally win the AL East, Schneider’s odds—which are usually pretty generous in the preseason—will evaporate quickly.
National League: A College Experiment and a Pirate Ship
The Senior Circuit is even weirder. The San Francisco Giants did something nobody saw coming: they hired Tony Vitello straight out of the University of Tennessee.
A college coach moving directly to a Big League dugout without a day of pro experience? That’s unheard of.
If Vitello even sniffs a Wild Card spot, he’s winning the award. It’s the perfect story. The media will eat up the "college guy conquers MLB" angle. Right now, he’s a high-risk, high-reward play in the odds market, mostly because nobody knows if his fiery personality will translate to a 162-game grind.
Over in Pittsburgh, Don Kelly is becoming a trendy long-shot pick. The Pirates have been "two years away" for about five years now, but with Paul Skenes looking like a perennial Cy Young candidate, the window is officially open. If Kelly is the one to finally lead the Bucs back to October, he’ll be a lock.
✨ Don't miss: Saint Benedict's Prep Soccer: Why the Gray Bees Keep Winning Everything
Why the Favorites Often Fail
You've got to be careful with the "safe" picks. Historically, this award hates the status quo.
- Voter Fatigue: Stephen Vogt winning three in a row is statistically improbable. No one has ever done it.
- The "Best Team" Trap: Dave Roberts (Dodgers) and Rob Thomson (Phillies) manage juggernauts. Unless they win 115 games, people just assume the roster won the games, not the manager.
- The Injury Factor: A manager’s odds can die in April if their ace goes down with Tommy John.
How to Actually Read the Odds
When you see the opening lines, don't just look for the best teams. Look for the teams that were bad last year but have a high ceiling. The "Abyss to October" path is the most reliable way to win this trophy.
The 2025 voting showed us that voters value late-season surges. Cleveland erased a 15.5-game deficit to win their division, which is why Vogt took home the hardware despite a mediocre batting average from his lineup.
Actionable Betting Insights for 2026
If you’re looking to place a wager before Opening Day, keep these specific scenarios in mind:
1. Monitor the "New Manager" Premium
Nine teams changed managers this offseason. Historically, a significant chunk of MOY winners are in their first or second year with a club. Albernaz (Orioles) and Schumaker (Rangers) are the primary targets here.
🔗 Read more: Ryan Suter: What Most People Get Wrong About the NHL's Ultimate Survivor
2. Watch the AL East Chaos
The Blue Jays, Orioles, and Yankees are all projected to be elite. If one of them runs away with the division, that manager is the frontrunner. If they all beat each other up and win 88 games, the award will likely go to a Central or West manager who overachieved.
3. The Vitello Factor
Keep a very close eye on San Francisco’s clubhouse chemistry in Spring Training. If the veterans buy into Vitello's system, his +1500 or +2000 opening odds will look like a steal by May.
4. The Long Shot
Keep an eye on Blake Butera in Washington. He’s only 33 years old. If the Nationals' young core finally clicks and they play .500 ball, the "youngest manager in 50 years" narrative will carry a lot of weight with BBWAA voters.
The market for MLB Manager of the Year isn't about who is the best at double-switches or bullpen management. It’s about who captures the imagination of the 30 voters who decide the winner. Look for the drama, find the turnaround story, and you’ll usually find the winner.
The most effective way to approach this market is to wait until the first two weeks of the season are over. Early trends often reveal which "project" teams are actually ready to compete, allowing you to jump on a mid-tier candidate before their odds plummet toward the favorites. Keep your eyes on the Baltimore and San Francisco dugouts specifically, as those two represent the highest narrative potential for the 2026 cycle.