So, you're standing there with a brush in your hand and a palette that’s missing the one thing you need. It happens to everyone. You need orange. It seems like the easiest thing in the world because we all learned it in kindergarten, right? Just grab red and yellow. Mix 'em up. Done.
But then you actually try it and—wait. Why does it look like burnt sienna or, worse, a weird brownish sludge that belongs on a wet sidewalk?
The truth is that knowing what colours to mix to make orange isn't just about grabbing any old tube of red and yellow. It’s about science. It’s about light. It’s about the fact that "red" isn't just "red" when you’re dealing with chemical pigments. If you've ever felt frustrated that your sunset looks more like a dust storm, you aren't bad at art. You just haven't been told how color bias actually works.
The basic recipe (and why it fails)
Let’s start with the absolute basics. In the traditional RYB (Red, Yellow, Blue) color model used by painters for centuries, orange is a secondary color. You create it by combining two primary colors: red and yellow. Simple.
In a vacuum, a 50/50 split of "pure" red and "pure" yellow gives you a standard, vibrant orange. But here is the kicker: pure pigments don't really exist in your local craft store. Every paint you buy has a "bias." This means your red might lean a little bit toward purple (cool) or a little bit toward orange (warm).
If you take a cool red—something like an Alizarin Crimson—and mix it with yellow, you’re basically inviting blue to the party. Purple-ish reds have blue undertones. When you mix red, yellow, and even a tiny speck of blue, you get brown. That is the secret reason your orange looks "muddy." To get a screaming, bright neon orange, you need a warm red (like Cadmium Red) and a warm yellow (like Cadmium Yellow).
📖 Related: Hairstyles for women over 50 with round faces: What your stylist isn't telling you
Understanding the "warm" vs "cool" divide
It sounds counterintuitive. How can red be cool? Think about a cherry versus a brick. Or a lemon versus a school bus.
When you are looking at what colours to mix to make orange, you have to look at the color wheel through the lens of temperature.
- Warm Reds: These have a yellow undertone. Examples include Cadmium Red Light, Scarlet Lake, or Vermilion.
- Cool Reds: These have a blue or pink undertone. Think Alizarin Crimson, Permanent Rose, or Quinacridone Magenta.
- Warm Yellows: These lean toward orange. Think Cadmium Yellow Deep or Indian Yellow.
- Cool Yellows: These lean toward green. Think Lemon Yellow or Hansa Yellow.
If you want a vibrant, citrusy orange, you must use a warm red and a warm yellow. If you use a cool yellow (which has blue in it) and a cool red (which also has blue in it), you’ve just mixed all three primaries. Congratulations, you’ve made a very sophisticated shade of mud.
Different shades of orange and how to hit them
Not every orange is created equal. Sometimes you want the neon glow of a traffic cone, and sometimes you want the muted, earthy tone of a dried autumn leaf.
The Vivid Tangerine
To get that "pop," use a large amount of warm yellow and just a tiny "kiss" of warm red. Red is a much stronger pigment than yellow. It’s a bully. If you start with equal parts, the red will swallow the yellow whole. Start with your yellow on the palette and slowly pull in the red until you hit that sweet spot.
👉 See also: How to Sign Someone Up for Scientology: What Actually Happens and What You Need to Know
The Burnt Orange or Terracotta
If you actually want those muted, earthy tones, you can break the rules. You can use a cool red like Alizarin Crimson with a warm yellow. Or, you can take your perfect orange and add a microscopic amount of its "complementary" color: blue. Just a dot of Ultramarine Blue will knock the brightness down and give you a sophisticated, shadow-heavy orange that looks more natural in landscapes.
The Pastel Peach
White is your friend here. But be careful. Adding white to orange doesn't just make it lighter; it makes it more opaque and "chalky." For a true peach, mix your orange first, then fold in Titanium White. If it looks too "candy-like," add a tiny drop of yellow to warm it back up.
What about light? The RGB vs CMYK struggle
It gets weirder if you aren't using paint. If you’re a digital artist or a lighting technician, the rules of what colours to mix to make orange change completely.
In the world of light (RGB), you aren't mixing pigments; you're mixing wavelengths. To get orange on a computer screen, you turn your Red channel all the way up (255) and your Green channel about halfway up (around 128 to 165). Wait, green? Yes. In light, red and green make yellow, and a bit more red pushes it into orange. There is no "yellow" primary in the world of pixels.
Then there’s printing (CMYK). If you’re a graphic designer, you’re mixing Cyan, Magenta, Yellow, and Black. To get orange on paper, you mix Magenta and Yellow. Specifically, about 50% Magenta and 100% Yellow usually lands you in a nice, bright orange territory.
✨ Don't miss: Wire brush for cleaning: What most people get wrong about choosing the right bristles
Real-world chemistry and pigment names
If you go to an art store like Michael's or Blick, don't just look for "Red." Look at the labels. Professional artists look for the pigment codes on the back of the tube.
- PY65 (Hansa Yellow Deep): Great for mixing oranges.
- PO73 (Pyrrole Orange): This is already orange, but it's a great "base" to start with if you want to skip the mixing headache.
- PR108 (Cadmium Red): The gold standard for mixing warm, opaque oranges.
Robert Gamblin, a legendary figure in the world of oil paints and founder of Gamblin Artists Colors, often talks about "tonal value." He suggests that when mixing orange, you should consider the transparency of the paint. A transparent yellow mixed with a transparent red will give you an orange that "glows" because light can travel through the paint layer and bounce off the white canvas. Opaque paints (like Cadmums) will give you a flat, solid orange that is great for covering up mistakes but won't have that same "inner light."
Common mistakes that ruin your mix
- Too much red. I'll say it again: red is aggressive. Always add the darker/stronger color to the lighter color.
- Using a "green" yellow. If your yellow looks like a lemon, it has blue in it. Blue + Yellow = Green. Green + Red = Brown. If your orange looks green-ish, throw the mix away and start with a warmer yellow.
- Dirty brushes. This sounds like "Mom advice," but even a tiny bit of leftover blue or purple on your brush will kill the vibration of an orange. Use a fresh brush.
- Over-mixing. If you stir the paint until it’s perfectly uniform, it can look a bit flat. Sometimes, leaving "streaks" of red and yellow within the orange creates more visual interest and "movement" in your art.
The psychological effect of the "Right" orange
Why do we care so much? Because orange is a polarizing color. In his book Interaction of Color, Josef Albers demonstrated how orange can look completely different depending on what color is next to it.
An orange mixed with a bit of red will look intensely energetic. It’s the color of fire and warnings. If you lean more toward yellow, it becomes the color of optimism and sunshine. If you get the mix wrong and it turns muddy, it evokes decay or dirt. Getting the mix right is the difference between a painting that feels "alive" and one that feels "heavy."
Actionable steps for your next project
To master this, you need to do more than read. You need to see the "mud" for yourself.
- Create a Mixing Chart: Take every red you own and every yellow you own. Mix them in a grid. You’ll be shocked to see that Red A + Yellow B looks totally different than Red B + Yellow A.
- Identify the Undertone: Smear a tiny bit of your red onto a white paper and streak it out until it's very thin. Does it look pink (cool) or orange (warm)? Use the one that looks orange.
- The "One-Drop" Rule: When mixing, start with a dollop of yellow the size of a quarter. Add red the size of a pinhead. Mix. Observe. Repeat. It is much easier to make an orange darker than it is to make it lighter once it’s already too red.
- Test your Blue: If you want a "burnt" or "autumnal" orange, don't use black to darken it. Black often makes orange look "dead." Use a tiny bit of dark blue instead. It creates a much richer, more vibrating dark orange.
Getting the perfect orange is a rite of passage for any artist. It requires you to stop seeing colors as "labels" and start seeing them as "ingredients" with their own hidden properties. Next time you reach for those tubes, remember: avoid the blue undertones, respect the power of red, and always start with your yellow. Now go make something that glows.