You've probably heard someone say, "I'm just not a math person." Or maybe you’ve looked at a talented musician and figured they were simply born with a "gift" that you’ll never have. It's a common way to think. It’s also, according to Stanford psychologist Carol Dweck, the very thing holding you back from actually getting good at stuff.
When Mindset: The New Psychology of Success by Carol S. Dweck first hit the shelves, it didn't just become a bestseller; it fundamentally shifted how teachers, CEOs, and parents talk about potential. But here is the thing: a lot of people think they understand the "growth mindset," but they’re actually practicing what Dweck calls a "false growth mindset." They think it’s just about being positive or trying hard.
It’s not.
It’s about the underlying belief of where ability comes from. Dweck’s decades of research suggest that our conscious and unconscious beliefs about our intelligence—our "mindsets"—form a massive part of our personality and determine whether we actually become the people we want to be.
The Core Conflict: Fixed vs. Growth
At the heart of the book is a simple, binary distinction. You either have a fixed mindset or a growth mindset.
In a fixed mindset, you believe your qualities are carved in stone. You have a certain amount of intelligence, a certain personality, and a specific moral character. You’re born with it. Period. This creates an urgent need to prove yourself over and over. If you only have a set amount of intelligence, you'd better look like you have a lot of it. You start avoiding challenges because failing would mean you’re fundamentally "less than."
The growth mindset is the opposite. It’s the belief that your basic qualities are things you can cultivate through your efforts, your strategies, and help from others. People with this mindset don't necessarily think everyone is the same or that anyone can be Einstein. But they do believe that a person’s true potential is unknown (and unknowable) and that years of passion, toil, and training can change even the most "basic" traits.
Why do we love being "smart"?
We’ve been conditioned to love the label "gifted." However, Dweck points out a startling reality: praising children for their intelligence actually harms their motivation and performance. In one of her most famous studies, Dweck and her colleagues took several hundred fifth graders and gave them a series of moderately difficult problems from a non-verbal IQ test.
After the first set, some kids were praised for their ability ("Wow, you got eight right. That’s a really good score. You must be smart at this.") and others were praised for their effort ("Wow, you got eight right. That’s a really good score. You must have worked really hard.").
👉 See also: The Gospel of Matthew: What Most People Get Wrong About the First Book of the New Testament
The "smart" kids? They immediately became risk-averse. When given a choice for the next task, they chose the easy one because they didn't want to lose their "smart" status. The "effort" kids? Over 90% of them chose the harder task. They wanted to learn.
The kicker? When given a final, difficult set of problems, the "smart" kids' scores actually dropped. The "effort" kids improved. Praising ability makes people fragile. It makes them feel like success is something they are rather than something they do.
The Danger of the "False Growth Mindset"
Honestly, this is where most people trip up today.
Since the book became a global phenomenon, the term "growth mindset" has been thrown around in every corporate boardroom and elementary school hallway. This led to what Dweck calls the "false growth mindset."
People started thinking that a growth mindset is just about being open-minded or optimistic. It’s not. It’s also not just about praising effort. If a kid tries really hard but uses a terrible strategy and fails, praising their effort is a consolation prize. It’s empty.
A true growth mindset involves praising the process. This means the strategy, the focus, the persistence, and the actual improvement. It’s about the link between the work and the result. If the effort didn't work, you don't just say "well, you tried!" You look for new strategies. You ask, "What else can we try?"
Can you really change your mindset?
Neuroscience says yes. Brain plasticity—the brain's ability to reorganize itself by forming new neural connections throughout life—is the physical proof that Dweck’s psychology is grounded in biology. When you learn something new, the neurons in your brain form stronger connections.
Think of it like a path in a forest. The more you walk it (practice), the clearer and easier the path becomes. If you stop walking it, the weeds grow back. A fixed mindset is like looking at a dense thicket and saying, "There is no path, so I can't go there." A growth mindset is picking up a machete.
✨ Don't miss: God Willing and the Creek Don't Rise: The True Story Behind the Phrase Most People Get Wrong
Mindset in the Real World: Business and Sports
The book spends a lot of time looking at how these mindsets play out in high-stakes environments.
In business, Dweck looks at "The Talent Mindset" which plagued companies like Enron. If a company is obsessed with hiring "the best and the brightest" and rewarding only "innate talent," it creates a culture where employees feel they have to look flawless. Nobody admits mistakes. Nobody asks for help. And as we saw with Enron, that leads to a culture of deception and, eventually, total collapse.
Compare that to leaders like Lou Gerstner at IBM or Anne Mulcahy at Xerox. They focused on "growth" cultures. They looked for people who were willing to learn, take risks, and admit when things weren't working.
The myth of the "Natural" athlete
Sports is where the fixed mindset usually lives. We love the "natural." We love the guy who walks onto the court and dominates without trying.
But Dweck uses Michael Jordan as the ultimate counter-example. Jordan wasn't a "natural" in the way we think. He was cut from his high school varsity team. He wasn't recruited by the college he wanted to go to at first. He became the greatest because he was the hardest worker. He practiced the shots he missed. He leaned into his weaknesses until they became strengths.
In a fixed mindset, if you have to work hard, it means you aren't talented. In a growth mindset, hard work is what makes you talented.
The "Special" Trap
There is a specific flavor of the fixed mindset that affects "high achievers." It’s the belief that you are superior to others because of your successes.
When things are going well, people in this mindset feel like "winners." But the moment they hit a snag, their entire self-worth crumbles. Because they defined themselves as "the best," any failure makes them "the worst." There is no middle ground.
🔗 Read more: Kiko Japanese Restaurant Plantation: Why This Local Spot Still Wins the Sushi Game
This leads to a lot of defensive behavior. You see it in CEOs who blame the economy for their failing company or athletes who blame the refs for a loss. If you are "perfect," then failure must be someone else's fault.
How to Actually Shift Your Thinking
Changing your mindset isn't like flipping a light switch. It’s more like a long-term neurological remodeling project.
First, you have to hear the "fixed mindset voice." It’s that voice in your head that says, "What if you fail? You’ll be a failure." Or, "I’m not good at this."
When you hear it, you have to talk back with a growth mindset voice.
- Fixed Voice: "I can't do this."
- Growth Voice: "I can't do this yet."
The word "yet" is incredibly powerful. It acknowledges the current reality while leaving the door open for future mastery.
Second, you have to stop seeking validation and start seeking growth. This means choosing the harder project at work even if it means you might not look like a superstar right away. It means asking for feedback even when you know it might be tough to hear.
Actionable Steps for Growth
If you want to move away from the "fixed" trap, stop focusing on the outcome and start dissecting your process. Here is how you can actually apply this tomorrow:
- Audit your self-talk. For one day, write down every time you judge your own ability. Do you say "I'm bad at names" or "I'm not a tech person"? Catch those labels.
- The "Yet" Pivot. Every time you catch a "cannot," add "yet" to the end of the sentence. It sounds cheesy, but it prevents the brain from closing the case on that skill.
- Identify a "Fixed Mindset Trigger." We all have them. Maybe it’s seeing a peer succeed or receiving a piece of criticism. When you feel that sting of defensiveness, stop. Acknowledge that your fixed mindset is trying to protect you from feeling "less than."
- Study the struggle. Instead of looking at successful people and seeing their "gifts," look for their "drudge work." Read biographies of people you admire. You will almost always find a period of intense, unglamorous struggle that paved the way for their "overnight" success.
- Change your praise. If you are a parent or a manager, stop saying "You’re so smart" or "You’re a natural." Instead, say "I can see you put a lot of thought into this strategy" or "The way you handled that obstacle was really effective."
Mindset isn't about pretending you're perfect. It’s about realizing that you’re a work in progress. Success isn't about proving you're the best; it's about the thrill of getting better. It’s a subtle shift, but it changes everything about how you live your life.