You know that feeling when a "Disney kid" finally breaks out and you’re just sitting there like, wait, they can actually do that? That was basically the collective reaction when Milo Manheim showed up as Joseph in the 2023 musical Journey to Bethlehem.
If you grew up watching Zombies, you know Milo. He’s the guy with the green hair and the infectious "I’m just happy to be here" energy. But playing the literal earthly father of Jesus? That’s a whole different level of pressure. Honestly, it’s a role that could have been incredibly cheesy or, worse, totally forgettable. Instead, Milo turned Joseph into someone... kind of relatable?
What Really Happened With Milo Manheim in Journey to Bethlehem
Most people see the finished product—the bright colors, the pop-infused soundtrack, the 100% "Nativity but make it High School Musical" vibe—and they don’t think about how much of a gamble this was for Milo.
This wasn’t just another TV movie. This was a feature-length musical directed by Adam Anders, the guy who basically ran the music for Glee. When Milo signed on, he wasn't just joining a movie; he was joining a 10-year passion project.
Filming took place on the coast of Spain, specifically around the Santa Bárbara Castle in Alicante. Can you imagine? You’re in this stunning, ancient location, playing one of the most famous historical figures ever, and you have to sing pop songs about it. Milo’s mentioned in interviews that he spent his time in LA before the shoot just driving around with the windows down, blasting the demos. He even joked about a group of high schoolers catching him crying in his car to "Mother to a Savior and a King."
✨ Don't miss: Why the Cast of Hold Your Breath 2024 Makes This Dust Bowl Horror Actually Work
That’s the thing about Milo—he’s deeply unpretentious. He didn't approach Joseph like he was playing a saint on a stained-glass window. He played him like a guy who’s just realized the girl he loves is carrying a child that isn't his, and he’s trying to figure out how to not lose his mind.
Why the "Ultimate Deception" Scene Changed Everything
If you haven't seen the "Ultimate Deception" number, you’re missing the peak of Milo's performance. Most nativity stories skip over Joseph’s internal conflict. They make him this silent, stoic figure in the background of a manger scene.
In Journey to Bethlehem, Milo gets to have a full-on musical crisis.
He’s singing about being "torn in two." One half of him wants to believe Mary; the other half thinks he’s been played. It’s gritty, it’s emotional, and it shows off a vocal range that we didn't necessarily get to see in the Disney days. He’s not just hitting notes; he’s acting through the song.
🔗 Read more: Is Steven Weber Leaving Chicago Med? What Really Happened With Dean Archer
- The Chemistry: His work with Fiona Palomo (who played Mary) was surprisingly grounded. They didn't feel like "Actors playing Icons." They felt like two teenagers in over their heads.
- The Dance: Being a Dancing with the Stars runner-up (remember season 27?) definitely paid off. The choreography isn't just "step-touch." It’s athletic and expressive.
- The Legend Factor: He was sharing scenes with Antonio Banderas. Banderas was playing King Herod like a campy, terrifying rock star. Milo had to hold his own against a literal Hollywood legend, and he didn't blink.
The Impact Nobody Talks About
We talk a lot about the "faith-based film" genre. Usually, these movies are... well, they’re often a bit stiff. They’re made for a very specific audience and they don't always care about being "good" movies as long as they get the message across.
Journey to Bethlehem was different because it didn't feel like a lecture.
Milo was a huge part of that. He brought a modern, pop-culture sensibility to the role that made the story accessible to a younger generation. He wasn't playing "The Joseph." He was playing a young man named Joseph.
Director Adam Anders spent a decade trying to get this made. He wanted it to be "a bright light." To do that, he needed a lead who could carry the emotional weight without making it feel heavy. Milo’s "Wally" from School Spirits or his role in Thanksgiving showed he has range, but this? This was the "leading man" audition the world didn't know he needed.
💡 You might also like: Is Heroes and Villains Legit? What You Need to Know Before Buying
Milo’s Journey: What’s Next?
Look, 2023 was a massive year for him. Between Prom Pact, School Spirits, and Journey to Bethlehem, he was everywhere. But this film feels like a permanent marker on his resume. It proved he can handle a big-budget musical that requires more than just a charming smile.
If you're looking to dive deeper into his performance, don't just watch the trailer. Go find the "Meet Joseph" featurettes. You can see the behind-the-scenes footage of him in Spain, looking genuinely exhausted and exhilarated. It wasn't an easy shoot. They were working with live animals (the donkey stories are a whole other thing) and massive sets.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Aspiring Actors:
- Study the "Ultimate Deception" sequence. If you’re an actor, watch how Milo uses his face during the instrumental breaks. He stays in character even when he isn't singing.
- Listen to the Soundtrack. Beyond just the movie, the music stands alone as a solid pop album. "Can We Make This Work" is probably the most underrated track on there.
- Watch his DWTS clips. If you want to see where that physical confidence in Journey to Bethlehem came from, go back to 2018. It explains a lot about his stage presence.
Milo Manheim didn't just play a role in this movie. He helped humanize a story that’s been told a thousand times. He reminded everyone that before Joseph was a figure in a storybook, he was a guy who decided to choose love over logic. And honestly? That’s a pretty cool way to spend a Christmas movie.