When people talk about Mike Smith and the Florida Derby, they usually point to the mid-90s. It was a time when "Big Money" Mike wasn't just a nickname; it was a weekly reality. Honestly, looking back at the stretch from 1994 to 1996, what he did at Gulfstream Park was borderline impossible. He won three of them. In a row.
Horse racing is chaotic. You've got bad breaks, traffic, and the sheer unpredictability of three-year-olds finding their legs. To sweep a major Triple Crown prep like the Florida Derby three years straight requires more than just luck. It requires a specific kind of synergy with the animal that most jockeys spend a lifetime trying to find once. Smith found it three times in 36 months.
The names still echo in the rafters of the old Gulfstream grandstand: Holy Bull, Thunder Gulch, and Unbridled’s Song. These weren't just fast horses. They were icons. And Mike Smith was the guy pulling the strings for every single one of them during their Florida campaigns.
The 1994 Breakthrough with Holy Bull
Holy Bull was different. People who saw him run in the 1994 Florida Derby still talk about the way he moved—sorta like a freight train that decided it wanted to be a ballerina. Coming off a disastrous last-place finish in the Fountain of Youth, a lot of "experts" had written the gray colt off. They thought he was a sprinter who couldn't handle the distance.
Smith knew better.
He rode Holy Bull with a level of confidence that looked almost arrogant from the stands. He sent him right to the lead. No waiting. No "rating" for the stretch. He just let the Bull be a bull. They won by nearly six lengths, stopping the clock in 1:47.66. It wasn't just a win; it was a statement. This was the race that arguably cemented Smith’s reputation as the go-to guy for the biggest stages in the sport.
👉 See also: Why the Marlins Won World Series Titles Twice and Then Disappeared
The sheer physicality of that 1994 win changed the narrative for Florida-breds. Holy Bull went on to be Horse of the Year, and Mike Smith was the only pilot he ever needed after that afternoon in Hallandale. It’s funny how one race can fix a reputation, but for Smith and the Bull, the Florida Derby was the ultimate "I told you so."
Back-to-Back: Thunder Gulch and the 1995 Grind
If 1994 was about raw power, 1995 was about the "grind." Mike Smith teamed up with the legendary D. Wayne Lukas to ride a compact, gritty colt named Thunder Gulch. Unlike Holy Bull, Thunder Gulch didn't necessarily want to blow the doors off the field from the jump. He was a scrapper.
Smith had to work for this one.
In the 1995 Florida Derby, it came down to a localized war between Smith and Suave Prospect. They hooked up at the top of the stretch and didn't stop swinging until the wire. Smith got him home by a nose. A nose! That’s the thing about Smith; he can win a race by ten lengths or a fraction of an inch, and he looks exactly the same doing it.
- Horse: Thunder Gulch
- Trainer: D. Wayne Lukas
- Margin: Nose
- Significance: Proved Smith could win tactical battles as well as speed duels.
What’s wild is that Smith actually jumped off Thunder Gulch for the Kentucky Derby later that year to ride Talkin Man. Thunder Gulch won the Run for the Roses without him. Even Hall of Famers make the wrong call sometimes. But that doesn't take away from the masterclass he put on at Gulfstream to get the horse there in the first place.
✨ Don't miss: Why Funny Fantasy Football Names Actually Win Leagues
The Triple: Unbridled’s Song in 1996
By 1996, the pressure was actually palpable. No one had won three Florida Derbys in a row since Bill Hartack did it in the late 50s. Smith showed up with Unbridled’s Song, a massive, stunning individual who looked like he was carved out of marble.
This race was a coronation.
Unbridled’s Song took the lead and basically told the rest of the field to stay home. He won by almost six lengths, mirroring the dominance of Holy Bull two years prior. It was effortless. Smith sat as still as a statue while the horse did the heavy lifting. At that moment, Mike Smith was essentially the King of Florida racing.
But there’s a bittersweet side to this one. Unbridled’s Song came out of that race with "quarter cracks"—basically a nasty foot injury. Smith often says that if that horse had stayed healthy, we might have been talking about a Triple Crown winner. Even with half a foot, the horse ran a massive race in the Kentucky Derby, but the Florida Derby remains his masterpiece with Mike.
Why Mike Smith and the Florida Derby Still Matter
You might wonder why we're still talking about races from thirty years ago. It's because the Florida Derby is the ultimate "truth teller" in horse racing. If you can win it, you're a contender. If you can win it three times in a row, you're a legend.
🔗 Read more: Heisman Trophy Nominees 2024: The Year the System Almost Broke
Mike Smith’s success at Gulfstream Park laid the groundwork for the rest of his career. It’s where he learned how to handle the "hype horses." He took that experience and eventually used it to guide Zenyatta to 19 wins and Justify to a Triple Crown. You don't get to Justify without learning the lessons of Holy Bull.
Actionable Insights for Racing Fans
If you're looking to understand why Mike Smith is still relevant at age 60 (or close to it), keep these points in mind:
- Watch the "Quiet" Hands: Notice how Smith barely moves in the saddle when he has a lead. He isn't fighting the horse; he's letting it breathe. This was his hallmark in those 90s Florida Derbys.
- The Bounce-Back Factor: Smith doesn't panic after a bad race. If your favorite horse loses a prep race, look at the jockey. A guy like Smith knows that one bad afternoon doesn't define a champion.
- Track the "Big Money" Moves: Even in 2025 and 2026, Smith is often "parachuted" in for big stakes races. Trainers still trust his "internal clock" more than almost anyone else in the room.
The Florida Derby isn't just a race; it's a gauntlet. Mike Smith didn't just run it; he owned it for a three-year stretch that we likely won't see again for a long, long time. Whether he was winning by a nose on a grinder or by a block on a superstar, he showed that a great jockey is often the difference between a "good" horse and a "legendary" one.
His 2025 appearance aboard Madaket Road, subbing in for Tyler Gaffalione, proved that even decades later, when the lights are brightest at Gulfstream, people still want "Big Money" Mike in the irons. It’s about trust. It’s about history. And mostly, it’s about knowing exactly where the wire is.