Driving past the intersection of State Route 57 and 49th Street today feels a bit like looking at a ghost. It’s quiet. If you grew up in Lorain County, you remember when Midway Mall in Elyria Ohio wasn't just a place to shop—it was the heart of the community. You could smell the pretzels from Auntie Anne’s the second you walked through the doors near Sears. Now? It’s mostly an asphalt desert surrounding a shell that’s seen better days.
But this isn't just another "malls are dying" story. It's more complicated than that.
The decline of this specific property tells us a lot about shifts in Midwestern economics, local politics, and the brutal reality of modern real estate. People keep asking if it's going to be torn down or if some tech giant is moving in. Honestly, the answer changes every six months depending on who you talk to at City Hall or which developer just pulled out of a deal.
The Glory Days of Lorain County’s Retail King
When Midway Mall opened in 1966, it changed everything for Elyria. Before the mall, people went downtown. After the mall? Downtown Elyria started a long, slow fade. It was the premier destination between Cleveland and Sandusky. We're talking about a massive footprint. At its peak, you had the "Big Four" anchors: Higbee’s (which became Dillard’s), Sears, JCPenney, and May Company (which became Macy's).
It stayed relevant for a long time. Even in the 90s and early 2000s, the food court was the place to be on a Friday night. You’d grab a slice of Sbarro, hit the Tilt arcade, and walk laps until your legs hurt. It was a social ecosystem.
But then the cracks started showing.
It wasn't just Amazon. People blame online shopping for everything, but that’s a lazy explanation. For Midway Mall, the "lifestyle center" trend hit hard. When Crocker Park opened in Westlake and Avon Commons started booming just a few exits away on I-90, the demographic Midway relied on—the middle-class shoppers from Lorain, Amherst, and Elyria—started driving ten minutes further for a "fancier" experience. Midway felt dated almost overnight.
Who Actually Owns the Mall Now?
This is where things get messy. For years, the ownership was fractured. If you’ve ever wondered why the parking lot looked like a lunar landscape with all those potholes, it’s because different companies owned different "parcels" of the land.
Sears owned their box. Penney's owned theirs. The main mall was under different management. It's a nightmare for redevelopment because you can’t just buy the whole thing with one check.
Namdar Realty Group, a company known for buying distressed malls and... well, let's just say they aren't known for high-end renovations... bought the main interior of the mall in 2017. Since then, it’s been a slow bleed. Shops left. The roof leaked. The heat was spotty. Eventually, even the stalwarts like JCPenney and Macy’s packed it in.
By 2023 and 2024, the Lorain County Port Authority stepped in. This was a massive move. They realized that as long as a private investment group held the keys, nothing would change. The Port Authority used a $13.9 million loan to acquire the property with the goal of finally clearing the slate.
The Industrial Pivot: No, It’s Probably Not Going to be a Mall Again
Let’s be real: Nobody is coming to build a new Macy’s at Midway Mall in Elyria Ohio. That ship has sailed, hit an iceberg, and is at the bottom of the ocean.
The current plan—and the one that actually makes sense for the 2026 economy—is light industrial and "innovation" space. Think clean manufacturing, cold storage, or a distribution hub. It sounds boring compared to a Disney Store and a KB Toys, but it brings jobs. Real jobs.
There was a lot of buzz about Industrial Commercial Properties (ICP) getting involved. They are the guys who turned the old Randall Park Mall into an Amazon fulfillment center and transformed the old Chapel Hill Mall in Akron. Their playbook is consistent:
- Strip the retail "fluff."
- Reinforce the floors.
- Raise the ceilings where possible.
- Turn the massive parking lots into truck docks and green space.
The city of Elyria is desperate for the tax revenue. When the mall was full, it was a cash cow. Now, it’s a drain on services.
The Weird, Persistent Tenants
Even now, Midway isn't completely empty, which is the strangest part of visiting. You still have a few businesses clinging on or operating in the outparcels. Best Buy and The Home Depot are still there, doing okay because they have their own entrances and separate identities from the "dead" interior.
Inside? It’s a different world. For a while, there were local churches, a martial arts studio, and some independent shops that looked like they were curated from a garage sale. It gave the place a liminal space vibe—that eerie feeling of being somewhere that should be crowded but isn't.
Why the Demolition is Taking So Long
People in Elyria ask: "Why don't they just bulldoze it tomorrow?"
Money and environmental concerns. Asbestos is a common guest in 1960s builds. You can't just knock it down; you have to abate it. Then there’s the sheer volume of concrete. The Port Authority and the city are trying to secure state grants—specifically from the Ohio Brownfield Remediation Fund—to cover the costs of tearing it all down. Without that government money, the math for a private developer just doesn't work.
What This Means for Local Property Values
If you live in the neighborhoods off Gulf Road or near the mall, you’ve probably seen your home value fluctuate. A decaying mall is a magnet for crime and "urban explorers" looking to film YouTube videos.
✨ Don't miss: Kohl's Payment Strategy Amid Turnaround Effort: What Really Happened
However, the shift toward a business park could actually stabilize the area. Industrial centers don't bring the "prestige" of a Nordstrom, but they bring hundreds of workers who need to eat lunch nearby and buy gas. It changes the traffic patterns from "Saturday afternoon rush" to "Monday morning shift change."
The Future of Midway Mall in Elyria Ohio: Actionable Steps for Residents
If you’re a local or an investor, you need to stop looking at this as a retail failure and start looking at it as a land-use opportunity.
- Follow the Port Authority Meetings: This is where the real decisions happen. Don't rely on Facebook rumors. The Lorain County Port Authority releases public records on their "Midway Mall Redevelopment Plan." Read them.
- Watch the Zoning Changes: The City of Elyria has been working on a "reimagining" plan. If they rezone the area from retail to mixed-use or light industrial, that's your signal that the wrecking ball is finally coming.
- Support Peripheral Businesses: The restaurants on 57 and 49th Street have been hurting. If you want that corridor to survive the transition, those are the spots that need the foot traffic while the mall sits vacant.
- Manage Expectations: This won't be a 12-month turnaround. We are looking at a 5-to-10-year cycle to fully transform 100+ acres of prime real estate.
The story of Midway Mall is really the story of the Rust Belt’s second act. It’s messy, it’s slow, and it’s a little bit sad for those of us who remember the fountain in the center court. But standing still is how the property died in the first place. Moving toward a functional, industrial future is the only way to keep Elyria from being stuck in 1985 forever.
The concrete stays for now, but the vision has finally shifted. It’s about time.