When Monolith Productions first dropped the trailer for Middle-earth: Shadow of War, it wasn't the Orc hierarchies or the massive siege engines that sparked a firestorm across the internet. It was a woman in a black dress. That woman, as the game quickly revealed, was Shelob. Yes, that Shelob. The ancient, bloated spider from The Lord of the Rings who tried to turn Frodo into a midnight snack.
Honestly, the backlash was immediate. Purists felt like Monolith had basically taken J.R.R. Tolkien’s lore, thrown it in a blender, and hit the "pulse" button. But here’s the thing about Shadow of War Shelob: once you actually play the game and dig into the narrative justifications the writers used, the decision starts to make a weird kind of sense within the context of their specific "non-canon" universe. It’s a bold, arguably reckless choice that changes how we view the power dynamics of Mordor.
💡 You might also like: Why Kingdom Hearts Re Chain of Memories is the Most Misunderstood Game in the Series
Why Shelob Looks Like a Person in Shadow of War
Most people know Shelob as a monster. A "Great Spider." In the books, she is a descendant of Ungoliant, a primordial being of darkness who wasn't just a big bug, but a spirit of literal void and hunger. Monolith’s narrative lead, Tony Elias, and the rest of the writing team leaned heavily into this ancestry. They argued that if Shelob’s mother was a primordial spirit who could take different forms, why couldn't Shelob?
It’s a fair point, even if it stretches Tolkien's text to the breaking point. In the game, Shadow of War Shelob acts as a sort of dark prophet. She uses a human form—specifically a woman with a regal, somewhat mourning aesthetic—to communicate with Talion. Why? Because you can’t really have a nuanced, emotional conversation with a giant thorax. By giving her a human face, the developers allowed her to become a major player in the plot rather than just a boss fight at the end of a tunnel.
Shelob represents a "third way" in the conflict between Sauron and Celebrimbor. She’s not exactly "good," but she’s definitely not on Sauron’s side either. She views the Dark Lord as a traitor to the ancient powers of the world. By taking a human shape, she manipulates Talion, feeding him visions of the future to suit her own ends. It’s a classic "the enemy of my enemy is my useful tool" situation.
The Lore vs. The Game: Is It Actually "Wrong"?
If you ask a hardcore Tolkien scholar, the answer is a resounding "yes." Tolkien’s spiders were physical manifestations of greed and hunger. They weren't really meant to be sexy or relatable. They were the "other." In The Two Towers, Shelob is described as having a "monstrous" form that is the antithesis of light. Giving her a human form feels like a move to make the game more "Hollywood."
However, the game developers pointed to Ungoliant’s ability to take various shapes when she collaborated with Morgoth. They suggested that Shelob is a shapeshifter who chooses her spider form because it’s efficient for killing, but can wear a human skin when she needs to deceive or bargain. It’s a bit of a loophole. Honestly, it’s one of the most creative—if controversial—bits of fan fiction ever backed by a multi-million dollar budget.
✨ Don't miss: Why Zenless Zone Zero Zhu Yuan Is Actually The Most Reliable Carry You Can Build
Interestingly, the voice acting by Pollyanna McIntosh (who fans might recognize from The Walking Dead) brings a lot of gravitas to the role. She doesn't play Shelob as a villain. She plays her as an ancient, weary creature who has seen the rise and fall of empires and is tired of Sauron’s nonsense. This nuance is something you just couldn't get if she stayed as a giant spider for the entire 40-hour campaign.
Gameplay Impact: Visions and the Web of Fate
The presence of Shadow of War Shelob isn't just a narrative flourish; it’s a core gameplay mechanic. Early in the game, she takes Celebrimbor’s New Ring. This forces Talion to work with her to get it back. This setup provides the justification for the "Shelob Memories" collectibles scattered across the map.
These memories are basically 3D puzzles. You rotate fragments of a shattered image until they align, revealing a bit of Shelob’s backstory and her past relationship with Sauron. It turns out—in this specific game universe—Sauron and Shelob had a bit of a "thing." Or at least, an alliance that ended in a bitter betrayal. This adds a layer of revenge to her character that makes her more than just a hungry beast. She wants to see Sauron fall because he spurned her and the ancient darkness she represents.
- She acts as the primary quest giver for the first act.
- Her visions guide you toward key targets in the Nemesis System.
- She provides the "Lore" context that links the events of Shadow of Mordor to the larger War of the Ring.
Without this version of Shelob, the first ten hours of the game would feel a lot more aimless. She provides the stakes.
The "Sauron's Ex" Controversy
One of the weirdest details that came out during the marketing for Shadow of War was the implication that Shelob and Sauron were former lovers. This was the point where a lot of fans checked out. In the books, Sauron refers to Shelob as his "cat," a creature he keeps around to guard the pass of Cirith Ungol because she’s a convenient, low-maintenance security system. He doesn't love her; he barely respects her.
Monolith took a different path. They portrayed their relationship as a partnership between two primordial powers that soured when Sauron chose the path of industrialization and dominion over the more "natural" (if evil) darkness Shelob prefers. While it’s a massive departure from the source material, it makes for a more compelling video game drama. It turns the war for Mordor into a family feud between ancient monsters.
How to Handle Shelob’s Quests Efficiently
If you're jumping into the game now, don't ignore the Shelob Memory quests. While they might seem like "busy work" at first, completing them actually provides some of the best skill points and loot upgrades in the early game. Plus, the final cinematic you unlock once you collect all of them is genuinely one of the best-produced scenes in the entire game. It ties up her arc in a way that feels surprisingly earned, regardless of how you feel about her human form.
Focus on the following to make the most of her storyline:
✨ Don't miss: Finding a Nice Name for Game Character Without Looking Like an Amateur
- Unlock the "Prospector" skill early. It increases the quality of gems you find, which you’ll need as Shelob’s quests progress.
- Use Haedir towers to pinpoint memory locations immediately upon entering a new region. Don't wait.
- Listen to the dialogue. The banter between Talion and Celebrimbor regarding Shelob reveals a lot about Celebrimbor’s own arrogance. He hates her because she can see through his lies.
Final Thoughts on the Spider Queen
At the end of the day, Shadow of War Shelob is a symptom of the "Rule of Cool." The developers wanted a character who could challenge the protagonist intellectually and emotionally, and a giant spider simply couldn't fill that role in a modern AAA narrative. Whether you think it’s a brilliant expansion of the mythos or a travesty of Tolkien’s work, there’s no denying that it made Shelob one of the most talked-about characters in modern gaming.
She represents the bridge between the high-fantasy world of the Second Age and the gritty, orc-slaying action of the game. Even if you hate the dress, you have to admit: it's better than having another generic orc telling you what to do.
To truly master the Shelob storyline and maximize your rewards, you should prioritize finding all "Shelob Memories" in Minas Ithil before the city falls in Act 1. This ensures you have a solid foundation of Skill Points and narrative context before the game’s world opens up and the Nemesis System becomes significantly more complex. Once you've cleared the memories, pivot your focus to the "Web of Fate" challenges to unlock high-tier runes that synergize with your preferred playstyle.