You’ve seen the photos on Instagram. Sun-drenched living rooms with floor-to-ceiling glass, tapered legs on every piece of walnut furniture, and that specific shade of avocado green that somehow looks cool again. It looks effortless. But honestly? Doing a real mid century modern renovation is a total nightmare if you go into it thinking it’s just about buying a West Elm rug and painting everything white. Most people accidentally strip the soul out of these houses. They turn a residence that was meant to "bring the outdoors in" into a sterile box that feels more like a doctor’s office than a Frank Lloyd Wright-inspired sanctuary.
It’s about the philosophy.
Post-WWII architecture wasn't just a vibe; it was a response to a housing crisis and a shift in how American families wanted to live. We moved away from the cramped, compartmentalized Victorian layouts toward open floor plans and "post-and-beam" construction. If you own a house built between 1945 and 1969, you’re sitting on a piece of history. But if you start ripping out walls without understanding how those beams hold up your roof, you’re in for a very expensive surprise.
The "Open Concept" trap in mid century modern renovation
Everyone wants an open kitchen. It's basically the law of home renovation at this point. However, in many mid-century homes—especially those designed by Joseph Eichler or the various architects of the Alexandria, Virginia "Hollin Hills" neighborhood—the walls were actually part of a carefully calibrated privacy screen.
When you start your mid century modern renovation, you have to look at the "circulation" of the house. These architects were obsessed with it. They wanted you to move through the space in a way that felt organic. If you tear down the wall between the kitchen and the living room, you might suddenly realize you’ve lost the intentional "compression and release" that makes the entry feel grand.
Why you should keep the galley kitchen (mostly)
I know. Galley kitchens feel small. But they are incredibly efficient. Modernists loved them because they were modeled after ship and airplane galleys—everything within an arm's reach. Instead of blowing out the walls, consider updating the materials. Swap the dated Formica for high-pressure laminates in period-correct colors or even a matte quartz. Keep the flat-panel cabinets. That "slab door" look is the hallmark of the era. Use walnut veneers if you want that warmth, or go with a bold, saturated orange or teal if you’re feeling brave.
📖 Related: Hairstyles for women over 50 with round faces: What your stylist isn't telling you
The biggest mistake? Putting in "shaker style" cabinets. Just don't. It's a different era. It clashes. It looks like you didn't know what house you were living in.
Dealing with the "Leaky" glass problem
Mid-century homes are famous for their windows. Huge, expansive panes of glass that make you feel like you’re sleeping in the woods. The problem? Most of that glass is single-pane. It’s a literal thermal bridge. You’re basically heating the neighborhood in the winter and roasting in the summer.
When people tackle a mid century modern renovation, they often look at the price tag for replacing those massive windows and faint. It’s expensive. You can’t just go to a big-box hardware store and buy a standard window. You often need custom-sized, tempered, double-pane glass.
But here is the trick: don't change the frames if you can help it. If you have original steel or thin-profile wood frames, try to find a glazier who can retro-fit them. If you swap them for chunky, modern vinyl frames, you lose the "thin line" aesthetic that defines the movement. You’ve gone from "architectural masterpiece" to "suburban tract home" in one afternoon.
The battle of the floors: Terrazzo vs. Everything Else
If you pull up your gross, 1990s beige carpet and find terrazzo underneath, you’ve won the lottery. Seriously. Stop everything and call a professional polisher. Terrazzo is a composite material—chips of marble, quartz, or granite set in concrete—and it was the gold standard for high-end MCM homes.
👉 See also: How to Sign Someone Up for Scientology: What Actually Happens and What You Need to Know
If you aren't that lucky, you’re probably looking at concrete or hardwood. For a mid century modern renovation that actually adds value, stick to:
- Cork: It’s sustainable, soft on the feet, and was used extensively in the 50s.
- Slate: Great for entryways and "wet" areas.
- Thin-plank Oak: Not the wide-plank farmhouse stuff. You want 2.25-inch strips. It keeps the scale of the rooms feeling correct.
Stop over-lighting your ceilings
Recessed "can" lights are the enemy of the mid-century ceiling. These houses often have tongue-and-groove wood ceilings or exposed beams. Punching twenty holes in that beautiful wood to install LED lights is a tragedy.
Lighting in the 1950s was about "pools of light." Think floor lamps, pendants (the George Nelson bubble lamp is a cliché for a reason—it works), and wall sconces. If you must have overhead lighting, use track lighting that sits on top of the beams or hidden LED strips that wash the ceiling with light from the tops of the walls. It creates a soft, indirect glow that makes the wood grain pop.
The exterior: Curb appeal without the "Flips"
Please, for the love of all things holy, do not paint your brick white.
I see it everywhere. People buy a beautiful Roman brick ranch and immediately slap a coat of white "farmhouse" paint on it. Brick needs to breathe. Painting it traps moisture and, more importantly, it hides the texture that is central to the MCM look. If you hate the color of your brick, look into "staining" it. It changes the color while preserving the masonry’s natural look and breathability.
✨ Don't miss: Wire brush for cleaning: What most people get wrong about choosing the right bristles
Focus on the front door instead. A bold, asymmetrical door with a vertical window lite can change the entire face of the house. Colors like "Crestline Teal" or a bright "Paprika" were common. Pair it with some period-correct house numbers—Neutraface or Eames-style fonts—and you’ve done more for your home's value than a $50k botched paint job would have.
Insulation: The boring part that matters most
Since many of these homes have flat or low-slope roofs, they don't have attics. No attic means no place to hide insulation or HVAC ducts. This is the "hidden" hurdle of a mid century modern renovation.
You basically have two choices when the roof needs work:
- Rigid Foam Board: You put this on top of the roof deck before the new roofing material goes down. It’s like putting a warm hat on your house.
- Mini-Splits: Since you can't easily run big metal ducts through a post-and-beam house without dropping the ceilings (which you should never do), ductless mini-split systems are your best friend. They provide heat and AC and can be tucked away relatively discreetly.
Real talk about the budget
A mid-century renovation is usually 20% to 30% more expensive than a standard "remodel." Why? Because nothing is standard. The electrical systems in the 50s were often "Zinsco" or "Federal Pacific" panels which are now considered fire hazards. The plumbing might be galvanized pipe that is currently rusting from the inside out.
You aren't just paying for the "look." You’re paying for the specialized labor required to work on non-traditional structures. You need a contractor who doesn't look at a butterfly roof and ask "Where's the attic access?"
Actionable steps for your renovation
If you're staring at a dated ranch and wondering where to start, don't rush. Live in the house for six months first. See how the sun hits the living room at 4:00 PM. Notice where the drafts are.
- Audit your electrical first. Before the pretty stuff, ensure your panel can handle a modern kitchen. Many MCM homes only have 60-amp or 100-amp service; you’ll likely need 200-amp.
- Source "New Old Stock" (NOS) hardware. Look on eBay or at architectural salvage yards for original Starburst backplates or Baldwin door pulls.
- Consult a specialist. Even a one-hour walkthrough with an architect who specializes in modernism can save you thousands in "oops" moments.
- Focus on the "Envelope." Fix the roof and the windows first. There is no point in having a beautiful Eames chair if it’s getting rained on or sitting in a drafty corner.
- Landscaping is part of the architecture. Mid-century design is 50% about the yard. Use grasses, structural plants like Yucca or Agave, and horizontal fencing to extend the lines of the house into the garden.
Renovating these homes is a stewardship. You’re taking care of a specific moment in design history. Keep the lines clean, keep the materials honest, and for heaven's sake, keep the shaker cabinets in the farmhouse where they belong.