If you’ve spent any time on message boards lately, you know the vibe around Ann Arbor is basically a mix of whiplash and guarded optimism. One minute we’re talking about Sherrone Moore’s 2026 recruiting class, and the next, he’s out. It happened fast. Really fast. Now, Kyle Whittingham is the man in the big chair, and the Michigan football rumors haven't slowed down just because the ink is dry on his five-year contract.
Honestly, the transition felt like a fever dream. Moore was let go late in the cycle, which usually spells disaster for roster retention. You've seen it happen at other blue-bloods: a coaching change triggers a mass exodus to the portal, and suddenly you're starting walk-ons on Saturdays. But somehow, Whittingham has kept the floor from falling out.
The Roster Retention Miracle
The biggest rumor—which turned out to be a massive sigh of relief for the fans—was whether the "young pillars" would stay. We’re talking about guys like Andrew Marsh. He’s the kid who put up 189 yards against Northwestern as a freshman. If he leaves, the offense loses its heartbeat. But Whittingham got him to stay.
Then you have the Bryce Underwood factor. Keeping the top-tier QB talent committed while the coaching staff was being overhauled is a feat of strength. Reports from inside Schembechler Hall suggest Whittingham made roster retention his "top priority" from minute one. It worked. Along with Marsh, we're seeing guys like Andrew Sprague, Jake Guarnera, and Zeke Berry decide that Ann Arbor is still the place to be.
It wasn’t all sunshine, though. The portal took its tax.
🔗 Read more: Saint Benedict's Prep Soccer: Why the Gray Bees Keep Winning Everything
- Jadyn Davis (QB) and Davis Warren (to Stanford) are gone.
- Semaj Morgan is heading to UCLA.
- Brady Prieskorn opted for Ole Miss.
Losing Prieskorn hurts. He’s a high-ceiling tight end, and in a system that loves using the "big skill" guys, that’s a gap that’s hard to fill. But that’s the nature of 2026 football. You win some, you lose some, and you hope the ones you keep are the ones who actually want to be there when the weather turns cold in November.
The Utah Connection: Is Michigan Just "Utah North"?
Look at the new coaching staff. It’s impossible not to notice the Salt Lake City influence. Whittingham didn't just come alone; he brought the whole moving van.
Jason Beck is the new Offensive Coordinator. Jay Hill is running the defense. Then you’ve got Jim Harding on the O-line, Micah Simon with the receivers, and Freddie Whittingham (yes, the brother) coaching tight ends. It’s a literal family affair. Some fans are worried this means Michigan is losing its "Midwest identity," but honestly, if that identity includes 177 career wins like Whittingham’s did at Utah, most people will take it.
The interesting part is the Michigan football rumors regarding the few "holdovers." Tony Alford is staying as the running backs coach and run game coordinator. That’s huge for continuity. Keeping Alford means the relationship with guys like Savion Hiter—the four-star RB from Virginia—stays intact. It gives the locker room a familiar face to look at while they’re learning a completely new defensive scheme from Jay Hill.
💡 You might also like: Ryan Suter: What Most People Get Wrong About the NHL's Ultimate Survivor
The Transfer Portal Haul: Salesi Moa and the New Blood
The latest buzz? Salesi Moa. This kid is a 6-foot-1, 190-pound Swiss Army knife. He was technically enrolled at Utah for about five minutes before Whittingham left. He hit the portal on January 12th and committed to Michigan less than a week later.
Moa is officially the "prize" of this portal cycle. He’s the No. 1 player out of Utah and can play receiver or defensive back. Considering the secondary just lost TJ Metcalf and Brandyn Hillman, Moa might find himself playing a lot of snaps early on defense.
And don't sleep on the other additions:
- Colin Hurley (QB from LSU): A former four-star who never saw the field in Baton Rouge but has a cannon.
- Smith Snowden (CB from Utah): A veteran who knows exactly what Jay Hill wants in a cornerback.
- Taylor Tatum (RB from Oklahoma): A massive get to help replace the depth lost to the portal.
The NCAA Shadow: Probation and Fines
We have to talk about the elephant in the room. The sign-stealing fallout. The NCAA didn't go easy on Michigan. Four years of probation. A $50,000 fine. But the real kicker is the "postseason revenue" fine. The NCAA is essentially clawing back 10% of the program's budget and all the money Michigan would have made from bowl games in 2025 and 2026.
📖 Related: Red Sox vs Yankees: What Most People Get Wrong About Baseball's Biggest Feud
Wait, is there a postseason ban? No. The Committee on Infractions decided not to punish the current players for what happened under the old regime. But the financial hit is north of $20 million. That's a lot of NIL money that could have gone elsewhere.
Also, even though Sherrone Moore is gone, his legacy includes a three-game suspension that was supposed to start in 2026. Since he’s no longer the coach, that specific penalty is a bit of a moot point for the university, but the recruiting restrictions remain. A 25% reduction in official visits is a hurdle Whittingham has to jump over while trying to build his first "real" class.
What to Watch for Next
The 2026 recruiting class is currently sitting pretty in the top 15. You've got legacy names like Tommy Carr—grandson of Lloyd Carr—joining the QB room. People who’ve seen him play say he’s actually a better pure athlete than his brother CJ. He flipped from Miami (Ohio) and seems perfectly content to sit behind Bryce Underwood for a year or two.
The real drama will be the February signing period. While Whittingham says he wants to build through high school ranks, the Michigan football rumors suggest they aren't done in the portal. They need linebacker depth. Desperately. If a veteran LB from the SEC or Big 12 hits the portal in the next few weeks, expect Michigan to be the first phone call.
Actionable Next Steps for Fans:
- Monitor the LB Portal: Keep an eye on any veteran linebackers entering the portal before the spring window closes.
- Watch the "Family" Hires: See how the Utah transplants adapt to Big Ten recruiting. The Midwest is a different beast than the Pac-12/Big 12 landscape.
- Spring Game Expectations: Expect a very vanilla look at Jason Beck’s offense, but pay attention to where Salesi Moa is lining up. If he’s at CB, that tells you everything you need to know about the depth chart concerns.
The transition hasn't been perfect, but the fact that Michigan hasn't imploded yet is a testament to the stability Whittingham brings. He isn't a "flashy" hire, but he's a winner. And in a post-Harbaugh, post-Moore world, maybe "stable winner" is exactly what this program needs.