You know that feeling when you're watching a show and a character walks on screen and you just think, "Oh, you are going to be a total disaster"? That is exactly the energy Michelle Monaghan brings to Bad Monkey. Honestly, it’s refreshing.
In a world of prestige TV where everyone is either a brooding anti-hero or a saint, Monaghan’s Bonnie Witt is just... a mess. A beautiful, chaotic, Florida-flavored mess. She’s the kind of character who makes you want to reach through the screen and tell her to maybe just stay home for a day. But if she did, the show wouldn’t be half as fun.
The Mystery of Bonnie Witt (aka Plover Chase)
Most people jumped into the Apple TV+ hit because of Vince Vaughn’s rapid-fire dialogue. I get it. He’s great. But Michelle Monaghan is the secret sauce that makes the Florida noir setting of Bad Monkey actually feel dangerous and weird.
When we first meet her, she's Bonnie Witt, the "other woman" in Andrew Yancy’s life. She’s married to a dermatologist, which sounds boring until you realize she’s basically hiding a whole previous life under a fake name. Her real name? Plover Chase.
She isn't just some bored housewife. She’s a fugitive.
Back in Oklahoma, she had an affair with a student. Now, she’s in the Keys, living a lie and dragging Yancy into her orbit of poor decisions. Monaghan plays her with this wild-eyed intensity. You never quite know if she’s going to kiss someone or set their house on fire. Usually, it's a bit of both.
👉 See also: Cuatro estaciones en la Habana: Why this Noir Masterpiece is Still the Best Way to See Cuba
Why Michelle Monaghan Was the Perfect Choice
Monaghan has talked about how this role felt like a homecoming. Remember Kiss Kiss Bang Bang? She was brilliant in that. That same sharp, comedic timing is back here. She told In Creative Company that she actually thought of Bonnie like a panther—calculated but capable of total chaos.
It shows.
She doesn't play Bonnie as a villain. She plays her as someone who is deeply, almost pathologically, incapable of being honest. It’s "morally ambiguous" at best. Most of the time, it's just straight-up reckless.
What’s interesting is that the character is pulled straight from Carl Hiaasen’s novel. In the book, Bonnie and Eve (played by Meredith Hagner) are these two forces of nature that weaponize their own desires to get what they want. In the show, Monaghan gives Bonnie a bit more humanity. You almost feel bad for her. Almost. Then she does something crazy again, and you’re back to shouting at the TV.
The Dynamics That Make It Work
- The Yancy Connection: Her chemistry with Vince Vaughn is electric because they both talk at a hundred miles an hour.
- The Secret Past: The reveal about her life in Oklahoma as Plover Chase adds a layer of "Florida Gothic" that the show needs.
- The Comedy: This isn't just a crime thriller. It’s funny. Monaghan leans into the absurdity of a woman who thinks she can outrun her own identity while wearing designer sunglasses in a dive bar.
Is Bonnie Returning for Season 2?
Here is the big question everyone is asking. Bad Monkey has been officially renewed for Season 2. That’s the good news. The weird news? Production is moving from Florida to California.
✨ Don't miss: Cry Havoc: Why Jack Carr Just Changed the Reece-verse Forever
They snagged a massive $20.6 million tax credit to film in Los Angeles. While they’ll still do some exterior shots in the Keys to keep that sweaty, humid vibe, the bulk of the work is shifting west.
As for Michelle Monaghan? The cast list for Season 2 is still a bit of a puzzle. We know Vince Vaughn and Natalie Martinez are back. We know John Malkovich and Yvonne Strahovski are joining the party. But Bonnie Witt’s story in the first season felt like a very specific arc.
In the books, the characters often cycle in and out. However, considering Monaghan was such a standout—and let’s be real, you don't just let a talent like her walk away if you can help it—there is a high chance we haven't seen the last of her. Even if it's just Bonnie causing trouble from afar, her presence is baked into the DNA of the show.
What You Should Do Next
If you haven't finished the first season, go back and watch the episodes where Bonnie’s past starts to catch up with her. Specifically, pay attention to the episode where the private investigator from Oklahoma shows up. Monaghan’s performance in those scenes is a masterclass in "panicked acting."
For those who are already caught up, keep an eye on Apple TV+ announcements later this year. Filming for Season 2 started in late 2025, which means we are likely looking at a late 2026 release date.
🔗 Read more: Colin Macrae Below Deck: Why the Fan-Favorite Engineer Finally Walked Away
Pro Tip: If you love the vibe of Monaghan in this show, go back and watch her in MaXXXine or Gone Baby Gone. She has this incredible ability to play women who are much tougher—and much more complicated—than they first appear. Bonnie Witt is just the latest, and perhaps most colorful, entry in that long list of "complicated Broad" characters she does so well.
The best way to prep for the new season is to dive into Carl Hiaasen's other books. Bad Monkey is part of a specific world, and while the show takes liberties, the spirit of "Florida Man" energy is 100% accurate. Bonnie Witt might be a fugitive, but in the world of high-stakes TV, she’s exactly where she belongs.
Next Steps for Fans:
- Watch the Season 1 Finale: Re-watch Bonnie’s final moments to see if there are clues about her return.
- Check the Tax Credits: Keep an eye on California Film Commission reports; they often list the full cast for projects receiving credits.
- Read the Source Material: Pick up the novel Bad Monkey to see how Bonnie’s fate differs from the show.
The show works because it doesn't take itself too seriously, and Michelle Monaghan is the poster child for that philosophy. She’s messy, she’s unpredictable, and she’s the best part of the Florida sun.