Everyone calls it Batman Returns. But for a lot of us growing up in the early nineties, the idea of Michael Keaton Batman 2 wasn't just a title on a marquee; it was a total cultural reset. It’s the movie that gave us the "slurp" heard 'round the world from Michelle Pfeiffer and a version of Gotham so snowy and depressing it felt like a gothic nightmare.
Honestly, the history behind this sequel is weirder than a penguin with a rocket launcher.
The Sequel That Almost Didn't Feature Keaton
You'd think after the 1989 Batman shattered box office records, everyone would be screaming to do it again. Not really. Tim Burton was actually pretty lukewarm on the idea of a direct sequel. He didn't want to just "do more Joker." He wanted something weirder.
Michael Keaton wasn't a lock either. He didn't have a sequel clause in his original contract. Can you imagine? The guy who was Batman could have just walked away. He eventually signed on, but only after a massive pay bump to around $11 million. That was an insane amount of money back then.
The studio, Warner Bros., was basically sweating. They had a hit and no stars. Eventually, they gave Burton total creative control just to get him back. That turned out to be a "be careful what you wish for" situation because what they got was a movie that was way darker, way more sexual, and way less "toy-friendly" than the first one.
What the first draft looked like
Before Daniel Waters came in and made everything "Burton-esque," there was a script by Sam Hamm. This version was a much more traditional Michael Keaton Batman 2. It actually followed up on the first movie.
- Vicki Vale was still around. Bruce was actually going to propose to her.
- The Joker's legacy. There were scenes showing shops selling "remnants" of the Batwing.
- Catwoman and Penguin were just teamed up to find buried treasure.
Burton hated it. He thought it was boring. He wanted a story about "freaks." So, he brought in Waters, and suddenly we have a Penguin who was raised by actual penguins and a Catwoman who was basically a zombie born from feline CPR.
Why "Batman Returns" Changed Everything
When people search for Michael Keaton Batman 2, they’re usually looking for why the tone shifted so hard. If you watch the 1989 film and then Batman Returns back-to-back, it’s jarring. The first one is a noir action flick. The second is an operatic tragedy.
Keaton himself was a huge part of this shift. He famously went through the script and started cutting his own lines. He realized that the less Batman speaks, the more powerful he is. He wanted the suit to do the talking. Honestly, he was right. The scene where he just sits in Wayne Manor waiting for the signal—no dialogue, just brooding—is peak Batman.
The McDonalds Disaster
You can't talk about this movie without the Happy Meal scandal. This is a real thing that happened. McDonalds had a huge tie-in with the film. Then parents actually saw the movie. They saw Danny DeVito oozing black bile and Michelle Pfeiffer putting a live bird in her mouth.
The backlash was so loud that McDonalds had to pull the promotion. This is a huge reason why we never got a "Batman 3" with Keaton and Burton. The studio got scared. They wanted "lighter, brighter, and more toys."
The Canceled "Batman 3" and the 2023 Return
For decades, we wondered what happened to the third movie. We know now it was titled Batman Continues in some circles. It would have featured:
- Robin Williams as The Riddler. He was basically ready to go until the studio got cold feet about the money.
- Marlon Wayans as Robin. He was actually cast and even had a costume fitting. He still gets royalty checks for it today.
- Billy Dee Williams as Two-Face. He had it in his contract from the first movie that he’d play Harvey Dent's dark side.
Instead, the studio hired Joel Schumacher. Keaton met with him, heard the "lighter" vision, and famously asked, "Why does everything have to be so bright?" He walked away from $15 million. He just wouldn't do it if it wasn't the character he knew.
The Flash and the "Modern" Batman 2
Fast forward to 2023. We finally got a sort of Michael Keaton Batman 2 legacy in The Flash. Seeing him back in the suit at 71 years old was wild. It confirmed a few things for fans:
- His Bruce Wayne had retired because Gotham became "the safest city in the world."
- He still had all the suits, including one that looked like the 1939 original.
- He was still the same guy—just a bit more "spaghetti-cooking" eccentric.
There were rumors of a Batman Beyond movie with Keaton as an old Bruce Wayne. It was almost a reality. Christina Hodson was writing it. Then the DC leadership changed again, and the project was shelved. It’s a bummer. Seeing Keaton mentor a new Batman in a futuristic Gotham would have been the perfect closing chapter.
📖 Related: The Don't Worry Be Happy Bob Marley Lyrics Myth: Why Everyone Gets This Song Wrong
What You Should Do Now
If you’re a fan of the Keaton era, don't just stick to the movies.
- Read the "Batman '89" comic series. It’s written by Sam Hamm (the original screenwriter) and it’s basically the "Batman 3" we never got. It features Billy Dee Williams’ version of Two-Face and a very different take on Robin.
- Check out the 4K remasters. Batman Returns looks incredible in 4K. The shadows and the suit textures are way more visible than they were on old VHS tapes.
- Watch the "Shadow of the Bat" documentaries. They’re usually on the Blu-ray extras and they go deep into the fight Keaton had with the studio to keep the character dark.
The legacy of Michael Keaton Batman 2 isn't just about the box office. It's about a time when a director and an actor took a massive risk to make a superhero movie feel like "art," even if it meant losing a Happy Meal deal.