It’s easy to look back at 1960s Hollywood through a lens of soft-focus nostalgia, especially when you’re talking about the woman who played the world’s most famous genie. But the reality behind the scenes for Michael Ansara and Barbara Eden was far more complex than a thirty-minute sitcom.
They were a powerhouse duo. He was the rugged, deep-voiced actor who made a career out of playing iconic figures like Cochise in Broken Arrow and later, the Klingon commander Kang in Star Trek. She was the blonde, bubbly, and incredibly talented star of I Dream of Jeannie. On paper, they were the ultimate Hollywood success story. In reality? Their lives were a whirlwind of sudden fame, shattering personal loss, and a marriage that ultimately couldn't withstand the pressure of a changing industry.
The Blind Date That Started It All
Believe it or not, Michael Ansara and Barbara Eden didn’t meet on a movie set or at a glitzy gala. It was a setup.
Back in 1957, Michael was already a household name thanks to Broken Arrow. Barbara was a rising star at 20th Century Fox. The studio’s publicity department decided that these two attractive, successful people needed to be seen together. It was basically a "PR date."
Honestly, Michael wasn't even that into the idea at first. He was a bit shy and didn't care for the forced nature of studio-arranged romances. Barbara, meanwhile, was actually dating someone else—a non-actor—at the time. But the studio pushed, they went out, and somehow, the fake date turned into something very real. They fell for each other. Hard.
They got married in 1958. For a while, they were the couple everyone wanted to be. They lived in a beautiful home in Studio City and worked together whenever they could. You might remember seeing Michael guest-starring on I Dream of Jeannie. He played the Blue Djinn (the one who originally trapped Jeannie in the bottle) and later, King Kamehameha. Seeing them on screen together was a treat for fans, but it also hinted at the professional overlap that would later become a point of friction.
🔗 Read more: Does Emmanuel Macron Have Children? The Real Story of the French President’s Family Life
The Birth of Matthew and the "Jeannie" Curse
For years, the couple struggled to have a child. It took nearly seven years of trying before Barbara finally got the news she was pregnant.
The timing was wild. She found out she was expecting the exact same day I Dream of Jeannie was sold to the network. Talk about a double-edged sword. She was thrilled, but she was also terrified she’d be fired. This was 1965, after all; being a pregnant leading lady wasn't exactly standard practice.
The legendary Sidney Sheldon didn’t fire her, though. Instead, they filmed the first 13 episodes of the series with Barbara draped in veils and hidden behind oversized props to mask her growing belly. Their son, Matthew Ansara, was born in August 1965. They called him their "lucky-charm baby."
But as Barbara’s career exploded, Michael’s started to shift.
Why the Marriage Finally Cracked
You’ve probably heard people talk about the "earning power" shift in marriages, and in the 1970s, that was a huge deal. As I Dream of Jeannie became a global phenomenon, Barbara was working 16-hour days and bringing home the lion's share of the income. Michael, while still a respected actor, wasn't seeing the same level of consistent, high-profile work.
💡 You might also like: Judge Dana and Keith Cutler: What Most People Get Wrong About TV’s Favorite Legal Couple
The dynamic changed. Resentment is a quiet killer in a marriage, and it started to seep in.
Then came the tragedy that most people forget. In 1971, Barbara became pregnant with their second child. Tragically, the baby was stillborn. The grief was suffocating. Barbara has since spoken about how she went into a deep depression, and Michael, in his own way, was grieving too. They just couldn't find their way back to each other after that. The silence in the house became too loud.
They divorced in 1974 after 16 years. It wasn't a "tabloid" divorce with screaming matches; it was more of a slow fading out of two people who had been through too much together.
The Heartbreak No Parent Should Face
If you really want to understand the bond between Michael Ansara and Barbara Eden, you have to look at how they co-parented Matthew. Even after the divorce, they stayed united for their son.
Matthew was a talented guy—a bodybuilder and an aspiring actor—but he struggled with a heroin addiction for over a decade. He was in and out of rehab 14 times. Barbara later wrote in her memoir, Jeannie Out of the Bottle, about the sheer terror of not knowing if her son was alive or dead on any given night.
📖 Related: The Billy Bob Tattoo: What Angelina Jolie Taught Us About Inking Your Ex
In June 2001, the nightmare became reality. Matthew was found dead in his truck at a gas station in Monrovia, California. He was only 35. He was just months away from his wedding.
Both Michael and Barbara were devastated. Losing a child is a club nobody wants to join, and it tied them together in a tragic way for the rest of Michael's life. He passed away in 2013 at the age of 91, with Barbara often speaking of him with nothing but respect and a sort of bittersweet fondness.
What We Can Learn From Their Story
Looking at the lives of Michael Ansara and Barbara Eden, it’s clear that "having it all" is a myth, even for Hollywood royalty. Their story isn't just about fame; it’s about the grit required to survive loss.
Here are a few takeaways from their journey:
- Communication is everything during grief: The loss of their second child was the beginning of the end for their marriage. Experts often note that couples who don't seek external support after a stillbirth or miscarriage face a significantly higher risk of divorce.
- PR isn't reality: Just because a couple looks perfect on a 1960s magazine cover doesn't mean they aren't struggling with career envy or personal demons.
- Addiction affects everyone: No amount of money or "Jeannie" magic could protect their son from the opioid crisis. Their openness about Matthew's struggle eventually helped de-stigmatize the issue for other parents.
If you're interested in the deeper history of classic Hollywood, the best thing you can do is read Barbara Eden’s autobiography. It’s raw, it’s honest, and it strips away the "genie" persona to show the woman who stood beside Michael Ansara through some of the brightest and darkest days in Tinseltown history.
For those looking to honor their legacy, supporting organizations like MusiCares or local addiction recovery programs is a meaningful way to turn their personal tragedy into a tool for helping others.