When you think about the Miami Dolphins, your mind probably goes straight to 1972. It’s unavoidable. The 17-0 season is the sun that every other year in franchise history orbits. But if you look at the Miami Dolphins all time record as it stands today, entering 2026, there’s a much more complex story than just one perfect winter.
This is a franchise that spent decades as the winningest team in professional sports, only to spend the last twenty years fighting like hell just to get back to a conference championship game.
By the Numbers: The Regular Season Grind
As of the conclusion of the 2025 season, the Dolphins' regular-season record is roughly 483-395. That gives them a winning percentage of about .550. Honestly, for a team that has felt "mediocre" to younger fans for a long time, that number is still incredibly high. Why? Because the Don Shula era was so dominant it basically padded the stats for the next half-century.
Under Shula, the Dolphins weren't just winning; they were a machine. From 1970 to 1995, Shula racked up 257 regular-season wins in Miami alone. When he retired, the Dolphins had the highest winning percentage in the history of the league. It's taken a lot of 7-9 and 8-8 seasons since then to drag that average down to where it is now.
The 2025 season itself was a bit of a rollercoaster. Under Mike McDaniel, the team finished 7-10, struggling with a brutal 1-6 start before finding some rhythm in the middle of the year. They were officially knocked out of the playoff hunt after a Week 15 loss to the Steelers. It was the second year in a row without January football in South Florida.
The Postseason: Peaks and Long Valleys
The Miami Dolphins all time record in the playoffs is where the frustration really sets in for the Dolfans. Historically, they are 20-23 in the postseason.
✨ Don't miss: The Detroit Lions Game Recap That Proves This Team Is Different
If you break that down, it’s a tale of two very different cities.
- Super Bowls: 2 wins (1972, 1973) in 5 appearances.
- Conference Championships: 5-2 record.
- The Drought: This is the stat that hurts. The Dolphins haven't won a playoff game since December 30, 2000. That was a 23-17 overtime win against the Indianapolis Colts.
Think about that. There are adults with college degrees and mortgages who have never seen the Dolphins win a playoff game. Since that win over Lamar Smith and the Colts, the Dolphins have made the playoffs six times (2001, 2008, 2016, 2022, 2023) and lost every single time in the Wild Card round.
The 2023 loss to the Kansas City Chiefs in the freezing cold of Arrowhead was particularly stinging. It felt like the "offensive juggernaut" era under McDaniel was finally going to break the curse. Instead, it was another early exit.
The Coaching Carousel: From Shula to McDaniel
You can't talk about the record without talking about the guys on the sidelines. The discrepancy here is wild.
Don Shula (1970–1995): The GOAT. 257 regular-season wins. 17 playoff wins. Two rings. He had exactly two losing seasons in 26 years. Basically, if Shula was your coach, you were planning for the playoffs in August.
🔗 Read more: The Chicago Bears Hail Mary Disaster: Why Tyrique Stevenson and Bad Luck Changed a Season
The Post-Shula Era: Since 1996, the Dolphins have had a rotating door of coaches.
- Jimmy Johnson was respectable (36-28) but couldn't get Marino that elusive second Super Bowl trip.
- Dave Wannstedt actually has a great winning percentage (.575), but he’s remembered for the collapse that followed.
- The Dark Years: Nick Saban (.469) used the team as a bridge to Alabama. Cam Cameron went 1-15.
- The Modern Era: Brian Flores brought some grit but no playoffs. Mike McDaniel (35-33 through 2025) has brought the most excitement since the 90s, but that 7-10 finish in 2025 has some fans wondering if the "Mad Scientist" has been figured out.
Why the Record Matters (and What Most People Get Wrong)
Most fans look at the Miami Dolphins all time record and think "Perfect Season" or "Marino's Arm." But the real backbone of the record was the defense.
The 1972 "No-Name Defense" allowed only 171 points all year. That’s about 12 points a game. In the 80s, the "Killer B’s" (Bob Baumhower, Bill Barnett, etc.) kept the team afloat while Marino was busy rewriting the record books.
The misconception is that Miami has always been this high-flying, flashy team because of the Dan Marino years. In reality, the most successful eras of the Dolphins record were built on elite offensive line play (think Jim Langer and Larry Little) and a defense that didn't break.
The current team is trying to get back to that balance. The 2023 team scored 70 points in a single game against Denver—a franchise record—but they still finished 11-6 and lost in the first round. Scoring 70 is cool; winning in January is better.
💡 You might also like: Steelers News: Justin Fields and the 2026 Quarterback Reality
What’s Next for the Record?
If you’re looking at the trajectory of the franchise, the next few seasons are make-or-break. The Miami Dolphins all time record is currently hovering in a spot where they are still "historically good," but they are losing ground to teams like the Steelers and Patriots in the "all-time winningest" conversation.
To fix the record and the reputation, the focus has to shift:
- Home Field Dominance: Hard Rock Stadium needs to become a fortress again. Historically, the heat in Miami was a weapon. Recently, it feels like visiting teams are just as comfortable there.
- Division Stability: You can't fix the all-time record while losing to the Buffalo Bills twice a year. The AFC East has been a thorn in Miami's side since the Brady era began, and it hasn't let up.
- Health at QB: Tua Tagovailoa's availability has been the single biggest variable in the record over the last four years. When he plays, they win at a .600+ clip. When he’s out, it’s a struggle.
Practical Steps for Fans Tracking the Record
If you want to keep a pulse on where this franchise is heading, don't just look at the W-L column.
- Monitor the Defensive EPA: In the modern NFL, the Dolphins' record lives and dies by their ability to get pressure without blitzing.
- Check the "Late Season" Stats: Miami has a nasty habit of wilting in December. If they can't improve their record in games where the temperature is below 40 degrees, they will never improve their playoff record.
- Watch the Turnover Margin: During the Shula years, Miami was almost always "plus" in turnovers. Over the last three seasons, they've been inconsistent. Winning the turnover battle is the fastest way to pad that all-time win total.
The Dolphins are at a crossroads. They have the history, the colors, and the "Perfect" label. But the record is more than a trophy case from the 70s—it’s a living document that needs some fresh, winning ink in the playoff section.