Honestly, it is hard to talk about modern horror without someone bringing up that one frame. You know the one. The final shot of Mia Goth as Pearl, her face frozen in a terrifying, tear-streaked rictus of a smile that lasts way longer than any comfortable person would want. It is a moment that turned a $1 million indie prequel into a genuine cultural reset.
Most people saw the memes before they saw the movie. But if you actually sit down and watch what Ti West and Goth pulled off, you realize it wasn't just a "scary movie" fluke. It was a masterclass in character study that the Oscars basically ignored because, well, it had a pitchfork in it.
The Secret Sauce of Mia Goth as Pearl
There is a weird misconception that Pearl was just a quick cash-grab shot after X. That is totally wrong. While they did film them back-to-back in New Zealand, the character of young Pearl was actually being built in the shadows for months.
Mia Goth didn't just show up and scream. She actually co-wrote the script with Ti West. Think about that. How many "scream queens" are literally architecting the trauma of their characters on a FaceTime call during a two-week COVID-19 quarantine? That is exactly how it happened. They were stuck in a hotel, spitballing ideas about why an old woman in 1979 would be so obsessed with being loved.
Why the Technicolor look matters
If you look at the visuals, it’s basically The Wizard of Oz if Dorothy had a psychotic break. They used these hyper-saturated, vivid colors—bright reds, deep blues—to mimic the Golden Age of Hollywood. It makes the violence feel twice as nasty because it’s happening in a world that looks like a Disney postcard. Pearl isn't a "monster" in her own head. She is a star. She's the hero of a musical that nobody else is singing along to.
💡 You might also like: World War I Films: Why We Can’t Stop Watching the Great War
That Monologue (You Know the One)
We have to talk about the confession. Near the end of the film, Pearl sits down and delivers an unbroken, eight-minute monologue to her sister-in-law, Mitsy.
It is 2026 and people are still studying this scene in acting classes. Here’s why it worked:
- The Unbroken Shot: Ti West didn't cut away. Not once. For nearly eight minutes, the camera stays on Goth’s face. There’s nowhere to hide.
- The Emotional Shift: She goes from "I’m a failure" to "I loathed the feeling of it growing inside me" (talking about her pregnancy) with a chilling level of honesty.
- The Lack of Makeup: Unlike her role in X, where she was under pounds of prosthetics, this was just Mia. Just her eyes and her voice.
Goth has mentioned in interviews that she was terrified of this scene. She practiced it every single night during the shoot. They saved it for the very last day of filming because she needed to "carry" all the emotional garbage Pearl had accumulated throughout the story. It paid off. It’s arguably one of the most technical pieces of acting in the last decade.
What People Get Wrong About the "Oscars Snub"
When the 2023 Oscar nominations came out and Mia Goth’s name wasn't there, the internet basically melted down. Even Martin Scorsese went on record saying he was "enthralled and disturbed" by the movie.
Goth herself didn't hold back either. She pointed out that the Academy's snub of horror is "very political." It isn't about the quality of the work; it’s about the "cooks in the kitchen" and the fact that horror is still seen as a "lesser" genre. It's a shame, really. If you took that same eight-minute monologue and put it in a period drama about a grieving widow without the murders, she would have had a golden statue on her mantelpiece.
The Joker for Women?
There is a funny trend online where fans call Pearl "Joker for women." It sounds like a joke, but there’s a kernel of truth there. Both films deal with a protagonist who is systematically crushed by a society that has no place for them. Pearl is trapped by the Spanish Flu, a paralyzed father, a bitter mother, and a husband away at war. She is "stuck," and her explosion of violence is a desperate, albeit horrific, attempt to finally be seen.
👉 See also: The Bear and Me Book: Why This Simple Story Still Hits So Hard
Actionable Takeaways for Cinephiles
If you're looking to really appreciate what went into this performance, here is how you should revisit the "X-traordinary" trilogy:
- Watch the credits: Do not turn off the movie when the screen goes black. The credits of Pearl are a continuation of the performance. Goth held that strained smile for minutes while the crew moved around her. It’s the ultimate "the mask is slipping" moment.
- Compare the "Pearl" and "Maxine" parallels: Since Goth plays both characters across the trilogy (including MaXXXine), look for the mirrored movements. The way they dance, the way they look in the mirror—it’s all intentional.
- Read the script beats: Look for the moments where Pearl tries to be "good." The tragedy isn't that she’s evil; it’s that she really, really tried to be the person her mother wanted, and she simply couldn't do it.
The legacy of Mia Goth as Pearl isn't just about the memes or the "I'm a star" line. It’s about a performer taking full agency over her character, from the writing room to the final, haunting frame. It proved that horror doesn't need jump scares to be terrifying; sometimes, you just need a girl, a pitchfork, and a dream that won't die.