Mexico is tired.
Walk through the Roma Norte neighborhood in Mexico City or the winding alleys of Oaxaca, and you’ll see it. It’s written on the walls—literally. Graffiti shouting "Gringo Go Home" or "Stay Home, Digital Nomad" isn't just a random act of teenage rebellion anymore. It's a symptom. For decades, the relationship between Mexico and its visitors was a simple, happy equation: sun and tacos in exchange for dollars and pesos. But lately, that math isn't adding up for the locals. Mexico is falling out of love with tourists, and if you’ve been paying attention to the rising rents and the dry taps in Mexico City, you probably understand why.
It’s not that Mexicans have suddenly become "unfriendly." That’s a lazy take. The reality is much more grounded in the physical struggle of surviving in a city that is being redesigned for people who don’t actually live there.
The Airbnb Paradox and the Death of the Vecindad
Imagine living in the same apartment for twenty years. You know the lady who sells tamales on the corner, and the guy at the tiendita knows your kids' names. Then, almost overnight, your landlord doubles the rent. Why? Because a guy from California or Berlin is willing to pay three times your monthly salary to stay there for five days.
This isn't a theory; it's the daily reality in Mexico City’s Cuauhtémoc borough. According to data from various housing advocacy groups like Calle Sin Nombre, gentrification has pushed thousands of long-term residents to the far edges of the city. When we say Mexico is falling out of love with tourists, we are specifically talking about the "touristification" of housing.
In 2022, the Mexico City government signed a deal with Airbnb to promote the city as a "global hub for remote workers." The backlash was immediate and fierce. Locals watched as traditional vecindades—communal housing blocks—were gutted and turned into sleek, minimalist lofts with high-speed internet and Nespresso machines. The "Digital Nomad" became the face of a new kind of invasion. Honestly, it’s hard to love a visitor when their presence means you can no longer afford to live in your childhood neighborhood.
Water Wars and the Environmental Toll
Let’s talk about the water. Or the lack of it.
Mexico City is sinking. It’s built on a dry lakebed, and the aquifers are being pumped bone-dry. In early 2024, the Cutzamala System—the massive network of reservoirs supplying the city—hit record lows. Some neighborhoods went weeks without a drop. Yet, if you go to a high-end hotel in Polanco or a luxury Airbnb in Condesa, the showers work perfectly. The pools are full.
💡 You might also like: The Largest Spider in the World: What Most People Get Wrong
There is a visceral anger that grows when you are rationing water to flush your toilet while the "slow traveler" next door is taking a twenty-minute hot shower. This resource disparity is a massive reason why Mexico is falling out of love with tourists. It feels like a zero-sum game. Every gallon used by a resort in Tulum or a high-rise in the capital is a gallon taken from a local farmer or a family in a marginalized colonia.
In Quintana Roo, the situation is even more visible. The "Mayan Train" (Tren Maya) project, championed by the government to bring tourists deeper into the peninsula, has been a lightning rod for controversy. Environmentalists and indigenous communities have pointed out the destruction of underground caves (cenotes) and the fragmentation of jaguar habitats. To many, the train represents a sacrifice of the land's soul for the sake of an extra few thousand hotel rooms.
The "Colonial" Vibe vs. Reality
There is a weird tension in how Mexico is marketed. Travel influencers post photos of "charming, colorful streets" and "authentic experiences." But that authenticity is often a performance staged for people with stronger currencies.
Take San Miguel de Allende. It’s beautiful. It’s also essentially an American retirement colony in the heart of Guanajuato. When a town’s economy shifts entirely to serve foreigners, the local culture starts to feel like a museum exhibit rather than a living, breathing thing. You’ll find shops selling "artisanal" goods at prices no local could ever afford.
This creates a "servant economy."
When the only jobs available to locals are cleaning those Airbnbs or serving margaritas, the social fabric starts to fray. The resentment isn't about the people themselves—it’s about the power dynamic. It’s hard to feel a "brotherhood of man" when one person is carrying the luggage and the other is complaining that the guacamole isn't "organic enough."
Is the Safety Issue Playing a Role?
People often ask if the violence in Mexico is why the love affair is ending. Kinda, but not in the way you think.
📖 Related: Sumela Monastery: Why Most People Get the History Wrong
Usually, the news focuses on how violence affects tourists. But the locals see it differently. They see "tourist bubbles" protected by heavy police presence and National Guard troops, while the rest of the city or state is left to deal with rising crime. In places like Acapulco or even parts of Cancun, there’s a feeling that the government only cares about security when it threatens the "tourism brand."
When a shooting happens on a beach in Playa del Carmen, the immediate government response is usually to reassure international travelers that "they aren't the target." It’s an insensitive message to the locals who are the targets of extortion and everyday crime. This "tourism-first" policy makes residents feel like second-class citizens in their own country.
The Economic Mirage
"But they bring so much money!"
That’s the standard defense. And yeah, tourism accounts for about 8.5% of Mexico’s GDP. That’s billions of dollars. But look closer at where that money goes.
A lot of it "leaks" out.
When you stay at a massive Spanish-owned resort chain in the Riviera Maya, a huge chunk of that profit goes back to Europe. The food is often imported. The profits are offshore. The local worker gets a minimum wage salary and maybe some tips if they’re lucky. This is known as "economic leakage," and it’s a big reason why the promise of tourism-led prosperity feels like a lie to many Mexicans.
The money that does stay often stays in very specific pockets. It doesn't fix the potholes in the outskirts of Tulum. It doesn't fund the schools in the mountains of Chiapas.
👉 See also: Sheraton Grand Nashville Downtown: The Honest Truth About Staying Here
A Shift in the "Gringo" Perception
For a long time, the "Gringo" was just a visitor who stayed for a week, got a sunburn, bought a ceramic donkey, and went home. They were temporary.
Now, with the rise of remote work, they are semi-permanent. They aren't just visiting; they are moving in. And many of them aren't bothering to learn the language or integrate. They are creating little "Expat" enclaves where English is the primary language and the prices are listed in USD.
This isn't just about Mexico being "grumpy." It’s a global phenomenon seen in Lisbon, Barcelona, and Venice. But in Mexico, with its complex history with the United States, it feels more pointed. It feels like a new type of colonization—one led by laptops instead of bayonets.
Can the Relationship Be Fixed?
It’s not all doom and gloom. Mexico hasn't "broken up" with tourists yet, but it’s definitely in the "we need to talk" phase.
Some cities are fighting back. In Mexico City, there are growing movements calling for stricter regulations on short-term rentals. There is a push to tax digital nomads to fund local infrastructure. There are "de-gentrification" collectives working to keep traditional businesses alive.
The "love" can return, but it needs to be a partnership of equals, not a lopsided arrangement where one side gets a cheap vacation and the other side loses their home.
How to Be a Better Guest in Mexico
If you’re reading this and planning a trip, don't cancel your flight. Just change your approach. The fact that Mexico is falling out of love with tourists should be a wake-up call to travel more ethically. It’s about being a guest, not a consumer.
- Skip the Airbnb, find a local hotel: Boutique hotels or family-run guesthouses (posadas) keep more money in the community and don't contribute as directly to the housing crisis.
- Learn the basics: If you can’t order your coffee in Spanish after living there for three months, you’re part of the problem.
- Eat at the mercado: Avoid the "Instagram-famous" cafes that look like they belong in Brooklyn. Go where the locals eat. The food is better anyway.
- Acknowledge the water crisis: Be mindful. Don’t waste resources just because you "paid for it."
- Get out of the bubbles: Visit states like Tlaxcala, Durango, or Veracruz that aren't overrun. They actually want the economic boost and haven't reached the "saturation point" yet.
The honeymoon period is over. Mexico is demanding respect, sustainability, and a fair share of the pie. If we can’t give that, we shouldn't be surprised when the welcome mat is eventually pulled away for good.
Actionable Steps for the Conscious Traveler:
- Audit your accommodation: Check if your stay is a "professional" Airbnb (an apartment that used to be a home) or a legitimate hospitality business. Use platforms like FairBnB if available.
- Support Local Advocacy: Follow groups like Observatorio de Derechos en la Ciudad to understand local housing struggles before you settle in a neighborhood.
- Tipping Matters, but Wage Advocacy Matters More: Tip well, but support businesses that pay a living wage to their staff without relying solely on the "generosity" of foreigners.
- Register as a Resident: If you are staying long-term, do it legally. Pay the fees. Pay into the system that provides the services you are using.