You see it everywhere. From the crowded subways of Tokyo to the sun-drenched streets of Barcelona, that interlocking NY is inescapable. But here is the thing: half the people wearing it probably couldn't name the Yankees' starting shortstop if their lives depended on it.
To them, it’s not a baseball team. It’s a brand. It's a vibe. It's basically the unofficial flag of New York City.
Then you have the Mets. Their logo is a literal skyline, a colorful, circular badge of honor that screams "I actually live here." It’s busy, it’s orange, and it’s deeply sentimental. When you compare the Mets vs Yankees logo, you aren't just looking at two different designs for two different teams. You are looking at two completely different philosophies of what it means to represent the Big Apple.
The Tiffany Connection Most People Forget
Most fans think the Yankees logo was born in a dugout. Honestly, it wasn't. The origins are way weirder and more "High Society" than you’d expect for a team from the Bronx.
In 1877, long before the Yankees even existed, Louis B. Tiffany (yes, of Tiffany & Co.) designed a silver Medal of Valor for the NYPD. It was meant to honor John McDowell, the first New York City police officer shot in the line of duty. The design featured a small, stylized, interlocking NY at the top.
Fast forward to 1909. Bill Devery, a former police chief turned co-owner of the team (then called the Highlanders), decided to "borrow" the design. He thought it looked sharp. He was right.
📖 Related: Matthew Berry Positional Rankings: Why They Still Run the Fantasy Industry
What’s wild is that the Yankees actually ditched the logo for a while. They went with just pinstripes on their jerseys from 1917 to 1936. Legends like Babe Ruth and Lou Gehrig never actually wore the interlocking NY on their home jerseys. They only wore it on their caps. It wasn't until 1936 that the logo returned to the chest, becoming the permanent face of the franchise.
The Mets Logo is a Hidden Map
If the Yankees logo is a minimalist masterpiece, the Mets logo is a detailed mural. Created by sports cartoonist Ray Gotto in 1961, the Mets' primary circular logo is basically a love letter to the history of New York baseball.
The colors? They aren't random. The blue is "Dodger Blue" and the orange is "Giant Orange." It was a deliberate move to win over the heartbroken fans left behind when the Brooklyn Dodgers and New York Giants fled to California in 1957.
But look closer at that skyline. It isn't just a generic silhouette of buildings. Every structure was hand-picked:
- The Church Spire: Represents Brooklyn, the "Borough of Churches."
- Williamsburgh Savings Bank: At the time, it was the tallest building in Brooklyn.
- Woolworth Building: A nod to lower Manhattan’s history.
- Empire State Building: Obviously.
- United Nations Building: Representing the world stage of NYC.
The white bridge in the foreground? That’s meant to be a suspension bridge—symbolizing that the Mets "bridge" the gap between all five boroughs. It’s deeply literal. While the Yankees represent the idea of New York to the world, the Mets represent the geography of New York to the locals.
👉 See also: What Time Did the Cubs Game End Today? The Truth About the Off-Season
Why the Yankees Won the Global Branding War
Ever wondered why you never see "Mets" hats in a Parisian fashion magazine? It comes down to the "Spike Lee Factor."
In 1996, the director called up New Era and asked for a custom red Yankees hat to match his jacket for the World Series. Up until that point, you could only buy team-color hats. That one phone call changed everything. It turned the Yankees logo from a sports uniform into a fashion accessory.
The Yankees logo is symmetrical, clean, and—crucially—monochromatic. It looks good on a leather jacket or a high-end hoodie. The Mets logo, with its bright orange and blue and script lettering, is a lot harder to pull off unless you're actually at a ballgame.
Logo Variations: The Small Details That Drive Fans Crazy
There isn't just one Yankees logo. There are three.
- The Cap Logo: Thin, elegant letters where the 'N' and 'Y' are roughly the same size.
- The Jersey Logo: Blockier, thicker, and the 'Y' is noticeably larger.
- The Print Logo: The one with the red-white-and-blue top hat on a bat, created by Lon Keller in 1946.
Mets fans have their own quirks. They wear an interlocking NY on their caps too, but it’s different. The Mets' 'N' and 'Y' have little "serifs" or hooks on them, a style lifted almost exactly from the old New York Giants. If you see an orange NY on a blue hat, that’s a Mets fan. If you see white on navy, that’s the Yankees.
✨ Don't miss: Jake Ehlinger Sign: The Real Story Behind the College GameDay Controversy
The Actionable Insight: Which One Should You Wear?
Choosing between these two isn't just about baseball records. It's about what you want to communicate to the world.
If you want a timeless fashion icon that blends into any wardrobe and signals a connection to "Global New York," the Yankees cap is the gold standard. It’s the logo of winners, history, and—let's be real—high-end street style.
If you want to signal that you are a die-hard New Yorker who knows the history of the boroughs, go with the Mets. It’s the "insider" choice. It’s for the person who values the underdog story and the deep, specific roots of the city over global recognition.
Next Step for You: Check the tags on your gear. If you’re buying a Yankees hat for the look, stick with the classic Navy and White for maximum versatility. If you’re going for the Mets look, try to find the "Cooperstown Collection" versions—the vintage embroidery on those old-school skyline logos captures the 1960s aesthetic much better than the modern flat prints.