It’s the greatest "what if" in the history of heavy metal. Honestly, it might be the greatest "what if" in music, period. You’ve seen the Some Kind of Monster footage where a teary-eyed Dave Mustaine confronts Lars Ulrich about being "Number Two." It’s uncomfortable. It’s raw. But to understand Metallica with Dave Mustaine, you have to go back way before the therapy sessions and the multi-platinum records. You have to go back to 1982, to a crusty garage in Norwalk and a transition that changed the DNA of thrash metal forever.
Dave didn't just play in Metallica. He was the attitude.
James Hetfield was painfully shy back then. He didn't even want to be the frontman; he just wanted to play rhythm guitar. When Mustaine showed up to the audition after seeing an ad in The Recycler, he didn't even have to play. He was unpacking his gear, and the guys just looked at him and knew. He had the look. He had the gear. He had the terrifying, jagged speed that nobody else in the Bay Area—or anywhere else—was doing yet.
The Sound of 1982: Why Mustaine Changed Everything
Before Dave, Metallica was basically a British Invasion cover band trying to find its feet. They were playing Diamond Head and Blitzkrieg covers. Once Mustaine joined, the tempo shifted. He brought a sense of danger. If you listen to the No Life 'til Leather demo, you aren't hearing the polished, stadium-filling Metallica of the 90s. You’re hearing a feral, high-gain explosion.
Mustaine’s lead style was chaotic. Unlike Kirk Hammett, who brought a melodic, blues-based shred style influenced by Joe Satriani, Dave played like he was trying to saw the neck off the guitar. It was chromatic, messy, and insanely fast. It forced James to become a better rhythm player just to keep up with the sheer velocity Dave was pushing from the other side of the stage.
People often forget how much of Kill 'Em All is actually Dave. He has writing credits on four of the ten tracks: "The Four Horsemen" (originally "The Mechanix"), "Jump in the Fire," "Phantom Lord," and "Metal Militia." But his influence is all over the "feel" of that record.
He was the one pushing the boundaries of what "fast" meant.
📖 Related: Big Brother 27 Morgan: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
The Drinking, the Dogs, and the Greyhound Bus
The stories are legendary, mostly because they’re true. The chemistry was volatile. You had four young guys—James, Lars, Dave, and Ron McGovney (the original bassist)—living in cramped quarters, fueled by cheap beer and a desperate need to be famous.
The breaking point wasn't just one thing. It was a slow burn. There was the infamous "dog incident" at Ron McGovney's house, where Dave’s dog allegedly scratched the paint on Ron's car, James kicked the dog, and a massive physical altercation ensued. Then there was the time Dave poured beer into Ron’s bass pickups, effectively frying his electronics.
But the real issue was the clashing of alphas.
James and Lars were the architects. Dave was a leader who didn't want to follow. In April 1983, while the band was in New York to record their debut album, the decision was made. They woke Dave up, handed him a bus ticket, and told him he was out. No warning. No second chances.
Imagine that. You’re in a band that's about to change the world. You've written half the material. And suddenly, you’re on a four-day Greyhound bus ride back to Los Angeles with nothing but your guitar and a chip on your shoulder the size of a mountain.
The Four Horsemen vs. The Mechanix
If you want to hear the difference between Metallica with Dave Mustaine and the Metallica that became a global powerhouse, you just have to compare "The Mechanix" to "The Four Horsemen."
👉 See also: The Lil Wayne Tracklist for Tha Carter 3: What Most People Get Wrong
Mustaine’s original version, which appeared on No Life 'til Leather and later on Megadeth's Killing Is My Business... and Business Is Good!, is played at a breakneck, almost unhinged speed. It’s a song about a gas station encounter, pure and simple.
When Metallica recorded it for Kill 'Em All, they slowed it down. They added the melodic middle section (which Dave famously claims he didn't write and hated). They changed the lyrics to be about the apocalypse. This perfectly encapsulates the divide: Mustaine was about raw, visceral speed and technical aggression. Hetfield and Ulrich were about structure, hooks, and "the epic."
What Most People Get Wrong About the Split
There’s this common misconception that Dave was fired purely because he drank too much.
Let's be real. It was 1983. Everyone in Metallica was drinking too much. They were literally nicknamed "Alcoholica." The real reason was behavioral. When Dave drank, he became "The Dangerous One." He was confrontational in a way that James and Lars—who were already developing their own tight-knit partnership—couldn't manage.
Also, we have to talk about Kirk Hammett.
Kirk was the perfect foil for James. He was easy-going, he took direction, and his lead playing provided a "singable" quality to the thrash songs that Dave’s playing lacked. Without the switch to Kirk, Metallica might have stayed a niche underground act. But without the foundation Dave laid, they wouldn't have had the "teeth" to get noticed in the first place.
✨ Don't miss: Songs by Tyler Childers: What Most People Get Wrong
The Legacy of the 11-Month Tenure
Does Dave Mustaine still matter to the Metallica story? Absolutely.
Even on Ride the Lightning, Mustaine has writing credits on the title track and "The Call of Ktulu." Think about that. He had been out of the band for a year by the time that album came out, yet his fingerprints were still on their most progressive work. His use of complex, spider-chord structures and "evil" sounding diminished riffs became a staple of the Metallica sound long after he was gone.
The tension between them fueled the entire "Big Four" rivalry. Without the anger of being fired, Dave might never have formed Megadeth. He might never have pushed himself to become one of the most technical rhythm guitarists in history. The rejection was the fuel.
Practical Takeaways from the Metallica-Mustaine Saga
If you’re a musician or just a fan of rock history, there are actually some pretty heavy lessons to be learned from this specific era.
- Chemistry beats talent every time. Dave was arguably the most talented guy in the room in 1982, but he didn't fit the culture. A band is a marriage, not a talent show.
- Ownership matters. Dave’s struggle with his credits on those early songs lasted decades. If you're creating, get the "who wrote what" sorted early, even if you’re just kids in a garage.
- Rejection is a pivot, not an end. Mustaine could have quit. Instead, he founded a band that sold 38 million albums.
- Listen to the demos. To truly understand the evolution of the genre, find the No Life 'til Leather bootlegs. You can hear the exact moment where NWOBHM (New Wave of British Heavy Metal) turned into American Thrash.
The era of Metallica with Dave Mustaine was short, chaotic, and loud. It was less than a year. But in that brief window, they created a blueprint for an entire subculture. You can still hear it today in every down-picked riff and every palm-muted chug. It’s the sound of three guys who wanted to be the biggest band in the world, and one guy who was just too restless to stay for the ride.
To truly appreciate where Metallica is now, you have to value that friction from 1982. Friction creates fire. And in this case, it created a blaze that’s still burning forty years later.
Actionable Next Steps:
- Compare the Tracks: Listen to "The Mechanix" from Megadeth's debut and then "The Four Horsemen" from Kill 'Em All back-to-back. Pay attention to the tempo and the "vibe" of the solos.
- Watch the 2011 Footage: Look up the videos of the Metallica 30th Anniversary shows at the Fillmore where Dave joined them on stage. It provides the necessary emotional closure to this story, showing the "Big 4" elder statesmen finally making peace with their shared history.
- Audit the Credits: Look at the liner notes for Kill 'Em All and Ride the Lightning. Note exactly which riffs were Mustaine's; it will change how you hear those "classic" Metallica hooks forever.