Menudo: What Is It and Why Do People Either Love or Fear It?

Menudo: What Is It and Why Do People Either Love or Fear It?

It is a Saturday morning in a bustling Mexican market. You’ll see it everywhere. Steam rises from massive stainless steel pots, carrying a scent that is earthy, pungent, and deeply savory. People are hunched over bowls, sweating slightly, squeezing limes with a sort of religious intensity. If you’ve ever wondered menudo what is it exactly, you’re looking at Mexico’s most polarizing culinary icon. It is the ultimate "love it or hate it" dish. There is no middle ground here.

Menudo is a traditional Mexican soup made with cow's stomach (tripe) in a broth with a red chili pepper base. That’s the clinical definition. But honestly? It’s a cultural touchstone. It is a weekend ritual. It’s the "hangover cure" whispered about in hushed, desperate tones after a wedding or a long night at the cantina. For some, the texture of the tripe—chewy, honeycomb-like, and distinct—is a dealbreaker. For others, it’s the very soul of the dish.

The Anatomy of the Bowl: What’s Actually Inside?

When people ask menudo what is it, they are usually asking about the meat. Let’s be real: we’re talking about offal. Specifically, the lining of a cow's stomach. Usually, a good menudo uses a mix of "honeycomb" tripe (reticulum) and "flat" tripe (rumen). The honeycomb is the prize; it holds the broth in its little pockets like a sponge.

But the broth is where the magic happens.

It isn’t just water and chili. A proper menudo rojo starts with a base of dried chilies—usually Guajillo for color and mild fruitiness, and Ancho for that deep, smoky backbone. Some cooks throw in Arbol chilies if they want to punish you a little bit with heat. Then comes the aromatics: garlic, onion, and a healthy dose of Mexican oregano.

Then there’s the "extras." You’ll often find pig's feet (pata) or beef knuckles tossed into the pot. They aren't just there for decoration. They release gelatin as they simmer for hours, giving the broth a rich, lip-smacking thickness that you just can't get from a bouillon cube.

✨ Don't miss: How to Sign Someone Up for Scientology: What Actually Happens and What You Need to Know

White vs. Red: The Great Menudo Divide

Depending on where you are or who your abuela is, the soup looks totally different. In the northern states of Mexico and parts of the Southwest US, you’ll find Menudo Blanco. It skips the red chili paste entirely. It’s clear, clean, and relies heavily on the quality of the tripe and a punch of pepper and garlic.

The most common version, however, is Menudo Rojo. This is the deep crimson bowl you see on Instagram. It’s bolder. It’s more aggressive.

And then we have the hominy debate.
Menudo Estilo Jalisco usually includes nixtamalized corn (hominy), which adds a nice, chewy contrast to the soft tripe. However, purists in other regions—like Chihuahua or parts of Texas—will tell you that adding corn makes it "Pozole with tripe," not true menudo. People will actually fight over this at family gatherings. It’s serious business.

Why Do People Call it a Hangover Cure?

Science sort of backs this up, though mostly it’s about how it makes you feel. Menudo is incredibly high in protein and B vitamins. When you’ve spent the night dehydrating yourself with tequila, your body is screaming for salts, fats, and minerals.

The gelatin from the bones soothes the stomach lining. The capsaicin from the chilies triggers an endorphin rush. It clears the sinuses. It wakes up the senses. Is it a miracle? Maybe not. But when you’re sitting there with a headache and a bowl of steaming menudo, it feels like a resurrection.

🔗 Read more: Wire brush for cleaning: What most people get wrong about choosing the right bristles

The Preparation: A Labor of Love (and Patience)

You can't rush this. You just can't.

If you try to cook menudo in an hour, you’re going to be chewing on rubber bands. Authentic menudo takes anywhere from four to seven hours of slow simmering. The tripe has to be cleaned meticulously—this is the part most home cooks hate. It involves scrubbing, soaking in lime juice or vinegar, and multiple rinses to ensure that "barnyard" smell is gone, leaving only a mild, clean flavor.

Most families make it on Friday night so it’s ready for Saturday or Sunday morning. It’s a communal event. It’s the food of the "after-party" or the slow Sunday morning.

The Toppings: The Final Layer

A bowl of menudo is incomplete without the "garden" on top. You never just eat it plain. You’re expected to customize it.

  • Fresh Lime: Essential. The acidity cuts through the heavy fat of the broth.
  • Chopped Raw Onion: For crunch and a sharp bite.
  • Cilantro: For freshness.
  • Crushed Dried Oregano: You rub it between your palms over the bowl to release the oils.
  • Dried Chili Flakes: If the broth wasn't spicy enough for you.

And you must have bolillo (crusty Mexican bread) or warm corn tortillas on the side. Some people even spread a little butter on the bolillo and dunk it straight into the red broth. It’s heaven.

💡 You might also like: Images of Thanksgiving Holiday: What Most People Get Wrong

Health and Nutrition: The Surprising Truth

Despite being "gut soup," menudo is actually pretty decent for you if you don't overdo the tortillas. A standard serving is relatively low in calories compared to a greasy burger, and it’s packed with collagen. Collagen is the "it" supplement in the beauty world right now for skin and joints, but Mexican grandmothers have been serving it in soup form for centuries.

One thing to watch out for is cholesterol. Tripe is an organ meat, so it’s higher in cholesterol than a chicken breast. But as a once-a-week treat? It’s a nutrient-dense powerhouse.

Where to Find the Good Stuff

If you’re looking to try it for the first time, don’t go to a fast-food joint. Look for a "Mom and Pop" fonda or a Mexican restaurant that only serves it on weekends. That’s the "Menudo Sign." If a place has it on the menu 24/7, it might be canned or frozen (yes, canned menudo exists, but we don't talk about that).

The best menudo comes from a pot so big the cook needs a literal paddle to stir it.

Making it at Home: A Quick Reality Check

If you’re brave enough to make it yourself, here is the real-world advice nobody tells you: open the windows. Even the cleanest tripe has a very specific aroma when it first starts boiling. It’s pungent. Some people find it comforting; others find it overwhelming.

  1. Buy "Cleaned" Tripe: Most modern butchers sell it bleached and cleaned. It saves you hours of work.
  2. The First Boil: Boil the tripe for 30 minutes, then throw that water away. Start fresh. This removes the strongest "off" flavors.
  3. Don't Salt Too Early: As the broth reduces, the salt concentrates. Wait until the end.
  4. The "Pata" is Key: Even if you don't want to eat the pig's foot, put it in for the texture it gives the soup. You can fish it out later.

Actionable Next Steps

If you’re ready to cross menudo off your bucket list, start small. Find a local Mexican carniceria or a highly-rated "hole-in-the-wall" restaurant this coming Sunday morning. Ask for a "small" bowl of Menudo Rojo with hominy (if you like a bit of starch).

Don't be intimidated by the texture. Focus on the broth first. Use plenty of lime. If you find the tripe too "adventurous," focus on the hominy and the bread. Most people who think they hate menudo actually just haven't had a bowl that was cleaned and seasoned correctly. It is a masterpiece of slow-cooking, and once you get past the "what is it" factor, you might just find your new favorite weekend tradition.