We used to call it "choking." When a star player missed a free throw or a kicker shanked a game-winning field goal, the narrative was always about "mental toughness." Or a lack of it. You’ve seen the clips. The screaming coaches, the fans burning jerseys, the pundits on TV questioning a human being's "will to win" because their nervous system hit a breaking point. It’s brutal. Honestly, it’s also pretty reductive.
The conversation around mental health in sports has shifted dramatically in the last five years, but we aren't quite "there" yet. We've moved from total silence to a sort of performative awareness. You see the green ribbons and the social media posts, but the actual infrastructure for athletes—from high schoolers to Olympians—remains surprisingly thin.
The Simone Biles Moment and the "Twisties"
Remember Tokyo? Not the neon lights or the empty stadiums, but the moment Simone Biles stepped back. She didn't have a broken leg. She didn't have a torn ACL. She had the "twisties." For the uninitiated, that’s a terrifying neurological disconnect where your brain and body stop communicating in mid-air. You lose your sense of where the ground is.
If you’re a gymnast, that isn't just a mental block; it's a potential death sentence.
Biles prioritized her mental health in sports over a gold medal, and the world lost its mind. Half the people called her a hero; the other half called her a quitter. This divide is exactly why the topic is so complicated. We want our athletes to be superheroes, but we forget they’re operating with the same biological hardware as the rest of us. Stress is stress. Cortisol doesn't care if you have a Nike contract.
What’s Actually Happening in the Brain?
Basically, when an athlete is under extreme pressure, the amygdala—the brain's smoke detector—can hijack the prefrontal cortex. That's the part responsible for complex decision-making and fine motor skills. Dr. Michael Lardon, a sports psychiatrist who has worked with Olympic gold medalists and PGA golfers, often talks about the "zone" as a state of neurological flow. But you can't get to the zone if your brain is stuck in survival mode.
It's not just "nerves."
Clinical depression and anxiety disorders are just as prevalent in locker rooms as they are in accounting firms. Maybe more so. Data from the American College of Sports Medicine (ACSM) suggests that roughly 30% of women and 25% of men who are student-athletes report having a mental health struggle. For elite athletes, that number often climbs because the stakes are higher and the isolation is deeper.
The High Cost of the "Grind" Culture
We love a good "started from the bottom" story. We worship the "Mamba Mentality." But there is a dark side to the 4:00 AM workouts and the "no days off" mantra. When your entire identity is wrapped up in your batting average or your 40-yard dash, what happens when you get injured?
You lose yourself.
That’s where the real danger lies. The NCAA has started to track this, noting that the transition out of sports—whether due to injury or retirement—is a massive trigger for depressive episodes. You're a "former" athlete at age 22 or 30. Then what? If you haven't developed a sense of self outside of the jersey, the vacuum left behind is massive.
Real Talk: It’s Not Just the Pros
If you think this is only a problem for people making millions, you’re wrong. Youth sports have become a multi-billion dollar industry. Ten-year-olds are playing on "elite" travel teams. They're being scouted before they hit puberty. The pressure to perform for a scholarship is crushing kids.
✨ Don't miss: Why 92.9 The Game Atlanta Is Still the King of Georgia Sports Talk
I’ve seen parents screaming at referees over a U-12 soccer game like it’s the World Cup final. That stuff trickles down. By the time these kids get to college, they're burnt out. Their relationship with mental health in sports is already fractured because they've been taught that their value is tied to their performance.
Breaking the Stigma: Who’s Doing It Right?
Kevin Love. Michael Phelps. Naomi Osaka.
These aren't just names; they’re catalysts. When Kevin Love wrote his piece for The Players' Tribune about having a panic attack during a game, it broke the seal for the NBA. Now, the league requires every team to have at least one licensed mental health professional on staff.
- The NBA now has a formal Mental Health and Wellness Program.
- Major League Baseball has seen a record number of players go on the Injured List for "mental health reasons" rather than pretending they have a sore shoulder.
- Progress is slow, but it's happening.
But let’s be real—having a therapist on staff is one thing. Creating a culture where a player feels safe saying "I'm not okay" without losing their starting spot? That’s another hurdle entirely.
The Hidden Impact of Social Media
You can't talk about mental health in sports today without talking about the "comments section."
In the 90s, if a player messed up, they might hear it from the local paper the next day. Now? They feel it instantly. Thousands of notifications. Death threats. Gambling addicts screaming at them because a missed shot ruined a parlay. The "digital noise" is a constant, low-grade trauma.
Athletes like Madison Keys have been vocal about the vitriol they receive after a loss. It’s constant. It’s personal. And for a 19-year-old athlete, it’s devastating. The "mental toughness" required to ignore ten thousand people calling you a failure is a burden no previous generation of athletes had to carry.
Nuance Matters: The "Toughness" Paradox
There is a balance here that we often miss. Sports do require a certain level of resilience. You do have to learn how to perform under pressure. We shouldn't throw the baby out with the bathwater. The goal isn't to remove all stress—that’s impossible in a competitive environment.
The goal is to provide the tools to manage it.
We teach athletes how to squat, how to sprint, and how to fuel their bodies. Why aren't we teaching them how to regulate their nervous systems? Why isn't breathwork as standard as a hamstring stretch? Some teams are catching on. The Seattle Seahawks, under Pete Carroll, were famous for integrating meditation and mindfulness into their routine. They didn't do it just to be "nice"—they did it because it works. A calm brain performs better.
Beyond the Buzzwords: What Needs to Change
We need to stop treating mental health like a "crisis" response. You shouldn't wait until someone is in a dark place to offer support. It has to be preventative.
- Standardized Screenings: Just like a physical exam, mental health check-ins should be mandatory and routine.
- Coach Education: Most coaches are former players who grew up in the "rub dirt on it" era. They need actual training on how to spot signs of anxiety and depression.
- Separating Performance from Worth: This is the hardest one. It’s a cultural shift. We need to value the person more than the stat line.
Actionable Steps for Athletes and Coaches
If you’re involved in sports at any level, waiting for "the system" to fix itself is a losing game. You have to take point on this.
For the Athletes: Start small. Find one person you trust—a teammate, a trainer, anyone—and be honest when you’re struggling. Don't wait for a breakdown. Use "psychological recovery" just as seriously as you use an ice bath. That means sleep, disconnecting from social media, and having hobbies that have absolutely nothing to do with your sport.
For the Coaches: Watch for changes in behavior. Is your star player suddenly irritable? Are they withdrawing from the team? That’s usually not a "bad attitude"—it’s a symptom. Create an environment where "checking in" is normal, not a sign of weakness.
For the Parents: The car ride home after a game is the most important ten minutes of your child’s athletic life. If you spend it critiquing their performance, you’re telling them your love is conditional. Try asking, "Did you have fun?" or "What was your favorite play?" and leave it at that.
The Bottom Line on Mental Health in Sports
We’re in a transition period. The old guard is retiring, and a new generation of athletes who grew up talking about their feelings is taking over. This isn't "softness." It’s evolution.
The most "elite" thing an athlete can do is take care of the engine that runs everything: their brain. If we want to see the highest level of human performance, we have to support the whole human. Anything less is just a waste of talent.
Stop viewing mental health in sports as a niche issue or a PR talking point. It is the foundation of performance. When a player feels safe, supported, and mentally clear, they don't just feel better—they play better. That’s the irony of the whole "toughness" debate. The strongest athletes aren't the ones who hide their struggles; they’re the ones who have the courage to address them so they can get back to the game they love.
👉 See also: Florence High School Football: Why It Hits Different in Alabama’s Shoals
Moving forward, the focus must shift toward long-term psychological sustainability. This means investing in sports psychologists at the youth level and ensuring that retirement protocols include robust mental health transitions. We owe it to the people who entertain us to make sure they aren't destroying themselves for our Sunday afternoon distractions.
The next time you see an athlete struggle, try to remember that you’re looking at a person, not a stat. It changes everything.
To improve the environment immediately, start implementing "Check-in Tuesdays" where the first five minutes of practice are dedicated to non-sport-related wellbeing. Encourage athletes to utilize apps like Headspace or Calm, which many pro leagues now provide for free. Finally, ensure that the contact information for the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline (988 in the US) is posted in every locker room—not because you expect a crisis, but because safety should always be visible.