You’re halfway through a three-mile run and it happens. That familiar, stinging friction. Chafing is the silent killer of a good workout, and honestly, most guys are still walking around in baggy mesh shorts from 2012 that do absolutely nothing to help. If you haven't switched to men’s shorts with lining, you’re basically choosing to suffer. It’s not just about modesty or keeping things in place; it's about engineering. Modern textile science has moved past that scratchy, "diaper-feeling" mesh we all grew up with in swim trunks.
Stop wearing boxers under gym shorts. Just stop.
The physics of it doesn't work. Cotton absorbs moisture, holds it against your skin, and turns into sandpaper. A built-in liner, usually made from a polyester-spandex blend, acts as a second skin. It wicks sweat away before it can cause a rash. I’ve talked to runners who swear they’ll never go back to "commando" or standard underwear once they feel the compression of a high-end jersey liner. It’s a total game-changer for your crotch.
The Great Mesh vs. Compression Debate
Not all men’s shorts with lining are created equal. You’ve basically got two camps here.
First, there’s the traditional brief liner. Think of these like built-in underwear. They’re great for breathability because there’s less fabric overall. Brands like Patagonia have mastered this with their Baggies, though some find the "mesh" a bit rough if they’re doing high-mileage days. Then you have the compression liner—often called "2-in-1" shorts. These are the gold standard for lifting and distance running. They look like a standard pair of athletic shorts on the outside, but inside, there’s a tight, stretchy layer that goes halfway down your thigh.
Why does this matter? Because of the "ride up" factor.
A good compression liner stays put. It creates a barrier between your thighs, which is a lifesaver for anyone who isn't a professional marathoner with zero body fat. If you’ve got muscular quads, the friction of skin-on-skin is real. Lululemon’s Pace Breaker shorts are a classic example of this—they use a Luxtreme liner that feels cool to the touch. It’s expensive, yeah, but your skin will thank you. Some guys complain that compression liners feel too hot in the summer. That’s a fair point. If you’re just walking the dog or grabbing coffee, a brief liner is plenty. But if you’re hitting a squat rack or a trail? Get the compression.
📖 Related: Finding the Bottega Hop Bag Dupe That Actually Lasts
Why Quality Liners Actually Cost More
You might see a pair of generic shorts for fifteen bucks and wonder why Nike or Rhone wants eighty. It’s the stitching. Cheap men’s shorts with lining use "overlock" seams. These are those bulky, raised edges that look like a little rope of thread. After five miles, that rope feels like a serrated knife.
Premium brands use flatlock seams.
Flatlock stitching means the two pieces of fabric are joined side-by-side without overlapping. It’s completely flat against the body. When you're moving, there's no ridge to rub against you. Then there’s the "pouch" construction. Real expertise in men’s apparel involves creating a 3D space for your anatomy rather than just smashing everything flat. It’s about comfort and blood flow. Ten Thousand, a brand that obsesses over grit and durability, actually tests their liners for "burst strength" to make sure they don't lose their shape after a hundred washes.
Hidden Features You’re Probably Missing
Most people buy men’s shorts with lining and don't even realize the liner is doing double duty as storage. Check the side of the inner spandex layer. Often, there’s a hidden pocket there. This is the absolute best place to put a smartphone.
Why? Because when a phone is in the outer pocket of loose shorts, it flops around. It hits your leg with every stride. It’s annoying. When it’s tucked into the liner pocket, the compression holds the phone tight against your hip. It doesn't move. You forget it's there.
- Look for "anti-odor" treatments like silver ion technology.
- Check if the liner has a "phone sleeve" on the right or left thigh.
- Make sure the waistband is flat, not gathered, to prevent "muffin topping."
- Verify the inseam length (5-inch is trendy, 7-inch is safe, 9-inch is for tall guys).
Honestly, the 5-inch inseam has seen a huge resurgence lately. It’s the "quad-summer" vibe. But if you're rocking 5-inch shorts, the liner is non-negotiable. Without it, you’re providing the general public with a view they didn't ask for the moment you sit down or do a bench press.
The "Soggy" Factor in Hybrid Shorts
We need to talk about hybrid shorts. These are the ones designed to go from the gym to the pool to the bar. These men’s shorts with lining usually feature a quick-dry liner that's thinner than a gym compression short but more substantial than a swimsuit mesh.
There’s a downside, though.
Because they try to do everything, they sometimes do nothing perfectly. A liner designed for water might not have the sweat-wicking properties of a dedicated running short. If you're a heavy sweater, "quick-dry" might take longer than you think. Brands like Fair Harbor use recycled plastic bottles to make their liners, which is cool for the planet, but make sure you rinse them after salt-water exposure. Salt crystals trapped in a liner turn into sandpaper once they dry.
💡 You might also like: 1.65 m height in feet: Why this specific measurement is more important than you think
Busting the "Too Tight" Myth
A lot of guys buy a size up because they're afraid the liner will be too restrictive. Don't do that. A loose liner is a useless liner. If the fabric isn't against your skin, it can't wick moisture. If it can't wick moisture, you're going to get swamp-butt. It’s that simple.
The liner should feel like a firm hug. Not a tourniquet, but definitely not loose. If you see the outline of the liner through the outer fabric, that’s actually a sign of a good fit. It means the tension is correct. High-end brands like Tracksmith focus on this "invisible" feel by using Italian micro-polyamide fabrics that are incredibly thin but surprisingly strong.
Maintenance: Don't Kill Your Spandex
You finally dropped some cash on high-quality men’s shorts with lining. Now don't ruin them in the laundry. Heat is the enemy of elastic. If you throw your lined shorts in a high-heat dryer, the tiny elastic fibers in the liner will eventually snap. This is called "elastic death." You’ll know it happened when the liner starts feeling crunchy or loses its snap.
Always wash on cold. Always hang dry.
It takes longer, but your gear will last three times as long. Plus, many of these technical liners use "polygiene" or silver-based finishes to kill bacteria. High heat can strip those treatments away, leaving you with shorts that smell like a locker room no matter how many times you wash them.
Real-World Transitions
The beauty of the modern lined short is the versatility. You can legitimately wake up, go for a run, hit the grocery store, and grab lunch without ever feeling like you’re "under-dressed" for the situation. It’s a uniform.
Take a brand like Vuori. Their Kore Short is basically the "gateway drug" for lined shorts. It has a boxer-brief liner that is so soft people frequently describe it as "silky." It’s not a hardcore compression short, so it doesn't look like you're about to run a Spartan Race. It just looks like a casual, everyday short. This is the sweet spot for most guys. You get the protection and support of a liner without the "performance athlete" aesthetic if that's not your thing.
Actionable Steps for Your Next Purchase
If you're ready to upgrade, don't just grab the first pair you see on a mannequin. Think about your actual movement.
- Measure your inseam. Grab a pair of shorts you already like and measure from the crotch to the bottom hem. Most guys who think they like 9-inch shorts actually look better in 7-inch.
- Check the liner's "hand feel." Reach inside and rub the fabric. If it feels scratchy to your fingers, imagine what it’ll do to your inner thighs after an hour of walking.
- The Squat Test. In the dressing room (or at home), do a deep squat. If the liner feels like it's going to rip, or if it pulls the outer short down, you need a different brand or a size up.
- Invert them. Turn the shorts inside out. Look at the seams. If you see big, bulky thread lines, put them back. You want flat, smooth joins.
- Evaluate the pocket placement. If you carry a heavy Max-sized phone, look specifically for "phone sleeves" built into the liner.
The move to men’s shorts with lining isn't just a trend. It’s an evolution in how we think about comfort. We stopped wearing stiff denim to work; why are we still wearing subpar gear to move our bodies? Buy one high-quality pair. Test it against your old "liners-not-included" shorts. The difference in how you feel at the end of a long day is usually enough to convince even the biggest skeptic.
Keep the tags on until you've done a few lunges in your living room. Comfort is subjective, but the science of preventing chafe is pretty absolute. Go for the compression if you're active, go for the brief if you're lounging, but whatever you do, stop wearing cotton underwear under polyester. Your body deserves better than that.