You're standing in the aisle of a high-end department store or scrolling through a digital storefront, and everything looks... the same. Black leather, some laces, maybe a few holes poked in the toe. But wear the wrong pair to a wedding versus a board meeting, and you'll feel it. People notice. Honestly, most mens dress shoe styles aren't nearly as interchangeable as the average guy thinks they are.
It’s about the "vibe" of the construction.
The Oxford vs. Derby Debate is Actually Important
If you take away one thing from this, let it be the difference between closed and open lacing. It sounds like nerd talk, but it changes the entire silhouette of your foot. The Oxford is the gold standard of formality. Its defining characteristic is the "closed" lacing system, where the eyelet tabs are sewn under the vamp (the front part of the shoe).
It looks sleek. It looks tight. It looks like you have your life together.
Then there’s the Derby. Sometimes called a Blucher—though shoe purists like Justin Fitzpatrick (The Shoe Snob) will tell you there are technical differences in the quarters—the Derby has "open" lacing. The flaps are sewn on top. It’s inherently more casual. If you’re wearing a charcoal power suit, the Oxford is your best friend. If you’re in chinos or a light grey flannel, the Derby is a much better "bridge" shoe.
Most guys buy a Derby because it's more forgiving on high arches. It’s easier to get into. But that extra room comes at the cost of elegance. You wouldn't wear a Derby with a tuxedo; that’s just a fact.
Broguing is a Decoration, Not a Shoe Type
Let's clear this up: a "Brogue" isn't a style of shoe. It's a treatment. You can have an Oxford brogue or a Derby brogue.
📖 Related: Kiko Japanese Restaurant Plantation: Why This Local Spot Still Wins the Sushi Game
Originally, those little holes (perforations) were functional. Scottish and Irish farmers used them to drain water out of their shoes while trekking through bogs. True story. Fast forward a hundred years, and those drainage holes are now a style flex.
- Full Brogues (Wingtips): These have the "W" shape on the toe. They’re busy. They’re loud. They scream "English countryside."
- Semi-Brogues: Just the toe cap has holes. It’s the middle ground.
- Quarter Brogues: Only the seams are perforated. No "medallion" on the toe.
The rule of thumb is simple: more holes = less formal. A plain-toe Oxford is the most formal shoe you can own (short of patent leather). Once you start adding "medallions" and wingtips, you’re moving toward the weekend.
The Monk Strap: For When You’re Bored of Laces
Some people hate them. I think they’re brilliant. The Monk Strap replaces laces with a buckle and a leather strap. You’ll usually see them in "Single" or "Double" varieties.
The Double Monk Strap had a massive "#menswear" moment on Instagram a few years ago. It’s cooled off since then, but it remains a staple for guys who want to look like they know what they’re doing without trying too hard. It’s a very "Milan" look.
A single strap is cleaner and slightly more conservative. If you’re wearing a double monk, leave the top buckle undone for a bit of sprezzatura—that Italian concept of studied carelessness. It sounds pretentious because it kind of is, but it looks cool.
Loafers and the "No Socks" Narrative
Loafers are the ultimate "I’m on vacation but I still have a 401k" shoe.
👉 See also: Green Emerald Day Massage: Why Your Body Actually Needs This Specific Therapy
The Penny Loafer is the American classic. G.H. Bass created the "Weejun" in the 1930s, and it’s been a staple of Ivy League style ever since. Legend says students used to tuck a penny into the slit of the leather strap to pay for emergency phone calls. Hence the name.
Then you have the Tassel Loafer. This one is divisive. For some, it’s the "Old Lawyer" shoe. For others, it’s a sophisticated alternative to the penny. If you want something sleeker, look at the Horsebit Loafer. Gucci made this famous in 1953 by adding a metal bit across the front, inspired by equestrian gear. It’s one of the few loafers that can actually pass with a suit if the leather is dark and the bit isn't too gaudy.
Boots Can Actually Be Dress Shoes
Don't wear your hiking boots to the office. Just don't.
But a Chelsea Boot? That’s a different story. With its elastic side panels and clean silhouette, a black leather Chelsea boot can look sharper than a standard dress shoe under a pair of slim trousers. It’s the rockstar’s dress shoe.
Then there’s the Chukka. Usually suede, usually with two or three eyelets. These are the kings of "Business Casual." They’re what you wear when you aren't sure if the party is fancy or "jeans and a nice shirt" fancy. Avoid the crepe sole (like the classic Clarks Desert Boot) if you're trying to stay formal; look for a leather or slim rubber sole instead.
Construction Matters More Than the Label
A shoe can look like a million bucks and fall apart in six months if it’s "Cemented." That basically means the sole is glued on. It's cheap. It's disposable.
✨ Don't miss: The Recipe Marble Pound Cake Secrets Professional Bakers Don't Usually Share
If you’re serious about mens dress shoe styles, you need to look for Goodyear Welting. This is a strip of leather (the welt) that is sewn to both the upper and the sole. It makes the shoe water-resistant and, more importantly, resolable. A Goodyear-welted shoe from a brand like Allen Edmonds or Crockett & Jones can literally last you 20 years if you take care of the leather.
There’s also the Blake Stitch. This is common in Italian shoes. The sole is stitched directly to the upper. It results in a thinner, more flexible sole that requires zero break-in time. It’s not as waterproof as a Goodyear welt, but it feels like a slipper from day one.
The Color Hierarchy
Black is the most formal. Period. If you’re wearing a black suit, you wear black shoes.
Dark brown (Oxford Blood or Burgundy) is actually more versatile. It goes with navy, grey, tan, and olive. Burgundy is the "cheat code" of the shoe world—it’s just as formal as dark brown but adds a bit of personality.
Tan is risky. It draws the eye downward. If your shoes are much lighter than your pants, you’ll look like you’re wearing light bulbs on your feet. Save the tan shoes for light blue suits in the summer or casual khaki trousers.
Actionable Steps for Your Next Purchase
- Check your closet. If you don't own a plain-toe Black Oxford, buy that first. It’s your funeral, wedding, and interview shoe.
- Examine the lacing. If you have high arches, look for Derbies (open lacing). If you want to look slimmer and more formal, stick to Oxfords.
- Invest in cedar shoe trees. This isn't optional. Leather shrinks and wrinkles as it dries from the moisture in your feet. Cedar trees absorb that moisture and keep the shape.
- Rotate your pairs. Never wear the same leather shoes two days in a row. They need 24 hours to dry out completely.
- Look at the sole. If you see a stitch running along the bottom, it's likely a Blake or Goodyear welt. If it's perfectly smooth and looks like plastic, it's probably glued. Avoid the glue.
The right shoe doesn't just complete the outfit; it anchors it. Start with the basics—the Oxford and the Loafer—and build out once you understand the "rules" well enough to break them.