If you were flipping through channels in the early 2000s, you probably stopped on a scene of a guy in a massive, antique brass diving suit trying to take twelve agonizing steps in a courtroom. It’s one of those cinematic moments that sticks in your brain. That movie is Men of Honor, and honestly, it’s one of the most resilient "dad movies" ever made.
Even decades later, people are still searching for the "Robert De Niro and Cuba Gooding Jr movie" because the chemistry between those two was lightning in a bottle. One is a legendary grump, the other is an underdog with a heart of gold. It’s a classic formula, but it works.
The True Story Behind the Scuba Gear
A lot of people think Men of Honor is just another "based on a true story" Hollywood flick that makes everything up. Well, parts of it are definitely exaggerated (we'll get to that), but the man at the center of it was very real. Carl Brashear was a total powerhouse.
Born to sharecroppers in Kentucky, Brashear joined the Navy in 1948. This was right as the military was starting to desegregate, but let’s be real—the "integration" was mostly on paper. In the actual fleet, black sailors were frequently pushed into roles as cooks or stewards. Brashear didn’t want to flip burgers. He wanted to dive.
It took him years of writing letters and getting rejected before he finally got into the U.S. Navy Diving and Salvage School. The racism he faced there? The movie actually tones it down. His son, Phillip Brashear, has mentioned in interviews that what his father went through was much more brutal than what we saw on screen.
👉 See also: The Entire History of You: What Most People Get Wrong About the Grain
What the Movie Got Right (and Wrong)
Hollywood loves a good composite character, and that’s exactly what Robert De Niro’s character, Billy Sunday, is. In the film, Sunday is this hard-nosed, alcoholic Master Chief who starts as Brashear’s tormentor and ends up as his biggest ally.
- Billy Sunday isn't real: There was no single "Billy Sunday." He’s a blend of several instructors Brashear had, mostly a man named Boatswain's Mate First Class Harry Rutherford.
- The Russian Submarine: Remember that tense scene where Brashear is underwater and a Soviet sub almost crushes him? Total fiction. It makes for a great thriller moment, but it never happened.
- The Amputation: This part is 100% true and maybe the most incredible part of his life. During a bomb recovery mission in 1966 (the Palomares incident), a cable snapped and a pipe nearly sheared Brashear's leg off. Instead of retiring, he fought the Navy for two years to prove he could still dive with a prosthetic. He became the first amputee to be recertified as a U.S. Navy diver.
Why the Critics Were Wrong About This One
When Men of Honor hit theaters in November 2000, critics were... lukewarm. If you look at Rotten Tomatoes today, it’s sitting at a 42% critic score. They called it "by-the-numbers" and "sentimental."
But look at the audience score. It’s hovering around 82%.
There’s a massive gap there. Critics often hate "inspirational" movies because they feel manipulated by the score or the slow-motion shots. But audiences loved the raw performances. Cuba Gooding Jr. brought a vulnerability that made you feel every racial slur and every physical obstacle. And De Niro? He did what De Niro does—he chewed the scenery in the best way possible.
✨ Don't miss: Shamea Morton and the Real Housewives of Atlanta: What Really Happened to Her Peach
The "Twelve Steps" scene is the soul of the movie. Brashear has to walk 12 steps in a 290-pound Navy Mark V diving suit to prove his fitness for duty. In reality, Brashear did have to prove himself to a board of officers, though the dramatic courtroom walk was a bit of Hollywood flair. Still, it captures the spirit of his stubbornness.
The Legacy of the "Master Diver"
The movie ends with Brashear achieving the rank of Master Diver, the first African American to do so. But the story didn’t end in 1970. Brashear stayed in the Navy until 1979, retiring as a Master Chief Petty Officer.
His influence is everywhere in the modern Navy. There’s a Lewis and Clark-class dry cargo ship named the USNS Carl Brashear. Think about that—a kid from a sharecropping farm who wasn't allowed to swim in certain pools ended up with a massive military ship bearing his name.
If you’re planning to rewatch it, keep an eye out for the supporting cast too. A young Charlize Theron plays Sunday’s wife, and Michael Rapaport is great as the one recruit who actually treats Brashear like a human being. It’s a "guy movie" that actually has a lot of heart and some pretty deep themes about what it means to actually earn respect.
🔗 Read more: Who is Really in the Enola Holmes 2 Cast? A Look at the Faces Behind the Mystery
Practical Ways to Honor the Legacy
If the movie inspired you, there are a few things you can actually do to dive deeper (pun intended) into this history:
- Visit the Museum: The U.S. Naval Undersea Museum in Washington has exhibits on Brashear and the history of Navy diving.
- Read the Oral History: The U.S. Naval Institute published The Reminiscences of Master Chief Boatswain's Mate Carl Brashear. It’s his story in his own words, and it's far more grit-filled than the movie.
- Support the Foundation: The Carl Brashear Foundation was set up by his sons to keep his legacy alive and help veterans.
Next time you see Robert De Niro shouting "Chief, get your gear!" on a Saturday afternoon broadcast, don't just keep scrolling. It’s a movie about the kind of grit that doesn't really exist much anymore. Whether you're there for the history or just to see De Niro be a legendary jerk who turns good, Men of Honor still delivers the goods.
Actionable Insight: If you're a history buff, compare the movie's depiction of the Palomares incident (the lost nuclear bomb) with the declassified reports of the 1966 mid-air collision. The reality of recovering nuclear weapons from the ocean floor is even more terrifying than the movie suggests.