You ever watch a movie and just know the actors are having way more fun than the audience? That's the vibe with Melissa McCarthy and Jason Bateman. Honestly, it’s a pairing that shouldn't have happened. The script for their 2013 hit Identity Thief was originally written for two men. But then Jason Bateman went to the premiere of Bridesmaids.
He saw McCarthy’s tour-de-force performance as Megan—the woman who tried to fight a flight attendant and successfully "stole" a bunch of puppies—and he basically told Universal Pictures they had to rewrite the whole thing. He wanted her. He needed that specific brand of chaos to bounce off his "buttoned-up, perpetually exhausted guy" energy.
It worked. People still talk about that movie today, even if the critics back then weren't exactly kind.
The Magic of Identity Thief
The premise is kinda ridiculous if you think about it too hard. A guy from Denver (Bateman) travels all the way to Florida to kidnap a woman (McCarthy) who stole his identity because the cops won't do anything. It’s a classic road trip setup. But what makes Melissa McCarthy and Jason Bateman so watchable isn't the plot; it's the physical comedy.
👉 See also: America's Got Talent Transformation: Why the Show Looks So Different in 2026
There’s this one scene where they’re scuffling in a house full of stolen merchandise. Apparently, it got a bit "dicey" on set. Bateman actually threw a real, 32-pound panini maker toward McCarthy's head. It wasn't supposed to be the real one—there were 14 rubber props lying around—but he grabbed the heavy one by mistake. Luckily, he missed. Can you imagine the insurance nightmare if Jason Bateman had actually taken out a national treasure with a sandwich press?
- Box Office Power: Despite a massive winter storm in the Northeast during its opening, the movie pulled in $34.6 million in its first weekend.
- The "Review-Proof" Factor: Critics hated it. Rotten Tomatoes was a bloodbath. But audiences? They didn't care. The film went on to gross over $175 million worldwide.
Why We Keep Coming Back to This Duo
Bateman is the king of the "straight man" role. He’s done it in Arrested Development, Horrible Bosses, and Ozark (though with a much darker twist there). He has this way of looking at a person like they’re the most confusing thing he’s ever encountered. McCarthy, on the other hand, is a human hurricane.
When you put them together, you get this perfect friction. It’s like watching a very organized cat try to deal with a very enthusiastic Roomba.
✨ Don't miss: All I Watch for Christmas: What You’re Missing About the TBS Holiday Tradition
They actually worked together before Identity Thief too. Both were in Bridesmaids, though they didn't share much screen time. McCarthy also mentioned in interviews that they’d crossed paths years ago at The Groundlings, the famous improv troupe in Los Angeles. That improv background is probably why their banter feels so fast. Half the stuff that makes people laugh in their scenes feels like it was cooked up on the spot.
The Netflix Resurgence
It’s 2026, and you’d think a 2013 comedy would be buried in the "deep scroll" of streaming services. Nope. Identity Thief regularly pops up in the Netflix Top 10. There’s a comfort to it. In a world where every movie is a three-hour multiverse epic, people just want to see Melissa McCarthy punch Jason Bateman in the throat and then see them become best friends two hours later. It’s simple. It’s effective.
What's Next for the Pair?
There’s been plenty of chatter about a sequel. Some blogs (the ones that use a lot of AI) keep claiming Identity Thief 2 is dropping any second. The reality is a bit more complicated. Both actors are insanely busy. Bateman has moved heavily into directing and producing with his company, Aggregate Films, and McCarthy is constantly balancing high-concept comedies with Oscar-nominated dramas like Can You Ever Forgive Me?.
🔗 Read more: Al Pacino Angels in America: Why His Roy Cohn Still Terrifies Us
However, they clearly like each other. McCarthy once joked that she keeps "chaining him to her and dragging him places." They even appeared together in The Heat, though Bateman's role was more of a cameo.
Actionable Insights for Fans
If you're looking to dive deeper into the Melissa McCarthy and Jason Bateman cinematic universe, don't just stop at the big hits. Here’s how to actually appreciate their work:
- Watch the Interviews: Their chemistry on the Larry King Now episode from 2013 is arguably funnier than the movie itself. They genuinely seem to irritate and adore each other in equal measure.
- Look for the Improv: When watching Identity Thief, pay attention to Bateman’s reactions. The "straight man" is the hardest job in comedy, and his micro-expressions are a masterclass.
- Track the Cameos: See if you can spot the overlap in their production circles. They often use the same directors, like Seth Gordon or Paul Feig, which keeps that specific comedic "family" feel alive.
The brilliance of this duo is that they don't try to out-funny each other. Bateman stays in his lane, McCarthy stays in hers, and the collision in the middle is where the money is. Whether we get a formal sequel or just another random collaboration, the "Bateman-McCarthy" formula is one of the few things in Hollywood that still feels reliably human.
To see more of their solo growth, check out Bateman’s directorial work on Ozark or McCarthy’s recent forays into more serious character studies. It makes their slapstick reunions even more satisfying when they happen.