When Melissa Benoist first zipped into that red and blue suit back in 2015, the internet basically had a collective heart attack. Some people loved the classic throwback vibes, while others were ready to nitpick every single stitch. But honestly? That suit became a symbol for an entire era of TV.
Designing a superhero outfit is never just about looking "cool" for the camera. It’s a massive logistical nightmare involving sweat, freezing Canadian winters, and enough double-sided tape to hold a skyscraper together. The Melissa Benoist Supergirl costume wasn't just one static thing; it was a living, breathing part of Kara Danvers’ evolution from a shy assistant to a world-saving icon.
The Oscar-Winning Brain Behind the Threads
Most people don’t realize that the original Season 1 suit was designed by Colleen Atwood. Yeah, that Colleen Atwood—the woman with four Oscars on her shelf for movies like Chicago and Fantastic Beasts. She wasn't just throwing some spandex together.
Atwood wanted what she called a "street-style action hero." She used a specific fabric called Eurojersey, which has this crazy four-way stretch. If you look closely at the "S" shield on the chest, it isn't just a flat patch. It’s actually "grown" onto the fabric using layers of ink to give it a 3D texture.
"I wanted to embrace the past, but more importantly, thrust her into the street-style action hero of today," Atwood said at the time.
One of the smartest things she did? The cape. Capes are notoriously heavy and usually pull the neck of the suit back, which makes the actor look like they’re being choked. Atwood built a hidden "undersuit" with a zipper that the cape attached to. This distributed the weight across Melissa’s shoulders so she could actually move during fight scenes without the collar ending up under her chin.
👉 See also: The Real Story Behind I Can Do Bad All by Myself: From Stage to Screen
The Skirt vs. Pants Civil War
Let's talk about the elephant in the room: the Season 5 transition to pants.
For four seasons, Kara Danvers fought world-ending threats in a leather-textured skirt and over-the-knee boots. Fans were split. Some felt the skirt was "iconic" and feminine. Others pointed out that flying at Mach 2 in a skirt is, well, a wardrobe malfunction waiting to happen.
But the real reason for the change wasn't just about "modernizing" the character. It was about the weather.
The show filmed in Vancouver. If you’ve ever been to British Columbia in January, you know it’s not exactly skirt weather. Melissa Benoist had been lobbying for pants since the very first season. She was literally freezing her legs off for years.
When the new suit debuted in Season 5, it used nanotechnology—in the show's lore, anyway. Brainiac-5 gave Kara a pair of microscopic-activation glasses. Tap the frame, and the suit materialized over her clothes. No more ducking into alleyways to change.
✨ Don't miss: Love Island UK Who Is Still Together: The Reality of Romance After the Villa
The new look ditched the bright primary red and blue for a slightly darker, more textured navy. It felt more like a "Super-Suit" and less like a "costume." Melissa called it "more adult," and honestly, you could tell she was way more comfortable in the behind-the-scenes footage.
That "Beach" Costume Most People Forgot
Before the final suit was locked in, the pilot episode had a hilarious sequence where Kara and Winn (Jeremy Jordan) test out different looks.
They actually poked fun at the history of over-sexualized female superheroes. One of the prototypes was a tiny crop top and hot pants that left most of her torso exposed.
Kara’s reaction? "I wouldn't even wear this to the beach."
It was a meta-commentary on the 1970s "hot pants" era of Supergirl in the comics. By rejecting that look on screen, the show runners were basically telling the audience: "We’re doing this differently. She’s a hero, not a pin-up."
🔗 Read more: Gwendoline Butler Dead in a Row: Why This 1957 Mystery Still Packs a Punch
Comparing the "Melissa Look" to the New Movie Suits
With Milly Alcock taking over as the Girl of Steel in the DCU, everyone is comparing the suits again.
Benoist’s suit had a certain "Americana" warmth to it. It felt approachable. The newer movie versions, like Sasha Calle's in The Flash or the upcoming Alcock suit, lean much harder into the "Kryptonian Armor" aesthetic. They look alien.
The Melissa Benoist Supergirl costume was the bridge between the goofy spandex of the 80s and the tactical gear of today. It kept the bright red boots (though they eventually added a wedge heel for height) and that signature gold belt.
Practical Takeaways for Your Own Cosplay or Collection
If you're looking to replicate this look or just want to appreciate the craft, here are the real-world details that made it work:
- The Fabric: Don't use cheap shiny spandex. The real suit had a subtle "honeycomb" or "basketball" texture that caught the light and made it look expensive.
- The Tights: In the early seasons, they used very specific dark-shaded tights. It wasn't just bare legs; it was a calculated choice to make the silhouette look more athletic and less "nude."
- The Boots: They weren't just leather. They had built-in support for stunts and a hidden lift to help Melissa stand tall next to the taller actors playing Superman or Martian Manhunter.
- The Symbol: If you're buying a replica, look for the yellow border. The Arrowverse "S" has a very specific thickness to that gold outline that differentiates it from the Superman version.
Whether you prefer the classic skirt or the tactical pants, there’s no denying that Melissa Benoist carried that mantle with a lot of grace. She didn't just wear the suit; she made people believe a girl could fly—even if she was shivering between takes in a parka.
To dive deeper into the technical side of superhero construction, you should check out the behind-the-scenes features on the Season 1 Blu-ray or look up Colleen Atwood's portfolio to see how she balanced the Arrowverse's "grounded" look across different shows.