You've probably been digging through old Medicare handbooks or chatting with a neighbor who has had the same insurance for twenty years, and you keep seeing it: Medicare Supplement Plan E. It sounds like a solid mid-range option, right? Something between the basic plans and the "Cadillac" coverage. But here is the kicker—if you go to a major carrier's website today to get a quote, it’s gone. It’s basically a ghost in the machine of the American healthcare system.
Honestly, the world of Medigap is a bit of a mess.
Medicare Supplement Plan E hasn't been available to new enrollees for over a decade. Since June 1, 2010, the federal government basically took it out back and retired it. If you already had it before that date, you were allowed to keep it, which is why you still hear it mentioned in senior centers or on old forum posts. But for the rest of us? It's off the table.
Why? Because the Medicare Modernization Act and subsequent tweaks to the Social Security Act decided that having too many plans with overlapping benefits was just confusing everyone. They weren't wrong. At one point, we had plans A through N, and the differences between some of them were so microscopic that even the brokers had headaches.
What Medicare Supplement Plan E Actually Covered
To understand why it was axed, we have to look at what it did. Plan E was a bit of an odd duck. It covered your Part A deductible—that’s the big chunk you pay if you get admitted to the hospital—and it covered your Part B coinsurance. That's the 20% Medicare doesn't pay for doctor visits.
But here is the weird part. It also covered "Preventive Medical Care" and "At-Home Recovery."
Back in the 90s and early 2000s, those were big selling points. However, as Medicare itself evolved, the "Core" Medicare benefits started including a lot of that preventive stuff for free anyway. If the government is already paying for your flu shot and your annual "Wellness" visit under Part B, you don't really need a supplement plan to "cover" it anymore. It became redundant.
It didn't cover the Part B deductible. That meant if you went to the doctor, you still had to pay that first couple hundred bucks out of your own pocket before the insurance kicked in. This is a recurring theme in Medigap history: the government really wants people to have some "skin in the game" so they don't go to the ER for every stubbed toe.
The At-Home Recovery Mystery
The most unique thing about Medicare Supplement Plan E was the at-home recovery benefit. It was meant to pay for someone to come help you with "Activities of Daily Living" (ADLs)—things like bathing or dressing—while you recovered from an illness or surgery.
Sounds great. In reality, it was a logistical nightmare.
The benefit was capped at a very low dollar amount per visit and had a strict annual limit. It wasn't long-term care insurance. It was more like a tiny band-aid for a very specific type of wound. When the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) looked at the data, they realized almost nobody was actually using the benefit correctly, and it was driving up premiums for no real reason. So, when the 2010 modernization hit, they folded the useful parts of Plan E into other plans and just deleted the letter E from the alphabet.
If You Still Have Plan E, Should You Keep It?
This is where things get tricky. If you are one of the "Grandfathered" folks still holding onto a Medicare Supplement Plan E policy, you might feel like you have a collector's item. In some ways, you do.
But collectors' items can be expensive to maintain.
Insurance works on "risk pools." For a plan to stay affordable, you need a healthy mix of young, healthy people paying premiums and older, sicker people using the benefits. Because Plan E has been closed to new members since 2010, the pool is "closed." Everyone in that pool is getting older every single year. No 65-year-olds are joining to balance out the costs.
What happens? The claims go up. The premiums skyrocket.
I've talked to folks who are paying double what a modern Plan G costs, simply because they are afraid to leave their old Plan E. They think they’re losing "special" coverage. In reality, they are usually overpaying for a plan that has less coverage than what is available on the market today.
The Math of Switching
If you are looking at your monthly bill and it’s north of $300 for a Plan E, you need to do a gut check. Medicare Supplement Plan G is currently the "gold standard" for most people.
- Plan G covers everything Plan E did.
- Plan G covers Part B Excess Charges (which Plan E did NOT).
- Plan G has an "open" pool, meaning it's usually more price-stable.
The only hurdle? Medical underwriting. Unless you live in a state like New York or Connecticut that has "continuous open enrollment," you usually have to answer health questions to switch from an old plan to a new one. If you have a serious chronic condition, you might be stuck with Plan E. But if you're relatively healthy? You're likely throwing money away by staying in a closed plan.
The Modern Alternatives to Medicare Supplement Plan E
Since you can't buy Plan E anymore, what are people actually buying? It basically boils down to three choices: Plan G, Plan N, and the high-deductible versions.
Plan G is the direct successor in terms of popularity. It covers every single gap in Medicare except for the Part B deductible. You pay that once a year (it's $257 in 2026), and then you pay nothing else for the rest of the year. No co-pays. No surprise bills. Just nothing.
Plan N is for the person who wants to save a bit on premiums and doesn't mind a small "cover charge" at the doctor. You’ll pay up to $20 per office visit and $50 for an ER visit. Honestly, for many people, the savings on the monthly premium more than make up for those small co-pays. It's the "thinking person's" plan.
Then there is Plan F. But wait—Plan F is also "dead" for anyone who turned 65 after January 1, 2020. It's the same story as Plan E. If you had it, you can keep it. If you're new, you're out of luck.
Why the Letter System is a Mess
The alphabet soup of Medicare is enough to make anyone want to just give up and stay on their employer plan forever. You have Plan A, B, C, D, F, G, K, L, M, and N.
Notice someone is missing?
Yep. Plan E. Along with Plan H, I, and J.
Those four plans (E, H, I, J) were all eliminated in 2010. They were the ones that used to offer prescription drug coverage before Medicare Part D existed. Once Part D became a thing in 2006, having drug coverage inside a supplement plan became illegal because you can't have "duplicate" coverage.
It’s a weird legal quirk. But the result is a list of plans that looks like a toddler was trying to learn the alphabet and skipped a bunch of letters.
Real-World Impact: The "Excess Charge" Trap
One of the biggest flaws of Medicare Supplement Plan E was the lack of coverage for Part B Excess Charges. Most people don't even know what those are until they get a bill for $500 they weren't expecting.
In most states, a doctor who doesn't "accept assignment" can charge you up to 15% more than the Medicare-approved amount. Plan E left you holding the bag for that 15%. Plan G covers it.
Imagine you have a $10,000 surgery. If your surgeon charges an excess fee, you could be out $1,500 just because your plan—the "trusted" Plan E you've had for years—doesn't cover that specific line item. This is the "nuance" that brokers often fail to mention.
🔗 Read more: Why Your Eye Is Twitching: What Most People Get Wrong About Eyelid Myokymia
What You Should Do Right Now
If you are researching Medicare Supplement Plan E, you are likely in one of two camps. You're either a researcher looking at old data, or you're a policyholder wondering if you're getting ripped off.
Here is the move.
First, stop looking for Plan E quotes. They don't exist. If a website tells you they can sell you a new Plan E, close the tab—they are either lying or the site hasn't been updated since the Obama administration's first term.
Second, if you currently have Plan E, find your latest renewal notice. Look at the premium. Now, go look at a quote for Plan G in your zip code. If the Plan G is cheaper (which it almost certainly will be), call a broker. Ask them if you can pass medical underwriting in your state.
Third, don't be afraid of "Change." The "Core" benefits of Medicare are standardized. A Plan G with a cheap company is the exact same coverage as a Plan G with a massive, expensive company. The only difference is the logo on the card and the amount of money leaving your bank account every month.
Medicare is a business. The insurance companies love it when people stay in old, expensive plans like Plan E because it’s high-margin for them. They aren't going to call you and tell you to switch to a cheaper, better plan. That is on you.
Key Takeaways for the Savvy Shopper
- Plan E is retired. You cannot buy it if you are new to Medicare.
- Check your "Grandfathered" status. If you have it, you can keep it, but it's likely a bad deal.
- Plan G is the better version. It covers more (like Excess Charges) and usually costs less because the risk pool is healthier.
- Underwriting is the gatekeeper. You can't always switch plans just because you want to; you may have to prove you are healthy enough for a new company to take you on.
- Avoid the "Old Plan" trap. Just because you've had a plan for 20 years doesn't mean it's the best one for the next 20.
The reality of 2026 is that healthcare is getting more expensive, not less. Hanging onto an obsolete insurance product like Medicare Supplement Plan E is like trying to use a flip phone in a 5G world. It might still make calls, but you're missing out on everything else, and you're probably paying more for the "vintage" experience than it's actually worth.
Next Steps for You:
- Locate your current Medigap policy document and find the "Outline of Coverage" page to see exactly what you are paying for.
- Run a comparison quote for a Medicare Supplement Plan G and Plan N in your specific zip code to establish a price baseline.
- Contact a licensed independent Medicare agent to determine if your state has "Birthday Rules" or "Guaranteed Issue" rights that would allow you to switch out of an old plan without a medical exam.