Art history has a way of sanitizing the messy bits. We look at slides in a dark lecture hall and talk about "composition" or "spatial dynamics," but honestly? Some art is just meant to be felt in your gut. Or smelled. Or feared.
Carolee Schneemann’s Meat Joy is exactly that kind of work. It’s visceral. It’s sticky. It’s frankly kind of gross if you think about it for more than ten seconds. In 1964, a group of people stripped down to their underwear and started rubbing raw fish, slimy chickens, and sausages all over each other. This wasn't some backyard prank; it was a revolution.
You’ve probably seen the grainy photos—bodies tangled in plastic, covered in wet paint and animal carcasses. It looks like a fever dream. That’s because it basically was. Schneemann actually based the performance on dreams she’d been recording for four years. She wanted to break the "starved" nature of her culture. People were repressed. They were rigid. And she decided the best way to fix that was to bring the butcher shop into the art gallery.
What Actually Happened During Meat Joy?
Most people think it was just a random orgy with groceries. It wasn't. Schneemann was a painter first, and she viewed the stage as an "exploded canvas." She called it Kinetic Theater. Everything was scored and rehearsed for weeks, though she kept the meat a secret until the actual performance to get a real reaction from the performers.
👉 See also: Album Hopes and Fears: Why We Obsess Over Music That Doesn't Exist Yet
Imagine being one of those dancers. You’ve practiced the movements, the "contact improvisation," the shifting from tenderness to wildness. Then, suddenly, a "serving maid" shows up with a tray of old, stinking mackerel and raw poultry.
The smell must have been unbelievable.
The Three Great Shocks: Paris, London, and New York
- Paris (May 1964): This was the debut at the Festival of Free Expression. It was so intense that one audience member actually tried to strangle Schneemann mid-performance. He just snapped. Two other people had to pull him off her.
- London (June 1964): Performed at Denison Hall. The British crowd was reportedly "reproachful" and unresponsive. A tough room for raw sausage.
- New York (November 1964): This took place at the Judson Memorial Church. The aroma of the raw mackerel was so pungent it allegedly never fully left the floorboards. The Reverend there, Howard Moody, was cool with it, though. He even gave sermons about the "loaves and fishes" while the place still smelled like a fish market.
The "Image-Maker" vs. The Image
Schneemann was fighting a specific battle. At the time, if you were a beautiful woman in the art world, you were the muse. You were the thing being painted. You weren't the one holding the brush—and you definitely weren't the one turning your own body into the brush.
✨ Don't miss: The Name of This Band Is Talking Heads: Why This Live Album Still Beats the Studio Records
She was famously expelled from Bard College in the 50s for painting herself with her legs open. The school was fine with male students painting nude women, but a woman painting herself? That was too much. Meat Joy was her way of saying, "I am the image, and I am the image-maker."
She wasn't angry, though. That’s a common misconception. She wanted the work to be ecstatic. She wanted it to be a celebration of "flesh as material." By mixing human skin with fish scales and wet paint, she blurred the line between the "sacred" human body and the "profane" animal meat we eat every day.
Why Should We Care in 2026?
You see her fingerprints everywhere now. When Lady Gaga wore that meat dress to the VMAs in 2010? That’s a direct descendant of Schneemann. When you see artists like Marina Abramović or Matthew Barney pushing their bodies to the absolute limit, they’re standing on the plastic sheeting Schneemann laid down in 1964.
🔗 Read more: Wrong Address: Why This Nigerian Drama Is Still Sparking Conversations
Honestly, our culture is still "starved" in a lot of ways. We’re more disconnected from the physical world than ever. We experience everything through screens. Schneemann’s work is a slap in the face to that digital distance. It reminds us that we are made of blood, bone, and heat.
How to "Get" Meat Joy Today
- Look past the "shock": Don't just see the nudity or the meat. Look at the choreography. Notice how the bodies move like brushstrokes.
- Listen to the sound: The original performance used a sound collage of pop music mixed with the sounds of Parisian street vendors shouting about fish. It’s supposed to be disorienting.
- Acknowledge the grit: This wasn't "clean" feminist art. It was messy, controversial, and even other feminists at the time hated it. They thought she was playing into male fantasies. Schneemann disagreed; she thought claiming her own pleasure was the ultimate act of rebellion.
Actionable Insights for the Modern Creative
If you’re an artist or just someone trying to understand why this matters, take these notes from Schneemann's playbook:
- Integrate your "split": Schneemann refused to separate her intelligence from her sensuality. Don't let society box you into being "the smart one" or "the creative one." You can be both.
- Use your discomfort: She was often "terrified" by her own performances. If your work doesn't scare you a little bit, you probably aren't pushing hard enough.
- Trust the "Kinetic": Sometimes you have to stop thinking and start moving. Whether it's writing, painting, or coding, find a way to make it a physical experience.
To really understand the legacy of Meat Joy, you have to look at how it redefined the female body from a passive object to an active, "kinetic" force. It wasn't just about the meat; it was about the joy of being alive and unapologetically physical in a world that wants you to stay tidy.
Check out the 16mm film version if you can find a screening; the way she edited the footage with that 60s pop soundtrack gives it a rhythmic, hypnotic energy that a still photo just can't capture.