Finding the right mascara feels like a never-ending quest for the Holy Grail. You've probably been there—standing in the drugstore aisle, staring at fifty different tubes that all promise the same "falsies" effect. But Maybelline Push Up Angel is different. It’s weird. It doesn’t look like a standard mascara, and honestly, that’s exactly why it works for a very specific type of person. If you're looking for chunky, thick, "spidery" volume, you're going to hate this. Seriously. Put it back on the shelf. But if you want that crisp, winged-out look that makes your eyes look wider without the weight of a heavy wax formula, we need to talk.
The The Falsies Push Up Angel Mascara launched as part of Maybelline’s massive "Falsies" expansion, but it pivoted away from the original’s core philosophy. While the classic Falsies was all about drama and girth, the Angel wing brush was engineered for precision. It’s a comb, basically. A tiny, curved, plastic comb that looks a bit intimidating if you’re used to big, fluffy bristles.
The Physics of the Winged Lash
Most people get the application wrong. They try to wiggle it from the root like a volumizing wand, but that’s not how the Push Up Angel is designed to move. Because the bristles are so short and located only on one side of the wand, it functions more like a styling tool than a coating tool.
The inner curve of the wand is meant to hug the lash line, while the longer bristles on the end allow you to "flick" the outer corner lashes upward and outward. This creates that specific "angel" wing. It’s about architecture. By lifting the outer third of the lash fringe, you’re essentially performing a non-surgical eye lift. It’s subtle. It’s clean. It’s the "no-makeup" makeup look's best friend.
One thing that’s genuinely impressive is the formula’s weight. It’s a very thin, fluid ink. If you have stick-straight lashes that refuse to hold a curl, heavy mascaras are your enemy. They’re like putting a wet coat on a blade of grass; the grass is going to droop. Maybelline Push Up Angel stays lightweight enough that once you use a lash curler, the "set" actually stays put through an eight-hour workday.
Let’s Talk About the Wand (It’s Polarizing)
You’ll notice immediately that the wand is skinny. Almost skeletal. This is the biggest hurdle for new users. When you pull it out of the tube, it doesn't look like there's enough product on it. You might think, "Is this thing even working?"
💡 You might also like: Bird Feeders on a Pole: What Most People Get Wrong About Backyard Setups
But that’s the secret.
The lack of bulk means you can get right into the roots without smearing black goop all over your eyelid. If you have hooded eyes, you know the struggle of the "mascara stamp" on your brow bone. This wand minimizes that risk because you have total control. You can see what you’re doing. It’s surgical.
- The Pros: Zero clumps. Defined separation. Incredible for bottom lashes.
- The Cons: Takes longer to build. Not for people who want "thick" lashes. The plastic bristles can be a bit pokey if you’re clumsy.
Does it Actually Replace False Lashes?
Honestly? No. No mascara truly replaces a strip of 3D mink lashes or a professional set of extensions. Let’s be real. Maybelline’s marketing team called it "Push Up Angel" to evoke the idea of a lift, but if your lashes are naturally short and sparse, this isn't going to magically double their length.
What it does do is mimic the look of individual lash clusters placed at the outer corners.
It’s about the silhouette. When you look at someone wearing this mascara from a distance, their eyes look "snatched." It’s a feline aesthetic. Compared to something like Maybelline Great Lash (which is basically just a tint) or Lash Sensational (which is a heavy hitter), the Push Up Angel occupies a middle ground of high-definition styling.
📖 Related: Barn Owl at Night: Why These Silent Hunters Are Creepier (and Cooler) Than You Think
Water-Resistant vs. Waterproof
There is a distinction here that matters. The washable version is surprisingly sturdy, but it will smudge if you’re a "crier" or if you have very oily lids. The waterproof version is a different beast entirely. It’s stubborn. You’ll need a dual-phase oil remover to get it off at night.
I’ve seen reviews where people complain that it’s "too hard to remove." That’s actually a sign of a high-quality waterproof polymer. If it came off with a simple face wash, it wouldn't be doing its job of holding that vertical lift. If you find your lashes losing their "angel" wing by noon, switch to the waterproof tube. The extra structural integrity of the waterproof resins acts like a scaffold for your lashes.
Why Pro Makeup Artists Keep it in Their Kit
Go to any backstage fashion show and you’ll likely find a tube of this—or at least the wand. Why? Because it’s the ultimate "detangler."
Sometimes, an artist will apply a thick, volumizing mascara first to get the bulk, and then they’ll go in with the Maybelline Push Up Angel wand to comb through the clumps. It’s the perfect finishing tool. It separates lashes that have stuck together, ensuring that the "fan" effect is perfect.
It’s also a favorite for the "Clean Girl" aesthetic that dominated TikTok and Instagram over the last few years. The trend moved away from the heavy, "Instagram Baddie" makeup toward something more breathable. This mascara fits that vibe perfectly. It makes you look like you just happen to have naturally dark, perfectly combed lashes.
👉 See also: Baba au Rhum Recipe: Why Most Home Bakers Fail at This French Classic
Common Misconceptions and Pitfalls
- "It’s dried out." It’s not. The formula is just thinner by design. Don’t pump the wand; that just introduces air and actually will dry it out.
- "It doesn't add length." It adds "perceived" length. By straightening and lifting from the very base, you're seeing the full extent of your natural lash hair.
- "The brush is too small." Small brushes are actually better for detail. Large brushes are just faster. If you're willing to spend an extra 60 seconds, the small brush will give you a better result every time.
How to Get the Most Out of Maybelline Push Up Angel
If you want to maximize the effect, don't just swipe and go.
First, use a metal lash curler. Give it three good pumps: one at the base, one in the middle, and one at the tip. Then, take the Angel wand and start at the outer corner of your eye. Use the long bristles to pull those lashes toward your temple.
Once the outer corner is set, use the shorter bristles for the inner lashes, pulling them straight up toward your eyebrows. This "split" directionality creates a fan shape. If you want more drama, wait 30 seconds for the first coat to get "tacky" and then apply a second coat only to the tips. This adds length without adding weight to the base, which would otherwise cause the curl to fail.
The reality of the beauty industry is that products get discontinued all the time. But the Push Up Angel has survived because it fills a niche that "mega-volume" mascaras can't touch. It’s for the perfectionist. It’s for the person who hates clumps more than they love volume. It’s for the person who wants their eyes to look wide awake on a Monday morning.
Actionable Steps for Your Next Lash Routine:
- Identify your lash type: If you have thick lashes that clump easily, the Push Up Angel is your solution. If you have very thin lashes, you might want to layer this over a primer.
- The "Double Wand" Technique: Use a volumizing mascara first for the roots, then use the Push Up Angel to comb through the mid-lengths and ends for a polished finish.
- Storage Matters: Keep the tube tightly sealed and avoid "pumping" the wand to prevent the thin formula from oxidizing and thickening prematurely.
- Removal: Invest in a dedicated bi-phase makeup remover (the kind you shake) to ensure you aren't tugging on your delicate eye area, especially if using the waterproof version.