Growing up in the 70s, you couldn't escape the Bradys. They were the ultimate "perfect" family. But if you look closely at those old episodes of The Brady Bunch, especially the ones from the later seasons, you might notice something a little... un-brotherly. There's a look in Greg’s eyes. A certain way Marcia smiles back. Honestly, it wasn't just good acting. Maureen McCormick and Barry Williams were dealing with a massive secret while the cameras rolled: they were falling for each other.
It's wild to think about now. On screen, they were the wholesome eldest siblings leading their pack of four younger brothers and sisters. Off screen? They were two teenagers navigating the messy, high-pressure world of Hollywood fame and a very real, very confusing mutual attraction.
The Hawaii Kiss and the "Dreamy Eyes"
Most fans point to the 1972 Hawaii episodes as the turning point. You remember the one—the cursed tiki, the surfing accidents, the tropical backdrop. But the real drama happened when the sun went down.
In her memoir, Here’s the Story: Surviving Marcia Brady and Finding My True Voice, Maureen admits that the minute she stepped off the plane in Hawaii, her feelings for Barry shifted. It wasn't just a crush anymore. They snuck away for a walk on the beach under the moonlight. Barry later bragged—in a totally teenage way—that he "set it up" and knew exactly where it was headed.
That night, they shared their first kiss.
"It was our first real kiss," Maureen wrote. "And it was long, and it was passionate."
🔗 Read more: Emma Thompson and Family: What Most People Get Wrong About Her Modern Tribe
But here’s the kicker. They had to go back to work the next morning and pretend they were related. It created this bizarre tension that even the producers started to notice. Lloyd Schwartz, the producer and son of creator Sherwood Schwartz, once recalled a scene in the episode "Room at the Top" where Greg sits on Marcia's bed to comfort her. He had to pull Barry aside because the chemistry was just too much. It didn't look like a brother comforting a sister; it looked like a boyfriend comforting a girlfriend.
The Jealousy on Set
Barry Williams has been pretty open lately about how protective he felt. On a 2025 episode of the Real Brady Bros podcast, he chatted with Christopher Knight (who played Peter) about those years. Knight joked that it was obvious to everyone on set. He described Barry as looking "longing and wide-eyed" while Maureen looked "dreamy."
Barry didn't deny it. In fact, he admitted to a specific kind of "set stalking."
Whenever the script called for Marcia to have a boyfriend or go on a date, Barry would make sure he was there. Even if he wasn't in the scene. He’d just hang out near the cameras, making his "presence" known. He wanted to see who she was working with. He wanted to be in her eye line. It was classic teenage jealousy, played out on the most famous soundstage in America.
They had what Barry calls an "on-again, off-again" thing. It would heat up during filming, then they’d go on hiatus, live their separate lives, and find their way back to each other when production started again.
💡 You might also like: How Old Is Breanna Nix? What the American Idol Star Is Doing Now
Why It Never Lasted
So, why didn't the "real" Greg and Marcia become a permanent Hollywood power couple?
- The "Incest" Factor: Even though they weren't related, the public saw them as siblings. The network was terrified of a scandal.
- The Age Gap: Barry was about a year older, but in your teens, that feels like a decade.
- Maureen’s Personal Struggles: After the show ended, Maureen went through a very dark period involving drug addiction and depression. Barry was always a friend, but their paths diverged sharply as they tried to find identities outside of the Brady house.
Life After the Bunch: Still Close in 2026?
It is now 2026, and the bond between Maureen McCormick and Barry Williams is arguably stronger than it was fifty years ago, though it has changed into something much deeper than a teenage fling.
In March 2025, Barry, Mike Lookinland, and Susan Olsen reunited at The Chocolate Expo in New Jersey. While Maureen wasn't at that specific event, she and Barry frequently show up for each other. They both competed on Dancing with the Stars (in different seasons), and they worked side-by-side on HGTV’s A Very Brady Renovation.
Seeing them walk through the reconstructed front door of that Studio City house was a massive moment for fans. They weren't just actors looking at a set; they were two people looking at the place where they grew up, fell in love, and learned how to survive the spotlight.
Maureen has said that doing reboots is hard because she’s "protective" of the legacy. She doesn't want to mess with the memories people have. But she also says the best part of the whole experience was the people.
📖 Related: Whitney Houston Wedding Dress: Why This 1992 Look Still Matters
Lessons from the Brady Romance
Looking back at the history of Maureen McCormick and Barry Williams, there are a few things that actually matter for anyone who grew up watching them.
- Chemistry can't be faked. That’s why people still watch the show. The genuine affection between the cast members—romantic or otherwise—is what made the Bradys feel like a real family.
- Fame is a pressure cooker. It’s a miracle any of those kids came out the other side as functional adults.
- Friendship evolves. They moved from co-stars to secret lovers to distant acquaintances to lifelong friends.
What to Do if You're a Fan Today
If you want to dive deeper into the real story, don't just rely on the TV land reruns.
- Read "Here's the Story": Maureen's book is raw. It doesn't sugarcoat the "Marcia" years, and it gives a very honest look at her relationship with Barry.
- Check out "Growing Up Brady": Barry’s book is the flip side. It’s a bit more lighthearted but filled with the "hormonal teenager" perspective of being the most famous big brother in the world.
- Listen to the Podcasts: Barry and Christopher Knight’s podcast, The Real Brady Bros, is a goldmine for behind-the-scenes trivia that has only come out in the last few years.
The story of Maureen and Barry isn't just about a secret romance. It’s about two people who were tasked with representing the "perfect" American life while they were busy dealing with the messy, beautiful, and complicated reality of being human.
Next Steps for Brady Fans:
Check out the latest episodes of the Real Brady Bros podcast where Barry discusses the 1973 season in detail. You can also look for the 2024 anniversary special clips online, which feature the remaining cast members discussing their 55-year legacy together.