Nobody saw it coming. One minute, you’re scrolling through TikTok watching Matt James and Rachael Kirkconnell inhale luxury sushi in London, and the next, your feed is hit with a cryptic black-and-white prayer about "broken hearts." It was January 16, 2025. A Thursday.
The announcement didn't just break the internet; it shattered the specific corner of the world that believed if these two could survive a literal national racial reckoning, they could survive anything. But they didn't. After four years of "food tours," marathon finishes, and constant "when are you getting engaged?" questions, it all went south in a Tokyo hotel room.
The Breakup That Blindsided Everyone
Honestly, the timeline of the split is enough to give anyone whiplash. Just hours before Matt posted that Instagram prayer, he was sharing videos of matcha lattes. Fans thought he’d been hacked. It felt like a glitch in the Matrix.
But it wasn't a glitch. Rachael later went on the Call Her Daddy podcast and dropped the real tea: she was literally sitting on a plane, taxiing for a 12-hour flight back to the States, when she saw the post. She had no Wi-Fi. No way to respond. Just twelve hours of staring at a seatback screen, knowing the whole world was dissecting her failed relationship. That’s cold.
Why did they actually call it quits?
For a long time, people assumed it was still about the 2021 controversy. You remember—the "Old South" plantation party photos that nearly canceled the franchise. But by 2025, that was old news. They had moved past that. Or so we thought.
💡 You might also like: Is Randy Parton Still Alive? What Really Happened to Dolly’s Brother
According to Rachael, the real issue was simpler and much more painful. Matt basically told her he couldn't see himself married to her. He cited "qualities" he worried about in a wife, specifically regarding accountability.
- The Marriage Goal: In early 2024, Matt told People they wouldn't be together if they weren't aiming for marriage.
- The Reality Check: By 2025, that goal post hadn't moved, but Matt's heart apparently had.
- The Final Straw: A lack of "alignment" on the future.
It's a classic story, really. You stay in a relationship for four years because you've survived trauma together, only to realize the trauma was the only thing holding the glue in place.
Matt James and Rachael: A History of "Almosts"
Their relationship was never normal. It started on a resort in Pennsylvania during a global pandemic. Matt was the first Black Bachelor, carrying the weight of a franchise on his shoulders. Rachael was the front-runner who became the face of a massive cultural debate.
When they first broke up in 2021 after the After the Final Rose special, Matt was firm. He said she didn't "get it." He needed her to "do the work." And she did. Or at least, she tried. They got back together a few months later after she gave him an ultimatum: I'm not just going to be a girl you're talking to. They spent the next few years trying to be the "un-Bachelor" couple. They didn't do the red carpets much. They didn't do the sponsored HelloFresh ads as much as others. They became food influencers. They traveled to Italy, London, and Tokyo. They looked happy. They looked solid.
📖 Related: Patricia Neal and Gary Cooper: The Affair That Nearly Broke Hollywood
The Long Distance Struggle
One thing people forget is that they never actually lived together. Rachael stayed in Georgia; Matt was in Florida or NYC. They were "joined at the hip" but lived out of suitcases. That works for a while. It’s exciting. But eventually, you want to know where you’re going to put your socks.
The "After" Conversations
Following the January 2025 split, things got a little messy, then weirdly quiet. Rachael admitted she felt "blindsided" and "shocked." Matt, for his part, stayed mostly silent, leaning into his fitness content and charity work with ABC Food Tours.
In March 2025, Rachael appeared on The Squeeze podcast and revealed they’d finally had a "real" conversation. Matt apologized. He took some of his harsher words back. He gave her the closure she needed. But he didn't ask for her back.
Where do they stand in 2026?
Today, they are "all good," but they aren't friends. Rachael has been spotted liking Matt's posts about his travels in Africa, but she’s quick to tell fans "fear not"—a reunion isn't happening. She’s focusing on being a "hopeless romantic" on her own terms. Matt is... well, Matt is still running marathons and posting about his mom, Patty.
👉 See also: What Really Happened With the Death of John Candy: A Legacy of Laughter and Heartbreak
What Most People Get Wrong
The biggest misconception is that the relationship was fake or "for the 'gram." If you look at the evidence, they stayed together long after the Bachelor fame faded. They stayed together when it was actually bad for their brands to be associated with each other.
Another mistake? Thinking Rachael didn't want to get married. She was ready. She was waiting for a ring that was "talking plenty" about by Matt's friends (like T.J. Holmes) but never actually materialized.
Lessons from the Matt and Rachael Saga
Relationships that start in a pressure cooker rarely survive the cooling-off period. They beat the odds for four years, which is a lifetime in "Bachelor years," but eventually, the fundamental differences—how they handle conflict and how they view "accountability"—caught up to them.
If you’re following their journey, here is what you can actually do to stay updated without the clickbait:
- Check their individual socials for career shifts: Rachael is leaning heavily into fashion and solo travel, while Matt is doubling down on philanthropy.
- Ignore the "reunion" rumors: Unless you see a joint statement, a "like" on Instagram is just a "like."
- Focus on the growth: Both have spoken about how much they learned about themselves during the 2021-2025 era.
It’s a wrap on one of reality TV's most complex chapters. They aren't villains, and they aren't perfect. They’re just two people who tried to make a very public mistake work in private, until they couldn't anymore.
To stay truly informed, look for long-form interviews on reputable podcasts like Call Her Daddy or The Squeeze, as these stars now prefer controlled environments over messy tabloid snippets.