Let’s be real for a second. If you lived in a town where your sister was murdered by a vampire, your girlfriend was turned into one, and your best friend was a hybrid who occasionally felt the urge to rip people’s heads off, you’d probably be a little grumpy too.
But for some reason, Matt Donovan became the punching bag of the Vampire Diaries fandom.
He’s the guy everyone loves to hate. Or, more accurately, the guy everyone loves to call "boring" while they thirst over thousand-year-old mass murderers in leather jackets. It’s a weird dynamic. We watch a show about the supernatural and then get mad when the one guy who stays human actually acts like a human.
The Mystery of Matt Donovan and His "Plot Armor"
You’ve seen the memes. Matt Donovan is basically the cockroach of Mystic Falls. He survives everything. He’s been drowned, neck-snapped (while wearing the Gilbert ring, obviously), hexed, and possessed by a Traveler. Yet, while fan favorites like Stefan Salvatore or Alaric Saltzman (temporarily) bit the dust, Matt just kept showing up for his shift at the Mystic Grill.
It feels like a glitch in the Matrix.
Honestly, the writers—led by Julie Plec and Kevin Williamson—knew exactly what they were doing. Matt was the "Designated Human." Every supernatural show needs one. You have Xander in Buffy, Stiles in Teen Wolf, and in the world of The Vampire Diaries, you have Matt. He is the yardstick. Without him, we lose the sense of how much damage the Salvatore brothers actually do.
If everyone is a superhero, nobody is. Matt’s existence reminds us that a "simple" bite from Damon isn't just a sexy plot point; it’s a life-altering trauma for a normal person.
✨ Don't miss: Temuera Morrison as Boba Fett: Why Fans Are Still Divided Over the Daimyo of Tatooine
Why the Hate is Actually Kind of Unfair
People call him a "crybaby" or "hypocritical." They point to Season 7, where he basically goes full "get off my lawn" and tries to kick every vampire out of town.
But look at his track record:
- His sister, Vicki, was turned and killed in the first few episodes.
- His mom was a total deadbeat who abandoned him.
- He had to work a full-time job at 17 just to keep the lights on while his friends were off having magical tea parties.
- He accidentally killed his fiancée, Penny Ares, because of a supernatural-induced misunderstanding.
If that happened to anyone else, we’d call it a tragic origin story. When it happens to Matt, fans just roll their eyes.
There’s this unspoken rule in the TVD universe: if you aren't "cool" or "magical," your trauma doesn't count. We forgive Damon for killing Lexi because he’s charming. We forgive Klaus for... well, everything... because he’s Klaus. But Matt? Matt gets yelled at for being "preachy" because he thinks maybe, just maybe, people shouldn't be murdered in the streets of his hometown.
From Busboy to Mayor: The Long Game
One thing most people overlook is that Matt Donovan actually "won" the show.
While the supernatural characters ended up dead, in "Peace," or mourning their lost immortality, Matt climbed the social ladder. He started as a high school jock who was dating the lead girl. Then he was the busboy. Then a deputy. Then the Sheriff.
🔗 Read more: Why Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy Actors Still Define the Modern Spy Thriller
By the time we get to the spinoff Legacies, he’s the Mayor of Mystic Falls.
That’s a hell of a glow-up for a guy who spent the first three seasons just trying to make sure his truck didn't break down. He outlived the vampires. He outlived the witches. He outlived the "Invincible" Originals. He stayed human, kept his soul mostly intact, and ended up running the place.
The Rebekah Mikaelson Factor
If you want to see the best version of Matt, look at his relationship with Rebekah.
She was an Original vampire with more baggage than an airport, and she was obsessed with him. Why? Because he was "good." He was the only person who didn't want anything from her. He didn't want her blood, her power, or her protection. He just wanted to see Europe.
That summer road trip they took? That was probably the most "normal" Matt ever got to be. It showed that he wasn't just a "vampire hater"—he was a guy who responded to kindness. If a vampire treated him like a person, he treated them back with respect. If they treated him like a snack, he reached for his wooden bullets. Fair deal, right?
What Most People Get Wrong About His Survival
There’s a theory that Matt only survived because the actors liked Zach Roerig. While the cast definitely loved him (he's famously one of the nicest guys on set), Matt’s survival was a narrative necessity.
💡 You might also like: The Entire History of You: What Most People Get Wrong About the Grain
He represents the town itself.
Mystic Falls is a character in The Vampire Diaries. It’s a place of history, "family values," and hidden darkness. Matt is the human personification of that town. If Matt dies, the town's "humanity" is officially gone. By keeping him alive, the show kept a foot in reality.
He was also the only one who could bridge the gap between the "Founding Families" and the "Supernatural Squad." He knew the secrets, but he held the badge.
Actionable Insights for Your Next Rewatch
If you’re planning a rewatch and you usually skip the Matt scenes, try looking at it through a different lens this time.
- Watch his facial expressions when the vampires talk about "collateral damage." He’s often the only one reacting with actual horror while everyone else just moves on to the next plan.
- Pay attention to his work ethic. In a show where no one seems to have a job or go to class, Matt is constantly working. It’s a grounded detail that makes the world feel real.
- Notice the subtle ways he protects people. He’s the one who stays behind to help the townspeople during the big disasters while the mains are off fighting the villain of the week.
Matt Donovan isn't the hero we want—the one with the cool powers and the snappy dialogue. He’s the hero Mystic Falls actually needed. He’s the guy who stays behind to clean up the mess after the "epic love stories" have burnt the house down.
Honestly, he’s probably the most relatable character on the show. Most of us aren't Salvatores. We’re Donovans. We’re just trying to survive the week without getting caught in the crossfire of someone else’s drama.
Next time you see a Matt Donovan meme, remember: the guy became the Mayor while everyone else was busy being dead. Who’s the "boring" one now?
To truly appreciate the scope of Matt’s journey, you should track his transition from Sheriff in the TVD series finale to his brief but telling appearances in The Originals and Legacies. Seeing how he interacts with Alaric Saltzman as a peer—rather than a student or a victim—really puts his evolution into perspective.