Mary Todd Lincoln was not a "monster." Honestly, if you grew up hearing the typical history book version of her, you probably think of a screeching, spendthrift woman who made Abraham Lincoln’s life a living hell. The "Hellcat" of the White House. But history has a funny way of scrubbing out the nuance.
She was arguably the most educated woman to ever step foot in the White House up to that point. She spoke fluent French. She was a political strategist who helped a backwoods lawyer become a President. And yeah, she was also a woman who watched three of her four sons die and saw her husband’s brains blown out while she was holding his hand.
Basically, we've spent a century judging a woman for having a nervous breakdown while the world was literally on fire.
The Myth of the "Uneducated" Westerner
People in Washington hated her from the jump. Because she was from Kentucky, the Eastern elite looked at her like some unrefined rustic. This is wild because Mary was actually way more "polished" than most of them. She spent years at Madame Mentelle’s finishing school. She studied drama, music, and French literature.
When Prince Napoleon Joseph Charles Paul Bonaparte visited the White House in 1861, Mary didn't need a translator. She chatted with him in his native tongue. Can you imagine the shock on the faces of those D.C. socialites?
She wasn't just a trophy wife. Far from it.
A Political Partner, Not Just a Spouse
Mary was Abraham’s "sounding board." Historians like Catherine Clinton have pointed out that Mary actually pushed Lincoln’s ambition. In 1849, she was the one who pressured him not to take the governorship of Oregon. Why? Because it was a political dead end. She knew he was meant for bigger things.
✨ Don't miss: Why the Siege of Vienna 1683 Still Echoes in European History Today
When he finally won the presidency in 1860, he didn't say "I won." He ran home and shouted, "Mary, Mary, we are elected!"
Why She Spent $27,000 on "Flub-a-Dubs"
The shopping. We have to talk about the shopping.
By 1864, Mary was $27,000 in debt. In 1860s money, that is an astronomical, "holy-crap" level of debt. She bought 300 pairs of kid gloves in four months. She bought expensive French wallpaper and fine china. Abraham called these things "flub-a-Dubs" and he was, understandably, pretty pissed about it.
But context matters.
The White House was a dump when they moved in. It was literally falling apart, smelling of sewage and old tobacco. Mary felt that the "People’s House" needed to look like a symbol of Union strength while the country was splitting apart. If the First Lady looked like a ragamuffin, what did that say about the strength of the North?
There’s also a modern medical take on this. Some researchers, like those published in PubMed, suggest she might have suffered from pernicious anemia (a Vitamin B12 deficiency). This causes:
🔗 Read more: Why the Blue Jordan 13 Retro Still Dominates the Streets
- Irritability
- Delusions
- Physical weakness
- Mood swings
Others point to Bipolar Disorder or PTSD. She wasn't just "crazy"; she was likely self-medicating her grief and physical pain through "retail therapy" before that was even a term.
The Betrayal: Robert Lincoln and the Insanity Trial
The saddest part of the Mary Todd Lincoln story isn't the assassination. It’s what happened ten years later. In 1875, her only surviving son, Robert, did the unthinkable. He had her followed by private detectives. He orchestrated a "surprise" insanity trial.
Imagine being Mary. You’re sitting in a courtroom, and 17 witnesses—most of whom you barely know—testify that you’re a lunatic because you carry your bonds in a skirt pocket or you shop too much.
Robert stood up and said:
"I have no doubt my mother is insane. She has long been a source of great anxiety to me."
The jury took ten minutes to decide. Ten minutes. They sent her to Bellevue Place, a private asylum.
💡 You might also like: Sleeping With Your Neighbor: Why It Is More Complicated Than You Think
She didn't take it lying down, though. Mary was a fighter. She smuggled letters to her lawyer, James Bradwell, and his wife Myra. She leaked her story to the press. She basically embarrassed Robert into letting her go. A year later, a second jury declared her sane. She never really forgave him. Who could?
What We Can Learn From Mary Today
Mary Todd Lincoln was a "chameleon." She was a grieving mother, a fierce Unionist with brothers fighting for the Confederacy, and a woman trapped in a time that had no words for mental health.
If you want to really understand her, stop looking at the caricatures.
Actionable Insights for History Buffs:
- Read the Keckley Memoirs: Elizabeth Keckley was Mary’s dressmaker and a formerly enslaved woman. Her book, Behind the Scenes, gives the most "human" look at Mary’s life behind closed doors.
- Visit the Mary Todd Lincoln House: It’s in Lexington, Kentucky. Seeing the refined world she came from makes her "western" reputation in D.C. seem even more ridiculous.
- Check the Medical Evidence: Look up the 2016 study on her potential B12 deficiency. It changes how you view her "moodiness" entirely.
She died in 1882, mostly blind and in pain, back in her sister’s house in Springfield. The same house where she had married Abraham forty years earlier. She wasn't a villain. She was just a woman who had been through more than any one person was ever meant to handle.
Next time you see a picture of her looking "stern," remember she was probably just trying to hold it all together.
Next Steps for Research
To get a deeper sense of the real Mary, you should compare the newspaper accounts of the 1875 trial with the personal letters she wrote to Myra Bradwell during her confinement. This reveals the sharp, tactical mind that remained intact even when she was labeled "insane." You can also look into the "Old Clothes Scandal" of 1867 to see how the press treated her attempt to gain financial independence after the President's death.