Let’s be real. If you walked into a party in 2010 wearing neon-colored hair and a subspace messenger bag, you weren't just a fan. You were trying to be her. Mary Elizabeth Winstead as Ramona Flowers didn't just play a character; she essentially birthed a blueprint for the "mysterious girl" trope that an entire generation of indie-movie lovers obsessed over.
It’s been over a decade. We’ve seen the graphic novels, the cult-classic film Scott Pilgrim vs. the World, and most recently, the Netflix anime Scott Pilgrim Takes Off. Yet, somehow, Winstead’s portrayal remains the gold standard. Why? Because she didn’t play Ramona like a cartoon. She played her like a person who was actually, genuinely exhausted by her own baggage.
The Secret Layers of Ramona Flowers
Most people think Ramona is just about the hair. Pink, blue, green—whatever. But Winstead brought this specific, low-key sadness to the role that most "Manic Pixie Dream Girls" usually lack. Honestly, it’s what saved the character from being a total cliché.
When director Edgar Wright was filming the 2010 movie, he gave Winstead a list of ten secret facts about Ramona’s past that weren't in the comics or the script. One of those secrets, which Winstead eventually let slip in an interview years later, was that Ramona’s younger brother had died when she was little. That black string she wears around her neck? It was actually one of his shoelaces.
Knowing that changes the whole vibe. Suddenly, her "mysterious" distance feels more like a defense mechanism. She isn't just "cool" because she's from New York; she’s guarded because she’s been through some heavy stuff.
📖 Related: The A Wrinkle in Time Cast: Why This Massive Star Power Didn't Save the Movie
Why the Casting Almost Didn't Work
It’s hard to imagine anyone else in those boots, but at the time, Winstead was mostly known as a "Scream Queen." She’d done Final Destination 3, Black Christmas, and Death Proof. Jumping into a hyper-stylized action-comedy with Michael Cera was a pivot.
But Winstead was actually 25 during filming—the exact age Knives Chau guesses Ramona is in the movie. That age gap between her and the teenaged characters was vital. She needed to feel like she was from a different world, someone who had lived a hundred lives before landing in Toronto.
Training for the League of Evil Exes
If you think the fights were all CGI and stunt doubles, you’ve clearly never seen the behind-the-scenes footage. Winstead and the rest of the cast spent months in intensive training. We’re talking basic martial arts, wire-work, and learning how to swing a massive hammer without taking out a light rig.
- The Hammer: It was big. It was heavy. Winstead actually suffered from tendonitis and pulled her shoulder multiple times while filming the fight scenes.
- The Rollerblades: Remember the scene where she's delivering packages in the snow? Not easy.
- The Hair: It wasn't just a wig (though she definitely wore them). The production went through dozens of iterations to get that specific "DIY but expensive" look.
Breaking the "Manic Pixie" Mold
For a long time, Ramona was criticized for being a prize for Scott to win. She was "the girl." The anime, Scott Pilgrim Takes Off, finally gave Winstead a chance to fix that.
👉 See also: Cuba Gooding Jr OJ: Why the Performance Everyone Hated Was Actually Genius
In the show, the plot flips. Scott disappears, and Ramona becomes the detective of her own life. Winstead has talked about how cathartic this was. She finally got to voice a Ramona who wasn't just "watching things happen" because of her. She was the one taking the reins.
The voice acting in the anime is interesting because it feels different from the 2010 movie. Some fans complained it sounded "too relaxed," but if you listen closely, it’s just Ramona being older. More mature. Less like she has to put on a performance for everyone else.
The Wardrobe That Defined a Decade
You cannot talk about Mary Elizabeth Winstead as Ramona Flowers without talking about the clothes. Costume designer Ruth Myers created a look that was basically "Amazon Ninja Chic."
- The Subspace Bag: Every alt-girl in 2011 had some version of this.
- The Goggles: Steampunk was having a moment, and Ramona made it look wearable.
- The Boots: Heavy, practical, and perfect for kicking ex-boyfriends into piles of coins.
The real magic, though, was in the colors. Each hair color change wasn't just for show; it signaled a shift in her relationship with Scott. It’s visual storytelling at its most basic, but it worked.
✨ Don't miss: Greatest Rock and Roll Singers of All Time: Why the Legends Still Own the Mic
How to Channel the Ramona Energy (Without the Ex-Boyfriend Drama)
If you’re looking to dive deeper into the lore or just appreciate the craft behind the character, here is what you actually need to do:
- Watch the 2010 film with the commentary track. Listening to Edgar Wright and Bryan Lee O'Malley talk about Winstead’s "dryness" is a masterclass in character acting.
- Check out Winstead’s other "tough" roles. If you liked her as Ramona, watch 10 Cloverfield Lane or Kate. You’ll see the same "don't mess with me" DNA, but stripped of the neon aesthetic.
- Binge the Netflix anime. Even if you hate "reboots," this one is a sequel-in-disguise. It gives Ramona the internal monologue she always deserved.
Basically, Ramona Flowers worked because Mary Elizabeth Winstead didn't treat her like a trope. She treated her like a woman who had made a lot of mistakes and was just trying to find a quiet place to drink some tea.
Next steps for your Scott Pilgrim obsession: Go back and watch the scenes where Ramona is by herself—no Scott, no exes. Watch her face. Winstead’s best work as Ramona isn't when she's swinging the hammer; it's when she's sitting on the couch, looking like she’s a thousand miles away. That’s the "secret" to the character that everyone else misses.