Martha Stewart Sports Illustrated Photos: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes

When the first martha stewart sports illustrated photos hit the internet in May 2023, it felt like a collective "wait, what?" moment for the entire world. People weren't just surprised; they were kind of obsessed. At 81, Martha didn’t just show up in a bathing suit—she broke the record as the oldest cover model in the magazine's history, snatching the title from Maye Musk.

Honestly, it wasn't just a lifestyle mogul posing in the Dominican Republic. It was a massive cultural pivot.

The Preparation Nobody Talks About

You might think someone like Martha just rolls out of bed and looks that good. Wrong. She’s famously disciplined, but the lead-up to this shoot was next-level. She basically cut out all bread and pasta for two months. Two months! For a woman who built an empire on carbs and comfort food, that's a serious commitment.

She also ramped up her Pilates sessions to every other day. She told the Today show that she didn't starve herself, but she was intentional. She wanted to feel strong.

The shoot took place at the Casa de Campo Resort & Villas. If you’ve never seen the photos, Ruven Afanador was the eye behind the lens. He’s a legend in his own right, known for high-drama, sculptural photography. He didn't just take pictures of her; he captured a version of Martha that was part Hollywood starlet, part "coolest woman you know."

What was she actually wearing?

People always ask about the swimsuits. It wasn't just one look. She had ten different outfits, ranging from a plunging white one-piece by Monday Swimwear to a fiery red halter suit.

👉 See also: Why the Man Black Hair Blue Eyes Combo is So Rare (and the Genetics Behind It)

• The Cover Look: A white plunging swimsuit paired with an orange-gold cover-up by TORSO CREATIONS.
• The Metallic Vibe: A sporty, black-and-silver zip-up suit that felt surprisingly modern.
• The Accessories: Think Anita Ko jewelry and Jacob & Co. rings. This wasn't a "budget" beach day.

Why the Martha Stewart Sports Illustrated Photos Mattered

There’s this weird thing in our culture where women over a certain age are expected to just... disappear? Become invisible? Martha basically said "no thanks" to that.

She wasn't trying to look 20. She was trying to look like a very healthy, very successful 81-year-old. She calls it "successful living" rather than "aging." It sounds a bit like corporate branding, but when you look at the photos, it’s hard to argue with the results.

The Critics vs. The Fans

Not everyone was clapping. If you head over to Reddit or read certain editorials from The Guardian, you’ll see the pushback. Some critics argued that the photos were too heavily edited. They felt that by smoothing out the reality of being 81, the magazine was actually reinforcing the same youth-obsessed standards it claimed to be breaking.

Then there’s the "male gaze" argument. Is putting an 81-year-old in a swimsuit a win for feminism, or is it just proving that a woman’s value is always tied to how she looks in a bikini?

Martha’s take? She did it for herself. She told the SI team, "I'm doing it for me." She wanted to see if she could still be photogenic and attractive at that stage of her life.

✨ Don't miss: Chuck E. Cheese in Boca Raton: Why This Location Still Wins Over Parents

The 2024 Return: Becoming a Legend

Fast forward to 2024. Martha didn't just do a one-and-done. She returned for the 60th-anniversary issue as an "SI Swimsuit Legend."

This time, she wasn't alone in the Dominican Republic. She was in Hollywood, Florida, at the Seminole Hard Rock Hotel. She posed with 26 other icons, including Christie Brinkley, Tyra Banks, and Kate Upton.

The vibe for the 2024 martha stewart sports illustrated photos was way more "Old Hollywood Glam." She wore a stunning golden Jenny Packham dress. It felt less like a swimsuit shoot and more like a victory lap. She looked like she belonged there, which, given her track record, she absolutely did.

How to Get the "Martha Look" (Even if You're Not 81)

Look, most of us don't have a personal chef or the time for Pilates four times a week. But there are a few takeaways from Martha’s SI journey that actually work for regular people.

1. Hydration is non-negotiable. Martha is a freak about skin prep. Her makeup artist, Daisy Toye, used a mix of high-end serums and affordable items (like a $16 L'Oréal primer) to get that glow.
2. Confidence is the main ingredient. She didn't look uncomfortable. She looked like she owned the beach. That kind of "inner swagger" translates to the camera.
3. Consistency over intensity. She’s been doing Pilates for years. It’s not about a two-week "shred"; it’s about a decades-long commitment to movement.

The reality is that martha stewart sports illustrated photos will probably be talked about for years because they forced a conversation we weren't ready to have. They challenged the idea of what an "elderly" woman should look like and what she’s allowed to do.

🔗 Read more: The Betta Fish in Vase with Plant Setup: Why Your Fish Is Probably Miserable

Whether you love her or think the whole thing was a PR stunt, you have to admit: the woman knows how to make an entrance. And an exit.

To really capture the Martha energy in your own life, start by focusing on "successful living" rather than just avoiding birthdays. Prioritize strength training or Pilates to maintain your posture, and don't be afraid to take a few risks with your personal style, no matter the number on your ID. If you're interested in the specific skincare routine she used for the shoot, looking into Mario Badescu products (a long-time favorite of hers) is a great place to begin.

The impact of Martha's appearance continues to ripple through the fashion industry, with more brands now casting models in their 70s and 80s for major campaigns. It wasn't just a magazine cover; it was a shift in the business of beauty.

To apply this "Martha mindset," start by challenging one of your own self-imposed limitations this week—whether it’s trying a new fitness class or finally wearing that bold outfit you’ve been saving. Consistency in your routine is key, so find a physical activity you actually enjoy, like Pilates or walking, and stick to it for at least three weeks to see real shifts in your energy and confidence.