You’ve felt it before. That specific sort of quiet that settles over a town when a staple finally pulls down the blinds for the last time. In Corning, New York, that quiet hit hard in early 2024. For nearly three decades, Market Street Brewing Company wasn't just a place to grab a pint; it was the literal anchor of the Gaffer District’s social life.
It was the first brewery in Steuben County since the dark days of Prohibition. Let that sink in. Before the "craft beer revolution" was a buzzword whispered in every hipster enclave, this place was already mashing grains and boiling hops at 63 West Market Street.
But honestly, the story of this place isn't just about beer. It’s about a rooftop that felt like the only place in the world on a July evening and a bowl of soup that people still talk about like it was a religious experience.
The 27-Year Run: Why This Place Stuck
Most restaurants are lucky to survive three years. Market Street Brewing Company did twenty-seven. Founded in 1997, it survived the shifting tastes of the early 2000s, the 2008 crash, and a global pandemic.
The secret sauce wasn't actually the sauce—though the Beer-B-Q was pretty great. It was the vibe. Walking in felt like stepping into a well-worn leather glove. It was warm, slightly noisy, and smelled like roasted malt and frying onions. It was "turnkey" before realtors turned that into a cliché.
✨ Don't miss: How to Sign Someone Up for Scientology: What Actually Happens and What You Need to Know
The brewery was famous for its consistency. In an old interview, the management once admitted they didn't locally source every single carrot or onion because they had spent 20 years locking in a specific flavor profile. They knew what people wanted. They wanted the MSBC Soup—that creamy, lemon-rosemary artichoke concoction—and they wanted it to taste exactly the same every single time.
The Beer That Defined the District
Let’s talk about the Wrought Iron Red. For a long time, if you were in Corning and you wanted something that wasn't a mass-produced light lager, you ordered a Red.
The lineup was classic:
- Mad Bug Lager: The easy drinker.
- Brisco Bridge Blackberry: A fruit beer that didn't taste like cough syrup (a rare feat).
- D’Artagnan Dark: A stout for people who think they don't like stouts.
- Potbelly Pale Ale: Balanced, not the hop-bomb palate wreckers that became popular later.
They weren't trying to reinvent the wheel. They weren't putting marshmallow fluff or glitter in their fermenters. They were making "dad beer" before that was a compliment, and they did it well.
🔗 Read more: Wire brush for cleaning: What most people get wrong about choosing the right bristles
That Rooftop and the "Only One" Factor
If you ask a local what they miss most, they won't say the IPA. They’ll say the roof.
For the longest time, Market Street Brewing Company had the only rooftop dining and outdoor patio on Market Street. It looked out over the historic brick buildings and the bustle of the Gaffer District. There was a fountain. There was a breeze. It was the "prime" spot.
In the final years, things got a bit rocky. There were reports of brewing issues, and for a while, they were actually serving guest taps from other local spots like Lucky Hare or Meier's Creek because their own systems were struggling. But people still showed up. They showed up for the giant grilled cheese and the sushi nachos.
What Really Happened with the Closure?
In February 2024, the news dropped on Facebook: they were shutting down indefinitely. No massive scandal. No dramatic blowout. Just a "thank you" to the patrons and a quiet exit.
💡 You might also like: Images of Thanksgiving Holiday: What Most People Get Wrong
The building, which includes the brewery equipment and a fully equipped kitchen, hit the market shortly after. As of late 2025 and into 2026, the community has been buzzing with rumors. Is it going to be a new brewery? Will the Nickel's Pit BBQ crew take it over? Or will it become another boutique shop?
The reality is that 63 West Market Street is a beast of a building. It's historic, it's large, and it needs someone with a massive vision (and a healthy bank account) to maintain that "gold standard" of downtown revitalization that Corning is known for.
Why It Matters Now
The loss of Market Street Brewing Company left a hole in the Gaffer District, but it also paved the way for the "new guard." You’ve got Liquid Shoes Brewing just down the street, doing the hazy, experimental stuff. You’ve got Iron Flamingo distributing bottles.
But there’s a nuance here that's easy to miss. Market Street Brewing was a brewpub in the truest sense—a place where the food was just as important as the drink. Most modern breweries are "tasting rooms" first, with a food truck parked outside if you're lucky. Market Street was a full-service experience.
Real Talk: The Pros and Cons of the Legacy
| What They Nailed | Where It Got Tough |
|---|---|
| Atmosphere: The rooftop was unbeatable. | Consistency: In later years, beer production stalled. |
| The Food: Artichoke soup and burgers were legendary. | Pricing: Some patrons felt the "tourist tax" was getting high. |
| History: First brewery in the county since 1933. | Modernity: The "stay the course" menu felt dated to some. |
Actionable Insights for Your Next Corning Visit
Since you can't currently grab a Wrought Iron Red at the source, here is how to navigate the Corning beer scene right now:
- For the Hops: Head to Liquid Shoes Brewing. Their "26 East IPA" is the current local favorite for the New England Style crowd.
- For the Vibe: If you miss the "old world" feel, The Cellar nearby offers that upscale-but-comfortable atmosphere, though it’s more wine-focused.
- For the History: Walk past 63 West Market. Look up at the rooftop. It’s a reminder of what started the craft movement in this corner of New York.
- Keep an Eye on the Listing: The building is a "turnkey" opportunity. If you see construction crews or new signage, it means the next chapter of Corning’s brewing history is finally starting.
Corning’s Gaffer District is resilient. It was rebuilt after the '72 flood and it will reinvent itself after this. But for those of us who spent twenty years leaning against that wood bar, there will never quite be another Market Street Brewing Company. It was the right place at the right time, and it stayed just long enough to become a legend.