Market Research in Business: What Most People Get Wrong

Market Research in Business: What Most People Get Wrong

You’ve probably seen the meme of the person trying to draw a horse from memory. It starts out okay with the legs, but by the time they get to the head, it looks like a confused potato. That’s exactly what happens when people talk about market research in business without actually talking to a single customer. They guess. They use "gut feeling." Then they wonder why their $50,000 product launch sank like a lead balloon.

Business is risky. Honestly, it’s terrifying. But the biggest mistake most founders and marketing directors make isn’t failing to do research—it’s doing the wrong kind of research. They look at a spreadsheet of demographic data and think they know their audience. Newsflash: a 35-year-old guy in Chicago who likes golf isn't a persona. It's a data point. It tells you nothing about why he buys.

The Death of the Focus Group (and why that's good)

Remember those one-way mirrors in the 90s? Companies would pay people $50 and a slice of lukewarm pizza to sit in a room and lie to them. Not intentionally, mind you. But humans are social creatures. If one loud guy in a focus group says he hates the color blue, half the room will nod along because they don’t want to be the "blue guy."

That’s why modern market research in business has shifted toward what the pros call "ethnographic research" or "jobs-to-be-done" (JTBD). Developed by people like Tony Ulwick and the late Harvard Business School professor Clayton Christensen, JTBD suggests that people don't buy products; they "hire" them to do a job.

Think about a milkshake. If you just look at demographics, you’ll never understand why people buy them at 8:00 AM. But when researchers actually stood in a McDonald's and watched, they realized people "hired" the milkshake to keep them occupied during a boring morning commute. It lasted longer than a donut and fit in a cupholder. That is a real insight. You can't get that from a Google Form.

Why Your Surveys are Garbage

Most surveys suck. There, I said it.

💡 You might also like: Writing a Reference Letter for a Friend: How to Help Without Looking Unprofessional

If you send out a survey asking, "Would you buy this product for $20?" almost everyone will say yes. Why? Because saying yes is free. It costs them nothing to be polite. But the second you ask for a credit card number, that "yes" evaporates.

Experts like Rob Fitzpatrick, author of The Mom Test, argue that you should never ask people about the future. They don’t know what they’ll do in the future. Instead, ask them about the past.

  • Bad question: "Would you use an app that tracks your water intake?"
  • Good question: "Tell me about the last time you tried to track how much water you drank. What did you use? Why did you stop?"

If they tell you they tried three different apps and a physical notebook, you have a market. If they say they’ve never thought about it, your "innovative" app is dead on arrival. This is the bedrock of market research in business. It’s about finding existing pain, not inventing it.

The Quantitative vs. Qualitative Tug-of-War

You need both. If you only do qualitative (interviews, observations), you might get biased by one very charismatic person who loves your idea. If you only do quantitative (big data, analytics), you’ll know what is happening but never why.

Imagine your website's bounce rate is 80%. The data tells you people are leaving. That's the what. But the data won't tell you that they’re leaving because your "Sign Up" button looks like an annoying ad. You need to watch a user session or talk to a customer to find the why.

Real World Example: Netflix and the "New" Market

Netflix is the king of data-driven market research in business. But they don't just look at what you watch; they look at when you pause, when you rewind, and when you give up on a show entirely. When they produced House of Cards, it wasn't a gamble. They knew a specific segment of their audience loved David Fincher, loved Kevin Spacey, and loved the original British version of the show. They didn't need to ask if people wanted it. They already had the behavioral proof.

But even giants fail. Remember "Qwikster"? Netflix tried to split their DVD and streaming services into two companies. On paper, the logistics made sense. In reality, customers hated the complexity. They ignored the "emotional" research of customer convenience in favor of "logical" operational research. It cost them 800,000 subscribers almost overnight.

How to Actually Do the Work

Stop looking for "industry reports" that cost $4,000 and were written six months ago. By the time those are published, the market has moved.

Instead, look at where the "unfiltered" humans hang out.

  1. Reddit and Niche Forums: Go to a subreddit related to your industry. Look for threads starting with "How do I..." or "I'm so frustrated with..." This is free gold. People are literally shouting their problems into the void.
  2. Review Mining: Go to your competitor’s Amazon page or G2 profile. Filter by 3-star reviews. Why 3 stars? Because 1-star reviews are often just angry rants, and 5-star reviews are often fanboys. 3-star reviews are where the honest critiques live. "I liked the product, but it was too heavy." Boom. There’s your market opportunity.
  3. Shadowing: If you’re a B2B company, go sit in your customer’s office. Watch them work. You’ll see them use a "workaround" for a problem they didn't even realize they had.

The Bias Trap

We all have it. Confirmation bias is the silent killer of market research in business. You want your idea to work, so you unconsciously lead the witness.

"Don't you think this interface is cleaner than the old one?"

That's a loaded question. You're basically begging them to agree with you. A better researcher stays neutral. They say, "Show me how you'd perform [Task X] using this." Then they shut up. They don't help. They don't explain. They just watch the user struggle. That struggle is where the profit is.

💡 You might also like: Danny Weisman Marketing Week: Why the Hype About Obsessed Media is Real

Market Research in Business: The Cost of Ignoring It

Look at Quibi. They raised $1.75 billion. Billion. With a 'B'. They had the best Hollywood talent and the best tech. What they didn't have was a clear understanding of how people actually consume short-form video. They thought people wanted "premium" 10-minute shows on their phones.

In reality, people use their phones for "gap time"—waiting for a bus, sitting in a doctor's office. During those times, they want TikTok or YouTube, which are free and social. Quibi didn't allow screenshots or social sharing at launch. They did "research" on what they thought people should want, rather than how people actually behaved. They shut down in six months.

Actionable Insights for Your Next Move

If you’re ready to stop guessing and start knowing, here is how you should actually approach market research in business without losing your mind or your budget.

First, kill your darlings. Go into your research trying to prove your idea is bad. If you try to prove it’s good, you’ll find a way to justify any data point. But if you try to "break" your business model and it still holds up? That’s when you know you’re onto something real.

Second, talk to 10 people. Not your mom. Not your co-founders. 10 strangers who fit your target profile. Ask them about their problems, not your solution. If 8 out of 10 mention the same headache, you’ve found your value proposition.

Third, watch the money. Watch where your customers are already spending money to solve the problem. If they are spending $0 and just "dealing with it," it’s going to be a hard sell. If they are spending $500 on a clunky, outdated solution, they will happily give you $200 for a better one.

Fourth, iterate fast. Don't spend six months on a research whitepaper. Spend a week talking to people, build a "smoke test" (like a simple landing page), and see if anyone clicks. Real-world behavior is the only data that matters at the end of the day.

💡 You might also like: The Art of Public Speaking: Why Your Preparation Is Probably Working Against You

The landscape of market research in business isn't about being the smartest person in the room with the biggest deck of slides. It’s about being the most curious person in the room who isn't afraid to be wrong. The market doesn't care about your feelings, but it will tell you exactly how to win if you're willing to actually listen.

Next Steps for Implementation

  • Identify your top three assumptions about your customer (e.g., "They care about price more than speed").
  • Find five 3-star reviews of your closest competitor and note the specific "missing features" mentioned.
  • Schedule three 15-minute "discovery calls" with people in your target audience this week—offer no sales pitch, only questions about their workflow.
  • Audit your current data: Are you tracking "vanity metrics" (likes, views) or "intent metrics" (repeat visits, time spent on key pages)?