If you grew up in the late eighties, you probably have a stack of 1987 Topps cards sitting in a shoebox somewhere. You know the ones—the wood-grain borders that looked like a cheap station wagon. Somewhere in that pile, there’s likely a Mark McGwire. You might think that's his "rookie card." Honestly, it’s not that simple.
The world of the mark mcgwire rookie card is a messy, confusing, and surprisingly expensive rabbit hole. While most people point to the 1987 issues where he’s wearing an Oakland A's jersey, the serious money is on a card printed two years earlier.
The 1985 Topps #401: The Real Heavyweight
Technically, Big Mac's first appearance on a major league licensed card happened in 1985. He wasn't even in the pros yet. He was part of the 1984 USA Olympic team.
📖 Related: Lausanne Switzerland Diamond League: Why Athletissima Still Matters
This card, the 1985 Topps #401, is the one everyone actually wants. It features a baby-faced McGwire with a bat on his shoulder, wearing that iconic red, white, and blue "USA" jersey. It’s a weird card because it predates his MLB debut by over a year.
Back in the day, collectors didn't know what to make of it. Now? It's the crown jewel.
But here is where it gets tricky. Not all #401 cards are the same. If you have the standard version, a PSA 10 (Gem Mint) might fetch you around $4,000 in today's market. However, if you're lucky enough to own the "Tiffany" version, you're looking at a different tax bracket.
What on earth is a Topps Tiffany?
Basically, Topps released limited-edition factory sets from 1984 to 1991. They called them Tiffany sets. They looked identical to the regular cards but had a high-gloss finish and white cardstock on the back instead of the muddy gray/brown stuff.
The 1985 Topps Tiffany #401 is incredibly rare. There are only about 35 known PSA 10 copies in existence. One recently sold for over $30,000. That’s a lot of money for a piece of cardboard from the "junk wax" era.
✨ Don't miss: Justin Boone Trade Chart: What Most Fantasy Managers Get Wrong
Why 1987 is the Year of the "True" Rookie
While the '85 is the first, many purists argue that the 1987 Mark McGwire cards are his "true" rookies because that’s when he actually started playing for the Athletics. This was the year he hit 49 home runs and shattered the rookie record. Everyone wanted a piece of him.
Because of that, 1987 cards were printed by the millions.
- 1987 Topps #366: The wood-grain classic. It’s everywhere. You can find them for five bucks at a flea market. But if it's a PSA 10? You’re looking at $150 to $200.
- 1987 Donruss #46: This is the "Rated Rookie" version with the yellow and black borders. It's notorious for having tiny white chips on the edges, making a perfect 10 very hard to find.
- 1987 Fleer #629: Often overlooked, but still a staple for any Big Mac collector.
Then there’s the 1987 Leaf #46. This was the Canadian version of Donruss. It’s much harder to find than the US version. If you find one in a high grade, the price jumps significantly compared to the standard Donruss.
Spotting the Fakes and the "Trash" Errors
If you spend five minutes on eBay searching for a mark mcgwire rookie card, you'll see listings for "RARE ERROR" cards priced at $10,000.
Don't buy them.
Usually, these are just printing defects. A "fish eye" (a little white circle in the ink) or a slight color smudge isn't an error that adds value. It’s just a bad print job. During the late eighties, quality control was basically non-existent.
Also, watch out for "reprints." In the early 2000s, Topps did a bunch of anniversary reprints of the 1985 USA card. They look almost identical to the original, but if you look at the back, it’ll usually have a different year or a "Topps Archives" logo. They’re worth a few dollars, nothing more.
👉 See also: What Really Happened With Josh Maravich: The Loss of a Legacy
The 2026 Market: Is He Still an Investment?
It’s been decades since the "Summer of 68" and the steroid scandals that followed. For a long time, McGwire’s card prices were in the basement. People felt betrayed.
But something shifted recently. Collectors who grew up idolizing him are now in their 40s and 50s with disposable income. They don't care as much about the controversy; they care about the nostalgia.
The prices for high-grade mark mcgwire rookie cards have been climbing steadily. It’s no longer just about the home run chase; it’s about owning a piece of 80s history.
Actionable Tips for Collectors
- Check the cardstock. Flip your 1985 Topps over. Is the back bright white or dull gray? If it’s white and glossy on the front, you might have a Tiffany. Get it graded immediately.
- Focus on Centering. 1980s cards were famously cut crooked. A card can be perfectly clean, but if the image is shifted too far to one side, it won’t get a 10.
- Buy Graded. Unless you really know what you’re doing, don't buy "Raw" (ungraded) cards of the #401 on eBay. There are too many trims and fakes out there. Stick with PSA, SGC, or BGS.
- Ignore the "Junk" Errors. If a seller is claiming a card is worth thousands because of a "black dot on the border," they are trying to hustle you.
The mark mcgwire rookie card market is finally maturing. Whether you're hunting for the 1985 Olympic rarity or just want a crisp 1987 Topps to put on your desk, the key is condition and authenticity. Just because there are millions of them doesn't mean the perfect ones aren't special.
If you’re sitting on a collection, take a close look at that 1985 USA card. Use a magnifying glass. Check those corners. You might just be holding the best-performing asset in your house.
Next Steps for You: First, locate any 1985 Topps #401 cards you own and check the back color against a standard 1985 Topps card to see if you have a Tiffany version. If the back is bright white, use a high-resolution scanner or a jeweler's loupe to inspect the four corners for any fraying or "softness." Once you've confirmed the condition is sharp, compare your card's centering to a PSA 10 image online to determine if it's worth the $25-$50 grading fee. If the card is significantly off-center or has "fish eye" ink defects, it is likely better kept as a personal memento rather than a financial investment.