Mario & Luigi: Paper Jam is a weird game. It’s the kind of project that feels like it shouldn't exist because it forces two distinct art styles and mechanical philosophies into one tiny 3DS cartridge. Honestly, if you played it back in 2015, you probably remember it as the "safe" crossover. AlphaDream, the studio behind the Mario & Luigi series (rest in peace), was at a crossroads. They had this vibrant, wacky RPG engine, and Intelligent Systems had Paper Mario. Putting them together was a no-brainer for Nintendo. Yet, the reception was... mixed.
People were annoyed. Why? Because the game stripped away the unique, bizarre original characters from Superstar Saga or Partners in Time and replaced them with generic Toads. Tons of Toads. Everywhere. But looking back at it now, especially with the 3DS era firmly in the rearview mirror, Mario & Luigi: Paper Jam is actually a technical marvel of turn-based combat. It’s arguably the most "gameplay-first" entry in the entire series.
📖 Related: Dragon's Dogma 2 Gameplay: Why This Game Actually Hates You (In a Good Way)
The Collision of Two Worlds
The premise is basically a library accident. Luigi, being Luigi, knocks over a book in Peach's Castle, and the entire Paper Mario universe spills out into the 3D world. It’s a meta-narrative that allows for some genuinely funny writing. Seeing two Bowsers argue about who is more "imposing" or watching the two Peaches bond over their shared hobby of being kidnapped is charming. It doesn't try to be deep. It just tries to be funny.
The Trio Combat System
This is where the game shines. Forget the story for a second. The combat in Mario & Luigi: Paper Jam is dense. You aren't just managing Mario and Luigi; you’re managing Paper Mario as a third, distinct entity. He doesn't play like the brothers. He can make copies of himself, allowing him to dodge attacks by literally stacking his "lives" or fluttering in the air while the 3D brothers jump.
- Trio Attacks: These are elaborate, rhythmic mini-games where all three characters turn the enemies into paper-thin targets.
- Battle Cards: This was a massive departure from Dream Team. Instead of Badges, you use a deck-building system. It adds a layer of strategy that keeps the late-game from feeling like a repetitive grind.
- Dash Mechanics: Exploring the world feels faster here than in any other Mario RPG because of the dash button and the "Paper Mario plane" abilities.
Why the "Toad Problem" Happened
If you talk to any hardcore Mario RPG fan, they’ll bring up the "Toad Problem." There are no weird bean-people or star-spirits. It’s just generic Mushroom Kingdom NPCs. This wasn't just a random choice by AlphaDream. During this era of Nintendo’s history, there were strict internal mandates regarding how Mario characters could be modified. Kensuke Tanabe, a longtime producer at Nintendo, famously mentioned in interviews around the release of Paper Mario: Sticker Star that the developers were encouraged to stick to the "established" Mario cast as much as possible.
✨ Don't miss: Finding Working Parkour Jumping Race Codes That Actually Work
Mario & Luigi: Paper Jam suffered the brunt of this policy. It’s the biggest criticism leveled against the game. It feels "vanilla." But if you can get past the lack of visual variety in the NPCs, the mechanical variety is staggering. The boss fights are some of the most complex in the franchise. They require genuine timing and pattern recognition. You can't just mash the A button and expect to win.
The Paper Craft Battles: Love Them or Hate Them?
Instead of the Giant Battles from Dream Team or Bowser’s Inside Story, we got Paper Craft battles. These are massive, cardboard-based skirmishes. You’re basically piloting a giant Mario statue on a platform carried by Toads. It’s essentially a rhythm-based tank game.
Some people hated these. They felt slow compared to the snappy turn-based combat. Honestly? They’re a fun diversion. They break up the pace. Are they the highlight of the game? No. But they show a level of experimental spirit that AlphaDream was known for. They were always trying to find ways to use the 3DS hardware in ways that felt tactile. Shaking the 3DS or tapping the screen—it’s all very "of its time."
👉 See also: Batman Arkham Harley Quinn: What Most People Get Wrong
Is It Still Worth Playing?
Absolutely. If you have a 3DS lying around or you're browsing the secondary market, Mario & Luigi: Paper Jam is a must-play for RPG fans. It’s polished to a mirror shine. The animations are fluid. The music by Yoko Shimomura—the legend behind Kingdom Hearts—is spectacular as always. She manages to blend the bouncy, jazzy themes of the Mario & Luigi series with the more acoustic, whimsical vibes of Paper Mario perfectly.
It’s also surprisingly long. You’re looking at about 30 to 35 hours for a standard playthrough. If you want to finish all the Battle Medals and Paper Toad missions (which, admittedly, can get a bit tedious), you’re looking at 50+ hours.
Technical Performance
Unlike some later 3DS titles that struggled with frame rates (looking at you, Pokémon Sun and Moon), Mario & Luigi: Paper Jam runs like a dream. The 3D effect is actually useful here too. It helps you judge the distance of incoming projectiles during those 3D-perspective dodge sequences. It’s one of the few games where I’d actually recommend keeping the 3D slider turned up.
Final Practical Insights for New Players
If you’re picking this up for the first time, don't sleep on the Battle Cards. It’s easy to forget they exist and just rely on your hammer and jump, but the cards are what make the "Hard Mode" challenges possible. Specifically, look for cards that increase your "Star Points" gain early in the battle.
Also, pay attention to the Paper Toad rescue missions. Yes, there are many of them. Yes, some are annoying hide-and-seek games. But they unlock the Trio moves that you absolutely need for the final dungeon. Don't leave them all for the end of the game or you'll burn out.
Mario & Luigi: Paper Jam might not have the soul of Superstar Saga, but it has the brain of a masterclass RPG. It’s a mechanical peak for a developer that we unfortunately lost too soon. It’s a game about the joy of pressing buttons at the right time, and in that specific category, it’s nearly perfect.
Actionable Next Steps:
- Check your 3DS battery; those old lithium-ion packs can swell if left uncharged for years.
- If you find the Paper Toad missions repetitive, play them in short bursts between major story beats to avoid "Toad fatigue."
- Focus your equipment builds on "Speed" for Mario and "Power" for Luigi to maximize their traditional roles, while using Paper Mario as your utility/multi-hit specialist.