If you’ve watched the glossy, high-drama world of The Tudors on Showtime, you probably remember Margaret Tudor as the rebellious sister who marries an old king of Portugal, smothers him with a pillow, and runs off with a handsome rogue. It’s great TV. It’s also mostly fake.
The real Margaret Tudor didn't go to Portugal. She went North. She was the Queen of Scots, the grandmother of Mary, Queen of Scots, and the woman who basically ensured the Stuart line would eventually sit on the English throne. People focus so much on Henry VIII’s six wives that they forget his sisters were playing the same high-stakes game of thrones, just with fewer executions and way more freezing Scottish rain.
Margaret was the eldest daughter of Henry VII and Elizabeth of York. She was the bridge between two warring nations. She was also, quite frankly, a bit of a chaotic mess when it came to her personal life—which makes her perfect for a deep dive.
The Portugal Lie in The Tudors
Let's address the elephant in the room. In the series The Tudors, Margaret (played by Gabrielle Anwar) is a composite character. The writers basically mashed Henry’s two sisters, Margaret and Mary, into one person.
They took Margaret’s name but gave her Mary’s story. It was the younger sister, Mary Tudor, who was forced to marry the aging King Louis XII of France (not Portugal) and then secretly married Charles Brandon after the King died of "exhaustion" in the bedroom.
The real Margaret Tudor? Her life was arguably more stressful. At just thirteen years old, she was sent away to marry James IV of Scotland. Imagine being a teenager, leaving the comforts of the English court, and being told your entire job is to stop two countries from killing each other.
A Teenager in the Scottish Court
Margaret’s arrival in Scotland in 1503 was a massive deal. It was the "Marriage of the Thistle and the Rose." James IV was older, experienced, and apparently quite charming, but Scotland was a different beast than England. The lords were fractious. The landscape was rugged.
✨ Don't miss: Death Wish II: Why This Sleazy Sequel Still Triggers People Today
She wasn't just a trophy wife. Margaret had to navigate a court where she was always seen as "the Englishwoman." When her father died and her brother Henry VIII took the throne, things got awkward. Henry was aggressive. James IV was proud.
Then came 1513. The Battle of Flodden.
This is the moment Margaret’s life flipped upside down. Her husband, James IV, was killed by her brother’s army. Think about that for a second. Her brother's troops killed her husband, and she was left as the widowed Queen of a country that now hated England more than ever. She was also pregnant.
Power, Regents, and Bad Decisions
After Flodden, Margaret was the Regent of Scotland for her infant son, James V. She was the most powerful woman in the country, but she was vulnerable. She needed an ally.
She chose Archibald Douglas, the 6th Earl of Angus.
It was a disaster.
🔗 Read more: Dark Reign Fantastic Four: Why This Weirdly Political Comic Still Holds Up
By marrying Angus, she lost the regency. The Scottish nobles didn't want a Douglas running the show through the Queen. She lost her kids for a while. She had to flee to England, pregnant and miserable, only to find that Henry VIII wasn't exactly the "protective big brother" she hoped for. Henry was a narcissist. He viewed his sisters as political assets, not human beings.
The Divorce That Preceded Henry's
Everyone talks about Henry VIII’s Great Matter—his quest to divorce Catherine of Aragon. But Margaret Tudor was actually ahead of the curve. She grew to loathe Angus. He was unfaithful, he spent her money, and he was generally a piece of work.
Margaret spent years lobbying the Pope for an annulment. She eventually got it in 1527, which is hilarious when you consider Henry was struggling to get his own at the same time. Henry actually had the nerve to lecture her on the "sin" of leaving her husband. Talk about hypocrisy.
She married a third time, to Henry Stewart, Lord Methven. It didn't get much better. Methven was just as bad as Angus. Margaret eventually realized that maybe she was better off without the drama, but in the 16th century, a woman's power was tied to the men she could influence.
Why Margaret Tudor Matters for History Buffs
If you're a fan of The Tudors or The Spanish Princess, you need to look past the costumes and see the political reality. Margaret Tudor is the reason the "Union of the Crowns" happened in 1603.
When Elizabeth I died without an heir, it was Margaret’s great-grandson, James VI of Scotland, who became James I of England. Without Margaret’s endurance in the Scottish court, the map of the UK would look very different today.
💡 You might also like: Cuatro estaciones en la Habana: Why this Noir Masterpiece is Still the Best Way to See Cuba
She wasn't a saint. She was impulsive. She changed sides between the pro-French and pro-English factions more often than people changed their tunics. But she survived. In an era where being a royal woman often meant being a silent victim or a headless one, Margaret fought.
Real Insights for Researching Margaret
If you're looking to get into the nitty-gritty of her life, stop relying on the TV shows. They prioritize "vibe" over "veracity."
- Primary Sources: Look for the State Papers, Scotland. You can find her letters to Henry VIII and Cardinal Wolsey. They are full of sass, desperation, and sharp political maneuvering.
- The Douglas Conflict: Research the "Clan Douglas" to understand why her second marriage was such a political landmine. It wasn't just a romance; it was a civil war waiting to happen.
- The Margaret vs. Mary Distinction: Always double-check which sister you're reading about. If she's in France, it's Mary. If she's in the Highlands, it's Margaret.
Practical Steps for Historical Deep Dives
- Check the Calendar: Cross-reference Margaret’s letters with the dates of Henry VIII’s marriages. It’s fascinating to see how her struggles in Scotland mirrored his in England.
- Visit the Sites: If you’re ever in Scotland, go to Linlithgow Palace or Stirling Castle. You can feel the cold stone and realize just how isolated she must have felt as an English princess in the North.
- Read Professional Biographies: Skip the historical fiction for a moment. Pick up Margaret Tudor: Queen of Scots by P.C. Buchanan or Maria Perry’s work. They give you the actual political context without the "pillow smothering" fiction.
Margaret Tudor’s life was a masterclass in survival. She wasn't the "other" sister; she was the foundation of a dynasty. While Henry was busy rewriting the church, Margaret was busy keeping the Stuart line alive under much harder conditions. She deserves more than a composite character in a TV show. She was a Queen in her own right, navigating a world that wanted her to be nothing more than a bridge.
Instead, she became the architect of the future.
Next Steps for the History Enthusiast:
To truly understand the Tudor impact on Scotland, look into the "Rough Wooing" period that followed Margaret's death. It illustrates the brutal reality of the Anglo-Scottish relations she spent her life trying to manage. Compare the diplomatic styles of Margaret Tudor and her brother to see how gender roles dictated their survival strategies in the early 16th century.