You’re walking across a metal grate in the Labyrinth. The air is thick, like breathing through a damp wool blanket. Then you hear it. A metallic skittering below your boots. A wet, labored rasp. Honestly, the first time most players run into a Mandarin Silent Hill 2 creature, they don’t even see it. They just see these giant, suction-cup-looking hands gripping the bars from below.
It’s one of the weirdest designs in a game full of nightmare fuel.
Most people think they’re just environmental hazards. Obstacles meant to keep you moving so you don't get your ankles shredded. But there is a lot more going on with these things than just "monster under the floor." Especially with how the 2024 remake changed the rules of the game.
Why the Mandarin Silent Hill 2 Monster Is Stuck Under Your Feet
The lore behind these guys is depressing. Typical Silent Hill, right? According to Masahiro Ito, the legendary creature designer behind the series, the Mandarin Silent Hill 2 monster represents "overwhelming, incomprehensible anguish."
Think about that for a second.
They aren't allowed to stand on the ground. They are literally forbidden from walking in the same space as James. They have to live in the dark, hanging by their arms because their grief is so heavy they can’t even support their own weight. In the original 2001 game, they were mostly a nuisance. You’d run over a grate, get poked by a stinger, and keep going.
But in the remake? Bloober Team turned them into a genuine threat.
👉 See also: Why Steel Type Pokemon Still Dominate the Meta (and What Are Steel Type Pokemon Weak Against Anyway?)
They still have those weird, tubular arms. They still have the "lips" that look suspiciously like Mary’s (a nod to the verbal abuse James endured during her illness). But now, they’re faster. They’re smarter. And they have a scream that will literally stun James in his tracks.
The Francis Bacon Connection
If you look at a Mandarin and think it looks like a piece of distorted fine art, you’re actually right. Ito has confirmed that the mouths on the Mandarin and the Flesh Lip boss were inspired by Francis Bacon’s Second Version of Triptych 1944.
It’s that raw, screaming energy.
The Mandarin is essentially a "lesser" version of the Flesh Lip. While Flesh Lip is caged in the hospital—symbolizing Mary confined to her sickbed—the Mandarin is the version of that pain that has leaked out into the rest of the world. It’s the background noise of James’s guilt.
How to Actually Kill Them (Because Yes, You Can)
For years, fans debated if you could even kill a Mandarin in the original game. You could, but it was a waste of bullets. In the remake, it’s a different story. You kind of have to deal with them in certain sections if you don’t want to burn through your health drinks.
Here is the thing: don't waste your handgun ammo.
Mandarins are surprisingly tanky if you just aim at their bodies. The trick is to go for the hands. If you shoot or smack the "suction cups" holding onto the grates, they’ll turn bright red. Hit one until it lets go, then quickly hit the other.
🔗 Read more: Elden Ring Brother Corhyn Questline: Why Most Players Mess This Up
Once both hands lose their grip, the Mandarin falls into the abyss.
Done.
Pro-tip for the Labyrinth: If you’re playing on Standard or Hard, the Mandarins in the Labyrinth feel way more aggressive. Use the lead pipe. I know it sounds risky to get that close, but James’s auto-aim for the pipe is actually pretty decent at hitting the floor grates. Just watch for the tell-tale "hiss" before they strike. That’s your cue to dodge.
The "Free" Mandarin Boss Fight
One of the biggest surprises in the Silent Hill 2 remake is the encounter in the Lakeview Hotel. In the original, Mandarins were always under the floor. Always. But in the remake's Otherworld hotel section, one actually breaks free.
It’s terrifying.
Seeing a creature that was "forbidden" from standing on the ground suddenly crawling across the ceiling and jumping at you changes the vibe completely. It’s no longer a metaphor for hidden anguish; it’s an active, screaming mental breakdown.
To beat this boss version, you need to stay mobile.
- The Roar: It’ll scream to stun you. If you get caught, mash the break-out button fast.
- The Tongue Lash: It has a ridiculous reach. Stay behind it as much as possible.
- The Ceiling Drop: When it tucks its legs in, it’s about to slam down. Dodge sideways, not backwards.
Honestly, the rifle is your best friend here. Two or three well-placed shots to its fleshy bits will bring it down much faster than trying to kite it with the handgun.
The Legacy of the Under-Floor Creep
You might notice that the Mandarin looks a lot like the "Closer" from Silent Hill 3. That’s not a coincidence. While the symbolism shifted to fit Heather’s story in the third game, the physical design—those massive, club-like arms—started right here with the Mandarin.
It’s a design that works because it hits on a primal fear.
The idea that something is right beneath you. That you’re walking on a "safe" path, but there’s a world of monsters just inches from your soles.
👉 See also: League of Legends Canada: Why Our Pro Scene Is Way Different Than You Think
If you're struggling with the Mandarin Silent Hill 2 encounters, stop trying to run past them every time. The stun-lock from their roar is designed to catch "runners." Instead, take a second to aim down. Aim for the hands. It’s much more satisfying to watch them drop into the dark than it is to get poked in the leg for the tenth time.
Next time you hear that metallic scraping, don't panic. Just look down, keep your pipe ready, and remember that these things are just as miserable as James is.
Actionable Insights for Players
- Listen for the Hiss: The audio cue is more reliable than your eyes in the dark Labyrinth.
- Focus the Hands: Damaging the arms specifically is the only way to reliably "kill" them by making them fall.
- Use the Flashlight: In the remake, your flashlight beam helps highlight their grip points, making it easier to land shots.
- Don't Run Blind: Running triggers their roar-stun more frequently than walking or standing your ground.