Football is a cruel game. One minute you're the hero of the Stretford End, and the next, you're walking off the pitch in a rain-soaked Manchester evening wondering where it all went wrong. Honestly, being named the Manchester United man of the match today—or rather, from this past weekend’s gut-wrenching FA Cup exit—feels like a bit of a hollow victory.
United just crashed out of the FA Cup third round. A 2-1 defeat to Brighton at Old Trafford. It’s the kind of result that leaves a bitter taste, especially when you realize the club has hit a 111-year low by exiting both domestic cups at the first hurdle. While the "Official" Man of the Match usually goes to a winning player—with Brighton’s Brajan Gruda taking the honors for most broadcasters after his opening goal and assist—United fans are left picking through the wreckage to find a silver lining.
The Standout Performer in a Dark Week
If we’re looking at who truly showed up for the Red Devils, you have to talk about Bruno Fernandes.
It’s almost a cliché at this point. When the ship is sinking, Bruno is the one trying to bail out the water with a teaspoon. In the Brighton match, he was everywhere. He finished the game having completed more passes than anyone else on the pitch. He created four clear-cut chances. He even grabbed the assist for Benjamin Sesko’s late header that briefly made us think a comeback was on the cards.
👉 See also: Meaning of Grand Slam: Why We Use It for Tennis, Baseball, and Breakfast
But here’s the thing: it wasn't enough.
Why the "Man of the Match" title is controversial right now
- The Captain's Hack: Off the pitch, Bruno’s week was a nightmare. His X account was hacked with messages targeting the INEOS ownership. Imagine trying to lead a team through a tactical transition while your social media is being used to start a civil war with the board.
- The Interim Era: Darren Fletcher is currently steering the ship as interim boss, and let's be real, the tactics are a bit of a mess. Switching between a back three and a back four has left the players looking dizzy.
- The Youth Spark: Some fans would argue 18-year-old Shea Lacey was the real man of the match today in terms of "vibes." He came on and looked fearless. He was the architect of United’s best second-half spells before that late red card ruined his afternoon.
Benjamin Sesko: The Only One Scoring?
You've got to feel for Benjamin Sesko. The guy is essentially a penalty-area ghost—he barely touches the ball (only 19 times against Brighton), but when he does, it usually ends up in the net. He’s now scored three goals in his last two games. In any other era, a striker with that strike rate would be the undisputed Manchester United man of the match today.
Instead, he’s scoring "consolation goals." That's a term no United striker wants to be associated with.
✨ Don't miss: NFL Week 5 2025 Point Spreads: What Most People Get Wrong
The Defensive Dilemma
Then there’s Patrick Dorgu. On Boxing Day against Newcastle, he was the undisputed hero. A wonder volley, a clean sheet, and a performance that had everyone saying he was the bargain of the century. Fast forward to the Brighton game, and he’s caught ball-watching for Gruda’s opener.
It’s this lack of consistency that is killing the team. You can’t be a 9/10 one week and a 5/10 the next. Not at this level.
What Really Happened With the Ratings?
Looking at the data from the recent matches, the "Man of the Match" award has been a revolving door of frustration.
🔗 Read more: Bethany Hamilton and the Shark: What Really Happened That Morning
Bruno Fernandes (8.2 rating): Statistically the best player on the pitch for United against Brighton. He led in progressive passes and shot-creating actions.
Benjamin Sesko (7.5 rating): Clinical but isolated. He did his job, but the service was sporadic at best.
Kobbie Mainoo (6.9 rating): A welcome return from injury. He showed flashes of the composure United has been missing in the middle of the park, but he clearly isn't at 100% fitness yet.
The reality is that while individuals are putting up decent numbers, the collective unit is fractured. When people search for the Manchester United man of the match today, they are often looking for a hero to cling to. But today, the heroics felt small compared to the scale of the defeat.
Where Does United Go From Here?
With Michael Carrick reportedly reaching an agreement to take over the interim role, the "Man of the Match" conversation is about to change again. Carrick knows this midfield better than anyone. He’ll likely demand more ball retention and less of the "chaos-ball" we saw under Fletcher's brief stint.
The next few weeks are brutal. The Manchester Derby is looming on January 17th. Then it's Arsenal away. If someone wants to be the man of the match in those games, they aren't just going to need a high pass completion rate—they’re going to need a pair of steel lungs and some serious mental fortitude.
Actionable Insights for Fans:
Keep a close eye on the team sheet for the Manchester City game. If Carrick is in the dugout, expect a shift back to a more stable 4-3-3. Watch the "Distance Covered" stats for Manuel Ugarte; if he isn't covering the ground, the defense will be exposed regardless of who the Man of the Match is. Also, keep track of Shea Lacey’s suspension—United desperately need his creativity back on the wing as soon as he's eligible.