Manchester City vs. Liverpool: What Most People Get Wrong

Manchester City vs. Liverpool: What Most People Get Wrong

You know the feeling when a match is so big it basically stops the world for two hours? That’s what we’re dealing with here.

Manchester City vs. Liverpool isn't just a game. It's become the definitive tactical chess match of our generation. Honestly, if you aren't watching these two go at it, are you even a fan of the sport?

People love to talk about the "traditional" rivalries—United vs. Liverpool, the North London Derby—but those are often fueled by history and old-school bitterness. This one? This is about the sheer, terrifying quality of football. It’s about two machines built to destroy everything in their path, finally meeting in the middle of the pitch.

The Recent Reality Check

Let’s talk about the most recent earthquake in this rivalry. On November 9, 2025, Manchester City absolutely dismantled Liverpool 3-0 at the Etihad. It was a statement. Huge.

It was also Pep Guardiola’s 1,000th game as a manager. Talk about a way to celebrate. Erling Haaland did what Erling Haaland does (scored in the 29th minute), but the real story was Jeremy Doku. He was unplayable. He terrorized Conor Bradley all afternoon and capped it off with a goal in the 63rd minute. Nico Gonzalez got the other one right before halftime.

Liverpool looked... well, sluggish. Sluggish and a bit lost.

The interesting thing is that just a few months earlier, in February 2025, Liverpool had walked into that same stadium and won 2-0. Mohamed Salah and Dominik Szoboszlai were the heroes that day. That win basically handed Liverpool their 20th league title under Arne Slot.

The pendulum swings so fast in this fixture you’ll get whiplash just trying to keep up.

The Slot vs. Pep Dynamic

Klopp is gone. We’ve had to accept it. But if you thought the tactical intensity would drop once Arne Slot took over at Anfield, you’ve clearly been watching a different sport.

📖 Related: Bethany Hamilton and the Shark: What Really Happened That Morning

Slot isn't Klopp. He's less "heavy metal" and a bit more "composed orchestra." He values control. He wants the ball. Under Slot, Liverpool has moved away from that chaotic, 100mph transition game into something more calculated.

  • Pep’s Positional Dominance: Guardiola is still the king of "death by a thousand passes." He uses inverted full-backs and hybrid midfielders to create overloads that make your head spin.
  • Slot’s Pragmatic Flexibility: Slot has turned Liverpool into a tactical chameleon. They can still press your brains out if they need to, but they're just as comfortable sitting back and baiting the press.

In that 3-0 drubbing in November, Pep actually beat Slot at his own game. City moved the ball slower—only 0.84 meters per second—which is the slowest they’ve ever been under Pep. Why? To stop Liverpool from having any transition moments. It was a masterclass in suffocating a rival.

The Numbers That Actually Matter

If we look at the all-time head-to-head, Liverpool still leads. As of late 2025, the Reds have 110 wins compared to City’s 61, with 58 draws. But that’s historical fluff.

The modern era is where it gets spicy. Since the 2017-18 season, these two have basically traded trophies like Pokémon cards. One of them has won every single Premier League title in that span except for the occasional Arsenal challenge.

Look at the 2021-22 season. City won the league by a single point. 93 to 92. Imagine playing 38 games, winning nearly all of them, and losing by a single point. It’s cruel. It’s also why this rivalry matters so much. There is no margin for error. Zero.

Why the "Home Advantage" is Weird

If you’re betting on Manchester City vs. Liverpool, you usually look at the stadium.

Anfield is a fortress. City has only won there once in their last 22 Premier League visits. And get this: that one win was in 2021 when the stadium was empty because of the pandemic. No fans, no "Anfield Effect."

Conversely, the Etihad has become a bit of a graveyard for Liverpool lately. Before that 2-0 win in February 2025, Liverpool had some truly miserable trips to Manchester, including a 4-1 thumping in 2023.

👉 See also: Simona Halep and the Reality of Tennis Player Breast Reduction

The Injury Factor (The 2026 Landscape)

Right now, as we head deeper into the 2025-26 season, both squads are feeling the burn.

Liverpool has been dealing with some massive holes. Alexander Isak (who joined the Reds in a blockbuster move) has been battling a broken leg. Mohamed Salah is often away for international duty or dealing with minor knocks, and the absence of Alisson Becker in goal during key stretches has been glaring. Giorgi Mamardashvili has stepped in, and he’s good—really good—but he’s not Alisson. Not yet.

City hasn't been immune either. Rodri—the man who makes City tick—has missed significant time. When Rodri doesn't play, City looks human. They look beatable. They also lost Josko Gvardiol and Ruben Dias to various muscle injuries recently.

It’s a war of attrition. Whoever has the healthier physio room usually wins the trophy.

What Most People Get Wrong

The biggest misconception? That this rivalry is "manufactured" by the media.

"Oh, it's not a real derby," people say. Tell that to the players. Watch the highlights of the March 2024 draw at Anfield. Alexis Mac Allister gets leveled by a Jeremy Doku high boot in the final seconds. No penalty given. The tension was so thick you could have carved it with a dull knife.

The rivalry is real because the stakes are the highest they can possibly be. It’s not about geography; it’s about the soul of English football.

Actionable Insights for Fans

If you're following this rivalry or looking to understand the next matchup, here is what you actually need to watch for:

✨ Don't miss: NFL Pick 'em Predictions: Why You're Probably Overthinking the Divisional Round

1. The "Rodri" Metric
Before the game starts, check the lineup. If Rodri is missing for City, Liverpool’s midfield (usually Gravenberch and Mac Allister) will dominate the central zone. If he's in, City controls the rhythm. It's that simple.

2. Watch the Full-Backs
The battle between Doku and Liverpool’s right-back (often Conor Bradley or a returning Trent) determines the game. If Doku is isolated 1-on-1, Liverpool is in trouble. Slot has tried to use double-coverage, but that leaves Foden or Savinho open on the other side.

3. The 70-Minute Mark
These games are exhausting. Usually, the first 60 minutes are a tactical stalemate. The game opens up in the final 20. Look for Slot to bring on impact subs like Federico Chiesa or Cody Gakpo to exploit a tiring City defense.

4. Check the "Anfield Factor"
If the game is at Anfield, ignore the form table. Liverpool could be on a 5-game losing streak and they’d still likely find a way to get a result against City. The crowd genuinely changes the way the referees and the City players react to pressure.

The next time Manchester City vs. Liverpool pops up on the calendar, don't just look at the table. Look at the benches, look at the recent injury reports from the AXA Training Centre, and look at the tactical tweaks Pep has made in the weeks leading up.

This is the highest level of football on the planet. Enjoy it while we still have these two geniuses on the touchline.

To stay ahead of the next fixture, track the individual xG (Expected Goals) of Erling Haaland and Mohamed Salah over their last three matches, as this has historically been the most accurate predictor of which side will break the deadlock in their head-to-head encounters. Additionally, monitor the fitness of the "number 6" role for both teams 48 hours before kickoff, as this position remains the single most influential factor in determining who wins the transition battle.