You probably didn't have "Antoine Semenyo dominates the headlines" on your 2026 bingo card a few months back. Yet here we are. After Manchester City’s clinical 2-0 dismantling of Newcastle United at St. James’ Park in the Carabao Cup semi-final first leg, there is only one name on every City fan's lips. Honestly, the way he’s settled in after that £62.5 million move from Bournemouth is kind of ridiculous.
Most people expected a bedding-in period. You know the drill: Pep Guardiola benches the new guy for six months while he learns where to stand during a throw-in. Not this time. Semenyo has basically kicked the door down. By scoring in his first two games—first in that 10-1 demolition of Exeter and now the crucial opener against Newcastle—he’s become the first City player to do that since Emmanuel Adebayor back in 2009. That’s a wild stat when you think about the world-class talent that has passed through the Etihad in the last 17 years.
The Man City Man of the Match Today: A Performance of Pure Efficiency
The man city man of the match today wasn't Erling Haaland, who actually had a bit of a stinker by his standards. It wasn't even Rodri, who usually runs the show with his eyes closed. It was Semenyo. While the first half of the match was, frankly, a bit of a slog—both teams barely scraped together 0.15 xG—the second half belonged to the Ghanaian international.
He didn’t need fifty touches to make an impact. He just needed to be in the right place. In the 53rd minute, Jeremy Doku (who was terrifying the Newcastle full-backs all night) whipped in a cross that Bernardo Silva flicked on. Semenyo was just there. Tapping it in at the back post looked easy, but the movement to get away from his marker was top-tier.
👉 See also: Meaning of Grand Slam: Why We Use It for Tennis, Baseball, and Breakfast
Why the Stats Don't Tell the Whole Story
If you just look at the box score, you see one goal. But Semenyo actually had the ball in the net twice. The second one was a piece of pure filth—a backheel from a corner that caught everyone off guard. It was ruled out after a VAR check that felt like it took three years. The officials eventually decided Haaland was offside and "impeding" the keeper. It was a "subjective offside," which is basically football-speak for "we aren't really sure, but we're saying no."
Despite that, the energy Semenyo brought to the left wing changed the entire gravity of the game. He chased everything. He tracked back. He made life miserable for Kieran Trippier.
James Trafford and the Defensive Masterclass
While Semenyo took the official plaudits, we have to talk about James Trafford. The kid was a wall. Newcastle actually had their chances—Yoane Wissa should have probably scored in the first five minutes, and Trafford made one save from a looping header that was honestly world-class.
✨ Don't miss: NFL Week 5 2025 Point Spreads: What Most People Get Wrong
It’s a weird time for the City defense. With John Stones, Ruben Dias, and Josko Gvardiol all sidelined with various injuries, Pep is basically duct-taping the backline together. Seeing youngsters like Max Alleyne and Abdukodir Khusanov holding it down at St. James' Park is impressive. Khusanov had one shaky moment early on where he lunged in and missed, but he recovered well.
The match ended with Rayan Cherki—another new face making waves—sliding home a second goal deep in injury time. It was the perfect "sucker punch" to a Newcastle side that had grown desperate.
What This Means for the Manchester Derby
The timing of this performance couldn't be better. City are heading into a massive Manchester derby against a United side now led by Michael Carrick. With Nico Gonzalez a doubt after taking an "incredible knock" against Brighton, Semenyo’s form is a massive safety net for Pep.
🔗 Read more: Bethany Hamilton and the Shark: What Really Happened That Morning
The "Semenyo effect" is real. He isn't just a backup; he's starting to look like a focal point. He brings a directness that City sometimes lacks when they get too caught up in "death by a thousand passes."
Actionable Insights for City Fans
If you're tracking the man city man of the match today to see who to watch in the coming weeks, keep these points in mind:
- Watch the Left Flank: Semenyo is developing a scary understanding with Jeremy Doku. They swap wings frequently, making it impossible for defenders to settle.
- The Haaland Factor: Ironically, Semenyo’s arrival has given Haaland more space, even if the Norwegian isn't scoring at his usual rate right now. Defenders are terrified of Semenyo’s pace, which pulls them out of the center.
- Trafford is the Real Deal: If you were worried about the goalkeeping depth, don't be. Trafford's distribution and shot-stopping are currently keeping City in the title race while the senior defenders heal up.
Next up is Old Trafford. If Semenyo scores there, he won't just be the man of the match—he'll be a certified club legend before February.