Ever watch a show that feels like a warm hug from a person who just spent three hours in a woodshop? That’s basically the vibe of Making It, the NBC competition series that brought Amy Poehler and Nick Offerman back together. If you’re like me, you probably expected a Parks and Recreation reunion disguised as a reality show. And yeah, the pun-heavy banter is definitely there. But there’s something deeper happening.
Making it Amy Poehler style isn't about the cutthroat drama of Survivor or the high-stakes intensity of Project Runway. It’s a "gentle competition." That’s Amy’s own term for it. Honestly, it’s a breath of fresh air in a TV landscape that usually thrives on people crying in confessionals or throwing wine at each other.
In this show, the makers—a mix of woodworkers, paper artists, and multi-media creators—actually help each other. They share tools. They give advice. It’s almost weirdly wholesome. But behind the glue guns and the googly eyes, the show actually shifted how a lot of us look at creativity and the "maker movement" in general.
The Secret Sauce of Making It Amy Poehler
The show debuted in 2018, produced by Amy’s company, Paper Kite Productions. It survived three seasons, and while NBC shelved it indefinitely in 2022, its DNA lives on in the spin-off Baking It. But why does it still matter in 2026?
Because it validated the "hobbyist."
✨ Don't miss: Priyanka Chopra Latest Movies: Why Her 2026 Slate Is Riskier Than You Think
Amy Poehler often calls herself a "crafting novice." She’s the proxy for the audience. While Nick Offerman is a legit master woodworker who runs his own professional shop in LA, Amy represents everyone who has ever tried to follow a Pinterest tutorial and failed miserably. That dynamic is key. It removes the barrier to entry for the viewer. You don't have to be a pro to care about the "Faster Craft" or the "Master Craft" challenges.
Who are the judges anyway?
The show didn't just pick random celebrities to judge. They went for actual industry heavyweights.
- Dayna Isom Johnson: She’s the trend expert at Etsy. If something is cool on the internet, she probably knew about it six months ago.
- Simon Doonan: A creative legend from Barneys New York. He brings a high-fashion, window-display sensibility to the barn.
Together, they evaluate the projects based on "Originality," "Craftsmanship," and "Storytelling." That last one is huge. In the world of Making It, a birdhouse isn't just a birdhouse; it's a narrative about your childhood or a tribute to your grandmother.
Why "Gentle" Competition Actually Works
Most reality TV relies on the "villain" edit. You know the one. There's always that one person who says, "I'm not here to make friends." In Making It, everyone is there to make friends.
🔗 Read more: Why This Is How We Roll FGL Is Still The Song That Defines Modern Country
I remember one specific episode where a contestant was struggling with a massive paper installation. Instead of watching the clock and smirking, the other contestants jumped in to help them finish. It sounds like it would be boring TV, but it’s actually incredibly compelling. It taps into a very human desire for community.
Nick and Amy lean into this by leaning into the puns. The wordplay is relentless. "I macramade you, and I can macra-break you." It’s dad-joke energy at its peak. But it serves a purpose: it keeps the environment light so the makers can take genuine creative risks.
The Impact on the Maker Movement
The "maker movement" isn't new. It’s been growing since the mid-2000s, fueled by things like Make: Magazine and the rise of Etsy. But Making It took that subculture and put it on a major network during primetime.
It shifted the conversation from "DIY" (which often implies doing it because it's cheaper) to "Artisanship."
💡 You might also like: The Real Story Behind I Can Do Bad All by Myself: From Stage to Screen
The show highlights people like Jeffrey Rudell, who does things with paper that seem to defy physics, or Robert Mahar, who brings a vintage, whimsical touch to every project. By showcasing these skills, the show gave a lot of people permission to spend time on "useless" hobbies. Except they aren't useless. They’re essential for mental health and self-expression.
Is the show coming back?
As of early 2026, there hasn't been a formal announcement about Season 4 of the original series. NBC moved some of the "Making It" energy over to Peacock with Baking It (hosted by Amy and Maya Rudolph). However, the original episodes are still streaming, and they’ve become a staple for people looking for "comfort TV."
The legacy of the show is seen in the explosion of local makerspaces and the continued success of the "handmade" economy. People want things with a soul. They want objects that tell a story. Amy Poehler realized that early on.
Actionable Takeaways for Your Own Creative Journey
You don't need a TV budget or a barn in California to get into the spirit of the show. If you're feeling a bit stagnant, here is how you can apply the "Master Maker" mindset to your own life:
- Embrace the "Faster Craft": Give yourself a time limit—say, 30 minutes—to make something simple. A card, a sketch, a modified piece of clothing. Don't overthink it. The goal is just to start and finish.
- Find Your "Nick" or "Amy": Creativity is better in pairs. Find a friend who is better than you at a specific skill (your Nick) or someone who just brings the hype and the jokes (your Amy).
- Focus on the Narrative: Next time you make something, ask yourself: what’s the story here? Why this color? Why this material? Adding a personal "why" makes the "how" much more satisfying.
- Value the Process Over the Patch: In the show, winners get a patch. It’s a small, symbolic reward. In real life, the "patch" is the pride of having made something that didn't exist before you sat down at the table.
The beauty of Making It is that it reminds us we are all, at our core, builders. Whether you're working with reclaimed wood or just trying to organize your junk drawer, there's a certain power in saying, "I made this." Amy Poehler and Nick Offerman just gave us a really fun place to watch that happen.