If you drive down Highway 27 and keep heading toward the Atlantic until the air tastes like salt and old money, you’ll eventually hit a patch of grass that looks like it was plucked out of a Scottish postcard and dropped into the middle of the Hamptons. That’s Maidstone. Honestly, calling the Maidstone Golf Club East Hampton a "golf course" is like calling a 1963 Ferrari GTO a "car." It’s technically true, but it misses the entire point of why people lose their minds over it.
It’s private. Like, really private.
While the neighboring Shinnecock Hills or National Golf Links of America get the big-ticket USGA championships, Maidstone has stayed famously reclusive. It’s a place where the membership list is a tighter-kept secret than a CIA dossier. You don’t just pay a fee and walk on. You don't even just "know someone." You have to be part of the fabric of East Hampton's social elite, often for generations.
The Design That Defied the Hamptons
Willie Park Jr. and his brother Jack didn't just build a golf course back in the 1920s; they basically sculpted the dunes. Most American courses from that era tried to look like manicured gardens. Maidstone went the other way. It’s rugged. It’s wind-swept. It’s got that "don't mess with me" vibe that only a true links course can pull off.
The routing is actually pretty weird if you look at a map.
📖 Related: What Does a Stoner Mean? Why the Answer Is Changing in 2026
The West Course—the one everyone talks about—starts inland, wanders toward the ocean, and then hits this incredible stretch from the 8th hole to the 15th where you’re basically playing in the surf. The 9th hole is legendary. It’s a par 4 that requires you to drive over a literal beach. If you hook it, your ball is in the Atlantic. If you slice it, you're in a dune that’s been there since the Ice Age.
Ben Crenshaw and Bill Coore did a massive restoration about a decade ago. They didn't try to make it "modern." Instead, they stripped away the fluff. They brought back the native grasses. They made the bunkers look messy and natural again. It’s a throwback. It’s not about hitting 350-yard drives; it’s about figuring out how to keep your ball from blowing into the next ZIP code when the breeze picks up off the water.
Social Gravity and the Membership Mystery
Let's be real: people search for the Maidstone Golf Club East Hampton because of the status.
It’s often cited as one of the "Big Three" in the area, alongside Shinnecock and National. But Maidstone is different because it’s a beach club too. On a Saturday in July, you’ll see families in the pool and people eating lunch on the veranda in their whites. It’s got a very specific, old-school East Coast aesthetic. Think less "Wall Street swagger" and more "inherited linen shirts."
👉 See also: Am I Gay Buzzfeed Quizzes and the Quest for Identity Online
There was a whole stir years ago—around the late 90s and early 2000s—about the club's lack of diversity. It was a very public, very awkward moment for an institution that prides itself on being invisible. Since then, the club has had to evolve, albeit at a glacial pace. They’ve admitted more diverse members, including high-profile figures like Ken Chenault, the former CEO of American Express.
But don't get it twisted. Even if you're a billionaire, you can't buy your way in. The membership committee at Maidstone looks for "compatibility" over "capital." They want people who fit the culture. Basically, if you’re the type of person who wants to tell everyone you’re a member, you’re probably the type of person they won't let in.
Playing the West Course: A Technical Nightmare (In a Good Way)
If you ever get the invite—and if you do, drop everything and go—be prepared to lose a dozen balls.
The greens aren't just fast; they're deceptive. They follow the natural contours of the land, which means they tilt toward the ocean even when they look flat.
✨ Don't miss: Easy recipes dinner for two: Why you are probably overcomplicating date night
- The 14th Hole: A par 3 that’s basically a target in the sand. It’s short, maybe 150 yards, but the wind can turn a 9-iron into a 5-iron in a heartbeat.
- Hook Pond: This is the giant body of water that guards several holes. It’s beautiful, but it’s a graveyard for golf balls.
- The Grass: It’s fescue. It’s thick. If you miss the fairway, you aren't just hitting out of the rough; you're excavating your ball from a jungle.
Most modern courses are "over-engineered." They have perfect drainage and artificial mounds. Maidstone feels like it was discovered, not built. The 18th hole brings you right back toward the clubhouse, which sits on a hill like a sentinel. It’s one of the most iconic views in sports, even if only a few hundred people ever get to see it in person.
Why It Still Matters in 2026
You might think a 100-year-old golf club would be a relic of the past. It’t not. In an era where everything is digital and everyone is "accessible," Maidstone is a holdout. It’s a physical manifestation of exclusivity.
The land itself is worth an astronomical amount. We’re talking about some of the most expensive real estate on the planet. But the club doesn't care about the real estate market. They care about the turf. They care about the history. They care about the fact that you can stand on the 10th tee and see exactly what the early settlers saw—minus the occasional Gulfstream flying into East Hampton Airport.
How to Actually Experience It
Look, the odds of getting a membership are slim to none. Even the waiting list is a "who’s who" of people who don't like waiting. However, there are ways to see the Maidstone Golf Club East Hampton without being a Vanderbilt.
- The Beach Access: Much of the course borders public or semi-public beach areas. You can't walk onto the greens (don't even try, security is tight), but you can see the oceanfront holes from the sand.
- Charity Events: Occasionally, very rarely, a high-end charity outing might snag a few tee times. These aren't cheap. You’re looking at a five-figure donation, minimum.
- The Guest Route: This is the only real way. You need a member. And no, you can't find one on LinkedIn and ask. It has to be a genuine connection.
Actionable Takeaways for the Golf Obsessed
If you’re planning a trip to the Hamptons and want to soak in the Maidstone vibe, do this:
- Study the architecture: Read "The Evangelist of Golf" by George Bahto. It’s technically about C.B. Macdonald, but it gives you the context for why this specific style of links golf matters in New York.
- Visit Hook Pond: You can drive near the pond and see how the course integrates with the water. It’s a masterclass in environmental design.
- Drive by the Clubhouse: It’s located at 50 Old Beach Lane. Even from the gate, the shingle-style architecture is a masterclass in Hamptons "quiet luxury."
- Play Montauk Downs: Can't get into Maidstone? Go to Montauk Downs State Park. It was designed by Robert Trent Jones Sr. and offers a similarly rugged, wind-blown experience for about $50. It’s the "people’s Maidstone."
Maidstone isn't just a place to hit a ball into a hole. It’s a museum. It’s a fortress. It’s a reminder that even in 2026, some things remain completely untouchable.