When the first season of The Handmaid’s Tale dropped back in 2017, everyone was talking about June Osborne. Rightfully so. But tucked into the corner of the Red Center was a character who would eventually become the show's most devastating, resilient, and surprisingly complex anchor.
Janine Lindo.
Madeline Brewer didn't just play Janine; she inhabited a woman whose spirit was physically and mentally chipped away until only a raw, shimmering core of humanity remained. Now that the series has finally closed its doors with the 2025 finale, looking back at the journey Brewer took with Janine feels less like a TV recap and more like a study in survival. It's kinda wild to think about where she started versus where she ended up.
Madeline Brewer Handmaid's Tale Performance: Beyond the Eye Patch
The first time we meet Janine, she’s defiant. She’s loud. She uses "vulgar" language that Gilead's architects can't stomach. And then, the punishment happens—the removal of her right eye.
It was a brutal introduction to the stakes of the show.
💡 You might also like: Doomsday Castle TV Show: Why Brent Sr. and His Kids Actually Built That Fortress
Most actors would play that trauma as a straight line toward brokenness. Madeline Brewer did something much more interesting. She gave Janine a "childlike" veil, a psychological defense mechanism that wasn't just "going crazy"—it was a survival strategy. Honestly, seeing her name her baby Charlotte while the Putnams called her Angela was one of the most heartbreaking tug-of-wars in the entire series.
The Evolution of the "Damaged" Girl
By the time we hit the middle seasons, Janine shifted. She wasn't just the girl who lost her eye; she became the conscience of the Handmaids.
- The Colonies: While others were giving up, Janine was finding beauty in the dirt.
- The Bridge: Her suicide attempt wasn't just about despair; it was a radical reclamation of her own body.
- The Chicago Escape: Watching her and June navigate a war zone showed a Janine who was finally grounded, no longer floating in the clouds of her own mind.
Brewer has mentioned in interviews that as she aged—starting the show at 24 and finishing at 33—her own growth mirrored Janine’s. She told People that her "frontal lobe wasn't even cooked" when they started. You can see that maturing on screen. The flighty, erratic Janine of Season 1 is replaced by the "fierce friend" who eventually stares down Aunt Lydia with more authority than June ever could.
What Really Happened to Janine in the Season 6 Finale?
The final season was, frankly, a lot.
📖 Related: Don’t Forget Me Little Bessie: Why James Lee Burke’s New Novel Still Matters
Janine's story took a turn that many fans found hard to stomach: her placement at Jezebel’s. After all the growth, all the times she survived the impossible, seeing her forced into sex work felt like a slap in the face from the writers. But Madeline Brewer defended the choice, noting that it forced Janine to find community in the darkest hole Gilead had left.
There was a lot of talk about whether she’d die.
In the finale, which aired in May 2025, Janine doesn't get a "big bang" ending. She doesn't lead a bloody revolution with a machine gun. Instead, her ending is "quietly beautiful," as Brewer described it to The Cut. She stays behind. She chooses the women in Gilead over her own immediate escape, becoming a pillar for the ones who can't yet find their feet.
It’s a cyclical ending. She started as a victim and ended as a protector.
👉 See also: Donnalou Stevens Older Ladies: Why This Viral Anthem Still Hits Different
The Madeline Brewer and Ann Dowd Dynamic
We can't talk about Janine without talking about Aunt Lydia. It’s the most toxic, fascinating, and weirdly loving relationship on television.
Ann Dowd and Madeline Brewer have a chemistry that makes you feel dirty and moved at the same time. Lydia's "soft spot" for Janine was the only thing that humanized the villain for years. It’s probably why Janine’s eventual rejection of Lydia’s "protection" in the later seasons hurt so much more than any physical blow. Janine realized that Lydia’s love was a cage. Breaking out of that cage was Janine's real victory.
Life After Gilead: What’s Next for Madeline Brewer?
If you're missing Janine, you don't have to look far. Madeline has been busy.
She recently joined the cast of the final season of You on Netflix as Bronte, a playwright who gets tangled up with Joe Goldberg. It’s a complete 180 from Janine—no eye patch, no red cloak, just a free-spirited woman in Manhattan.
- Stage Work: She made a massive splash as Sally Bowles in the London production of Cabaret.
- Film: Keep an eye out for her in indie projects like Pruning and Space Oddity.
- Personal Life: She actually got married in July 2025 to cinematographer Jack Thompson-Roylance. Fun fact: her Handmaid's Tale co-stars Nina Kiri and Bahia Watson were her bridesmaids.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Actors
Janine’s character arc offers more than just entertainment; it’s a masterclass in character development and emotional resilience.
- Study the Nuance: If you're an aspiring actor, watch Brewer’s work in Season 4 and 5. Notice how she uses her physicality to show Janine’s "re-grounding." The way she stands changes.
- Community as Resistance: The show's legacy, according to Brewer, is that community is the only thing that stops individualistic despair. In your own life, finding your "inner circle" is the best defense against a world that feels like it's falling apart.
- Don't Look for the Loud Exit: Sometimes the most powerful way to end a story is to stay behind and help the next person. Janine taught us that survival isn't just about getting out; it's about what you do for those still inside.
If you're looking for a series to fill the void, checking out Brewer's earlier work in Orange Is the New Black is a great way to see the seeds of Janine's vulnerability being planted years before Gilead was ever a thing.