You know that feeling when you walk into a place and immediately realize you’re underdressed, but then someone greets you like a long-lost cousin and suddenly it doesn't matter? That's the vibe at Made in Italy. It’s sitting right there on West Venice Avenue. If you've spent any time in Venice, Florida, you know this stretch. It’s charming. It’s got those Mediterranean Revival buildings. But honestly, a lot of spots around here cater strictly to the "early bird special" crowd or people who think salt is a spicy seasoning.
Made in Italy restaurant Venice Florida is different.
It isn't just a name. It’s basically a manifesto. Owned by the Garafolo family—specifically Agostino and Giusy—the place has been a staple since around 2009. They didn't just move here and open a pasta shop; they brought a piece of their actual lives from Italy. You can feel it in the noise. It’s loud. It’s crowded. There is a giant wood-fired oven that looks like it was stolen from a Neapolitan street corner.
The Pizza Situation is Actually Serious
Most people think they know pizza. They don't. Or at least, they don't know the difference between a "pizza" and a Neapolitan pie that follows the Associazione Verace Pizza Napoletana (AVPN) kind of standards. At Made in Italy, the oven is the heart of the room. It hits temperatures that would make a normal stove melt, which is why your pizza comes out in about 90 seconds with those beautiful, charred "leopard spots" on the crust.
Don't send it back because it's burnt. It’s not burnt. It’s blistered.
The "Pizzaioli" here aren't just tossing dough for fun; they're working with high-hydration dough that’s been fermented properly. If you order the Margherita, you’re getting the basics done right: San Marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basil, and a drizzle of olive oil. It’s simple. It’s kinda perfect. Honestly, if a place can’t do a Margherita, you shouldn't trust them with anything else.
💡 You might also like: Why the Blue Jordan 13 Retro Still Dominates the Streets
But they do go beyond the basics. They’ve got the Salsiccia e Friarielli—that’s Italian sausage and rapini. It’s bitter. It’s fatty. It’s exactly what you’d eat in a back alley in Naples.
Beyond the Oven: The Pasta and the "Vibe"
If you aren't in the mood for pizza, the pasta is usually the move. But here is a tip: check the specials. While the regular menu has the hits—like a solid Lasagna or Penne alla Vodka—the kitchen really shines when they’re playing around with seasonal ingredients.
One thing that surprises people is the bar. It’s not just a service bar tucked in the back. It’s a full-on experience. They have a massive selection of Italian wines and Grappa. If you haven't had Grappa, be careful. It’s basically rocket fuel made from grape skins, but it’s the traditional way to end a meal. It’ll wake you up. Or put you to sleep.
The outdoor seating is where you want to be if the weather isn't doing that typical Florida "hundred degrees with 100% humidity" thing. Sitting on Venice Ave, watching people stroll by with their dogs while you dive into a plate of Fritto Misto (fried calamari and shrimp)? That’s the peak Venice experience.
Why Locals Keep Coming Back
Venice is a weird town. It’s got a lot of seasonal residents. Some restaurants survive just because they’re the only thing open in October. But Made in Italy stays packed year-round. Why?
📖 Related: Sleeping With Your Neighbor: Why It Is More Complicated Than You Think
- The Authenticity Factor: Agostino is often there. Giusy is often there. It’s family-run in a way that’s becoming rare in an era of corporate restaurant groups.
- The Martini Bar: They have a dedicated Martini bar area that gets pretty lively. It’s one of the few places in town that feels "cool" after 8:00 PM.
- The Bread: They make their own bread. It sounds like a small thing, but once you dip that warm, crusty bread into their olive oil and balsamic, you’ll get it.
Common Misconceptions About Made in Italy
People sometimes complain about the wait. Look, it’s a popular spot in a tourist town. If you show up at 6:30 PM on a Friday in February without a plan, you’re going to be waiting. That’s just physics.
Another thing is the noise. If you’re looking for a quiet, romantic spot where you can hear a pin drop, this probably isn’t it. It’s a bustling Italian eatery. There are plates clattering, people laughing, and the sound of the oven roaring. It’s energetic. It’s "Italian quiet," which is to say, not quiet at all.
Also, some folks expect "American-Italian" food. You know the stuff—pasta swimming in two quarts of heavy cream. You won't find that here. The sauces are lighter, more focused on the quality of the tomato and the olive oil. It’s authentic. It’s refined but rustic.
The Logistics: What You Need to Know
The restaurant is located at 117 W Venice Ave, Venice, FL 34285.
They don't always take reservations for small parties during peak season, so your best bet is to go early or be prepared to grab a drink at the bar while you wait. They’re open for lunch and dinner, and honestly, lunch is a bit of a "pro tip" move. You get the same quality food but without the frantic dinner rush.
👉 See also: At Home French Manicure: Why Yours Looks Cheap and How to Fix It
Parking on Venice Avenue can be a nightmare. Don't stress it. There’s usually parking a block or two over on Miami Ave or in the public lots behind the shops. A little walk is good for you anyway, especially after eating a pound of pasta.
Actionable Tips for Your Visit
- Try the Antipasto Misto: It’s a great way to sample the cured meats and cheeses they import. It’s basically a charcuterie board that actually knows what it's doing.
- Don't skip the dessert: Their Tiramisu is legit. It’s not that frozen, cakey stuff you get at the grocery store. It’s creamy, espresso-soaked, and dangerous.
- Check the hours: They sometimes have mid-day breaks or specific hours for the pizza oven versus the main kitchen. Always double-check their website or give them a quick call if you’re heading there at an odd time.
- The Martini Bar: If the main dining room is too packed, check if there’s a spot at the Martini bar. You can usually get the full menu there, and the service is fast.
Venice has a lot of dining options, from high-end steakhouses to little sandwich shops. But for a consistent, high-energy, actually-Italian experience, Made in Italy restaurant Venice Florida remains the benchmark. It’s the kind of place that reminds you why we go out to eat in the first place—to feel a little bit like we’ve traveled somewhere else without ever leaving the zip code.
Next time you're downtown, skip the tourist traps and head straight for the smell of burning oak and simmering tomatoes. You won't regret it. Just maybe leave the flip-flops at home if you're going for dinner. Or don't. It's Florida, after all.
When planning your trip, remember that the restaurant is closed on certain holidays, and during the "Snowbird" season (January through April), the wait times can exceed an hour during prime dining slots. Aim for a late lunch around 2:00 PM or an early dinner at 4:30 PM to beat the heaviest crowds. If you're a fan of live music, they occasionally have performers near the bar area, which adds another layer to the atmosphere. For the best experience, ask your server which wine pairs specifically with the region of Italy your dish originates from; the staff is generally well-trained on their cellar offerings.