George "Machine Gun" Kelly wasn't really a machine gun guy. Not at first. He was actually George Kelly Barnes, a college dropout from Memphis who spent most of his early twenties just trying to figure out how to stay out of the rain. He was a bootlegger. He sold illegal liquor. He was honestly more of a salesman than a "public enemy." But then he met Kathryn Thorne, and everything changed.
Kathryn was the marketing genius of the Great Depression crime world. She's the one who bought him his first Thompson submachine gun. She reportedly forced him to practice in the woods so he wouldn't look like an amateur. She even handed out spent shell casings to people in bars, telling them they were "souvenirs" from her husband's latest heist. She basically manifested his infamy into existence. By the time Machine Gun Kelly at Alcatraz became a reality, the man was more legend than muscle.
The Crime That Sent Him to The Rock
You can’t talk about Kelly’s time on the island without talking about why he was there. It wasn't for the bank robberies, though he did plenty of those in Texas and Mississippi. It was the kidnapping of Charles Urschel, an Oklahoma oil tycoon, in 1933.
It was a total mess.
They snatched Urschel from his porch during a bridge game. They wanted $200,000. They got the money, sure, but Urschel was smarter than they were. Even while blindfolded, he memorized the sounds of airplanes passing over the hideout and felt the wind patterns. He even left his fingerprints on every surface he could touch. The FBI—led by a young, hungry J. Edgar Hoover—used those clues to track the gang to a ranch in Texas.
📖 Related: Leonardo DiCaprio Met Gala: What Really Happened with His Secret Debut
When they finally cornered Kelly in Memphis on September 26, 1933, the legend says he shouted, "Don’t shoot, G-Men!" It’s a great story. It’s also probably fake. Most historians, including those at the FBI's own archives, suspect the phrase was a PR stunt to make the "G-Men" (Government Men) sound more intimidating.
Regardless of what he said, he was done. He got life. And in 1934, he was shipped off to the most feared prison in America: Alcatraz.
Life as Inmate 117
When he stepped off the boat at the San Francisco Bay, he wasn't George Barnes anymore. He was AZ-117.
Alcatraz was designed to break the spirits of the guys who thought they were untouchable. It was cold. The wind off the bay was brutal. But a weird thing happened to Kelly once he was behind those bars. He stopped being the terrifying gangster Kathryn had invented.
👉 See also: Mia Khalifa New Sex Research: Why Everyone Is Still Obsessed With Her 2014 Career
Why They Called Him Pop Gun Kelly
In the yard, the other inmates didn't look up to him. Not like they did with Al Capone or Alvin "Creepy" Karpis. To the real hard-cases, Kelly was a blowhard.
- He told "fish stories" constantly.
- He boasted about crimes he probably didn't even commit.
- He acted like a celebrity in a place where no one cared about your press clippings.
Because he was so harmless and obsessed with his own myth, the other prisoners started calling him "Pop Gun Kelly." It was a dig. It meant he was all noise and no power.
But here is the twist: he was actually a model prisoner. He didn't start fights. He didn't try to escape. He worked in the prison industries, mostly in the laundry and as a clerk. He was quiet. He followed the rules. To the guards, he was a dream. To the "public enemy" crowd, he was a letdown.
The Long Road Back to Leavenworth
Kelly spent 17 years on the island. That's a long time to stare at a city you can't reach.
✨ Don't miss: Is Randy Parton Still Alive? What Really Happened to Dolly’s Brother
He was finally transferred out of Alcatraz in 1951. Why? Because he wasn't a threat. He was an aging man with a bad heart. They sent him back to Leavenworth Federal Penitentiary in Kansas—the same place where he’d done time years earlier for bootlegging.
He died there on his 59th birthday, July 18, 1954. Heart failure.
It wasn't a blaze of glory. There were no Tommy guns or dramatic standoffs. He just faded away. He’s buried in Cottondale, Texas, under a headstone that says "George B. Kelley." Even his name on the grave is spelled differently than the one that made him famous.
Lessons from the Legend
So, what do we actually learn from the saga of Machine Gun Kelly at Alcatraz? Honestly, it’s a lesson in branding versus reality.
- Reputation is a double-edged sword. The "Machine Gun" persona made him a target for the FBI. Without it, he might have just been another small-time bootlegger who faded into the background.
- The FBI needed a win. J. Edgar Hoover used the Urschel kidnapping to prove that a federal police force was necessary. Kelly was the perfect villain for that narrative.
- Prison changes the narrative. The man who entered Alcatraz as a feared gangster left it as a "model prisoner" who told tall tales to anyone who would listen.
If you’re ever in San Francisco, you can still see the cell blocks. You can almost imagine him there, AZ-117, leaning against the bars and telling some kid from Chicago about the time he "ruled" the South. It’s a reminder that history is often written in the headlines, but the truth usually lives in the quiet years that follow.
If you want to understand the era better, look into the Lindbergh Law. It's the reason kidnapping became a federal crime, and it's the specific hammer that crushed Kelly's career. You could also check out the National Archives’ records on the Urschel case—the level of detail Charles Urschel provided while blindfolded is still used as a case study in witness observation today.