Art is usually a slow burn. You wait years for a biopic, decades for a history book, and maybe a century for a classic opera. But San Francisco just doesn't work like that. Not in 2025, and definitely not when the internet is involved.
Luigi the Musical San Francisco wasn't just a play; it was a chaotic, neon-lit collision of true crime, corporate rage, and pure camp. It basically happened overnight. One minute, people were tracking a manhunt on X (formerly Twitter); the next, they were lining up outside a tiny 49-seat black box theater to watch a singing version of the same guy.
The Most Controversial Ticket in Town
Honestly, the timing was wild. Usually, you don't write a musical about an active capital murder case before the trial even starts. But creators Nova Bradford and Arielle Johnson didn't wait. They saw the weird cultural moment where Luigi Mangione—the guy accused of shooting UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson—was being called a "folk hero" by people tired of insurance denials.
Then came the kicker: the news that Mangione was being held in the same Brooklyn prison as Sam Bankman-Fried (SBF) and Sean "Diddy" Combs. You can't write that. Or, well, they did.
✨ Don't miss: Cuba Gooding Jr OJ: Why the Performance Everyone Hated Was Actually Genius
The show premiered on June 13, 2025, at the Taylor Street Theatre. It sold out in minutes. It wasn't some high-budget Broadway spectacle. It was raw. It was queer. It was messy. And it was exactly what the San Francisco underground scene is known for.
Who was on stage?
- Jonny Stein played Luigi. He brought this weirdly endearing, "hunky" vulnerability to a character that the news usually portrays as a monster.
- Janeé Lucas stepped in as Diddy. Imagine a flamboyant music mogul trying to run a prison cell like a VIP lounge.
- Andre Margatini captured the jittery, "effective altruism" word-salad energy of SBF perfectly.
- Caleb Zeringue played the Guard, eventually joining the chaos in a campy dance duet.
Is it Satire or Just Exploitation?
This is where things get heated. If you ask the critics at the San Francisco Chronicle or the New York Times, you get two very different answers. Some panned it as "too soon" or "gross." They argued it was insensitive to the family of the victim.
But if you talk to the people who were actually in those seats? They felt something else.
🔗 Read more: Greatest Rock and Roll Singers of All Time: Why the Legends Still Own the Mic
The show featured a song about a McDonald's hash brown—a nod to where the real-world arrest happened. It sounds ridiculous, and it is. But underneath the jokes about prison food and "Dear Manifesto" ballads, the musical was asking a heavy question: Why did so many Americans root for a guy accused of murder?
The play didn't actually glorify the shooting. It poked fun at us. It looked at how we turn real, tragic events into viral memes and "thirst traps." Basically, it held a mirror up to our collective internet addiction.
Why Luigi the Musical San Francisco Still Matters
The run eventually moved to The Independent on Divisadero Street because the demand was just too high for a 49-seat room. Even with the controversy, the production managed to release a cast recording in August 2025.
💡 You might also like: Ted Nugent State of Shock: Why This 1979 Album Divides Fans Today
It’s easy to dismiss this as a "TikTok musical" or a gimmick. But look at the history of San Francisco theater. From the Cockettes to the Mime Troupe, this city has always used the stage to scream about what’s happening right now.
Luigi the Musical San Francisco succeeded because it didn't try to be polite. It took the three biggest villains (or heroes, depending on who you ask) of the 2024-2025 news cycle and threw them in a room to sing about justice and healthcare.
How to Engage with Independent Satire
If you missed the initial run, don't just wait for a Netflix special that might never come. Support the local creators who are actually making "dangerous" art.
- Follow the Creators: Nova Bradford and Arielle Johnson are still active in the SF queer comedy scene. Look for shows at the SF Eagle or the San Francisco Playhouse.
- Check for Tour Dates: There have been whispers of an Edinburgh Fringe Festival run or a national tour. Keep an eye on the official
luigithemusical.infosite for legitimate ticket links. - Listen to the Cast Recording: The songs "Dear Manifesto" and "Keys to my Heart" are available on most streaming platforms. It gives you a better sense of the tone than any news snippet can.
- Engage with Caution: Remember that while the musical is a satire, the real-life events are still moving through the court system. Separating the art from the ongoing legal tragedy is the key to understanding why this show exists in the first place.