If you spent your summer of 2024 glued to the screen watching Kaylor Martin sob over a seashell, you weren't alone. The saga of Kaylor and Aaron Evans was, quite frankly, the emotional rollercoaster of Love Island USA Season 6. It was messy. It was loud. It involved more tears than a Victorian novel.
But once the cameras stopped rolling in Fiji, the real drama actually started.
A lot of people think they just "didn't work out" because of distance or the usual post-villa fizzle. Honestly, it was way more explosive than that. Between bombshell revelations at the reunion and a very awkward TV comeback in 2025, the story of Love Island Kaylor and Aaron is a textbook case of what happens when "villa love" hits the cold, hard pavement of reality.
The Casa Amor Lie That Finally Broke Them
We have to talk about the reunion. It was the moment the "Kaylor and Aaron" ship didn't just sink—it imploded.
While they were in the villa, Aaron's behavior in Casa Amor was the main talking point. He told Kaylor he "explored a connection" with Daniela Ortiz Rivera, but he downplayed the physical side. He made it sound like a bit of flirting and a few kisses. Kaylor, bless her, wanted to believe him. She forgave him. They even made it official before being dumped just shy of the finale.
📖 Related: Isaiah Washington Movies and Shows: Why the Star Still Matters
Then came the New York City reunion.
Right there on the couch, in front of Ariana Madix and the world, Aaron finally dropped the truth bomb he’d been sitting on. He hadn't just "kissed" Daniela. He admitted to being much more intimate, specifically stating he had "put his hands down her pants."
Kaylor’s reaction wasn't just for TV. She was visibly vibrating with rage. She had spent the last three days in a hotel room with him in NYC, asking him point-blank if there was anything else she needed to know. He said no. Finding out on a stage instead of in private was the final nail.
"I cannot believe I wasted my entire summer on you," Kaylor shouted. "Take accountability and be a man."
👉 See also: Temuera Morrison as Boba Fett: Why Fans Are Still Divided Over the Daimyo of Tatooine
Life After the Villa: The 2025 Update
Fast forward to 2025, and things haven't exactly become "friendly." If you follow them on social media, you’ve seen the back-and-forth. For a while, Aaron actually had Kaylor blocked. He headed back to the UK, citing a need to focus on his mental health after the massive wave of public backlash he faced.
Kaylor, meanwhile, stayed in the States and started the long process of "finding her worth," a phrase she’s used a lot in her TikTok updates.
Love Island: Beyond the Villa
Interestingly, they couldn't stay away from each other forever—or at least, they couldn't stay away from the cameras. They both signed on for the spinoff Love Island: Beyond the Villa, which premiered in the summer of 2025.
Seeing them onscreen again was... uncomfortable. Kaylor admitted she still had feelings for him, which frustrated a lot of fans who wanted her to "stand on business." But it's human, right? You don't just switch off that kind of intensity because of a bad reunion segment. Aaron used the spinoff to apologize for the gaslighting and manipulation, and while they didn't get back together, they did reach a sort of shaky peace.
✨ Don't miss: Why Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy Actors Still Define the Modern Spy Thriller
Why Their Relationship Still Matters
Why are we still talking about Love Island Kaylor and Aaron in 2026? Because they represented a very specific, very toxic dynamic that resonates with anyone who has ever stayed in a relationship too long.
- The Power of the Bubble: In the villa, your partner is your entire world. Without phones or family, your "person" is your only support system. This is why Kaylor forgave things in Fiji that she never would have tolerated in Pennsylvania.
- The Role of Public Opinion: Aaron struggled hard with being the "villain." He mentioned on The Viall Files that the backlash affected his relationship because as soon as Kaylor started seeing what the public saw, she couldn't look at him the same way.
- The "Slow Burn" of Truth: Their breakup didn't happen because of one fight. It happened because the truth came out in drips. First the video from Casa, then the Movie Night clips, then the podcast reveals, then the reunion confession.
Where Are They Now?
As of early 2026, Kaylor has moved on. She’s been linked to Torin Dunn, and by all accounts, she seems much more stable and, well, less teary. She’s living that LA life, doing the influencer thing, and hanging out with her real villa soulmate, Liv Walker.
Aaron has mostly stayed out of the US spotlight since the spinoff. He pops up on British reality circles occasionally, but the "Kaylor and Aaron" era is officially in the rearview mirror.
Actionable Takeaways for Reality TV Fans
If you're still dissecting their relationship or looking for closure, here’s how to view the situation through a realistic lens:
- Don't ignore the "Re-watch" Factor: Many Islanders, including Kaylor, have said their feelings changed once they watched the episodes back. If you’re ever in a situation where your gut says something is off but your partner is "love-bombing" you, take a step back and look at the objective facts.
- Accountability is everything: The reason Kordell and Serena survived and Kaylor and Aaron didn't was accountability. Kordell owned his mistakes immediately. Aaron hid them until he was forced to speak.
- Distance is a reality check: It’s easy to be "in love" when you're 20 feet away from someone 24/7. When Aaron went to the UK and Kaylor went home, the lack of a foundation became glaringly obvious.
The story of Love Island Kaylor and Aaron serves as a permanent reminder that what happens in the villa rarely stays in the villa—especially when the truth eventually finds its way to the surface.
Next Steps to Stay Updated:
Follow Kaylor Martin’s official TikTok for her "life lately" vlogs, or check out the Love Island: Beyond the Villa archives on Peacock to see the full context of their 2025 reunion. Keeping an eye on the Season 6 cast's joint YouTube appearances is usually the best way to catch the unedited "tea" that doesn't make it into the 60-minute TV edits.